What kind of cast?

Re: What kind of cast?

kessler said:
i was told there billet

If they were billet they would cost $4k+ and could handle rediculous amounts of HP.

92 Ty 1173 said:
Anybody know exactly what kind of cast steel the stock crankshafts are? Need to know to get it treated.


A common crankshaft material is 4340, which is a medium carbon steel. I know the Eagle crank in my Sonoma is 4340 as well. I'm not sure if the cranks are cast or forged. Anyone else know?

Forging is much more expensive, but produces a much stronger part. Casting is cheaper, but gives large grain sizes with more voids and a higher percentage of unwanted inclusions.

A good treatment is Nitriding. It is a surface hardening technique that improves wear life, but allows the metal inside to remain somewhat ductle. If the whole part is hardened, it becomes brittle which is very bad for fracture toughness. You see there is always a trade off between hardness and ductility. You could make a part very hard and thereby resistant to wear, but it would be very brittle and crack easily. For example, a tungsten carbide wedding band. Very difficult to scratch one, but it will shatter if you drop it on a ceramic tile floor.

A lot of guys on here swear by cryogenic treating, but I'm still skeptical. It is hard to quantify the increase in material performance after taking it to a very high temperature. From the research I have done, it apparently converts the resigual austintic iron to martensite. This is normally achieved by rapidly quenching the part after heat treating it. While martensite is indeed the hardest form of iron, it is also brittle one of the most brittle.

I'm still learning about cryo-treatments, but I asked a couple of metallurgists their opinions and they were on the fence about using it for automotive applications.
 
Last edited:

ViciousV6

400HP/550FTLB
Re: What kind of cast?

well from what i hear alot of Race Teams (NHRA-NASCAR) use cyro treatment on alot of parts in order to make them last longer. My Machine Shop works directly with some NHRA Teams and they treat alot of parts with cyro treatment to help it hold up to the abuse it gets.

He reccomended to get my crank Cyro treated rather than nitrided.

Ralph
 

sy445

New member
Re: What kind of cast?

Nitrading is good for surface hardening and in most cases that is great for wear on surfaces such as gears, shafts and bearing surfaces. I cryoed my cast crankshaft knowing it is a double edged sword like stated above with it being stronger yet possibly more brittle. It is hardened all the way through rather than just the surface though. I believe that cryoing is better in a "CAST" crankshaft because it will cut down on the amount of flexing under load. The more something flexes its going to become weak and crack. Cryoing will cut down on the flexing. As long as the crank doesnt see big detonation croyed or not, the cryoing is a benefit Lets face it, most people with mods are pushing these cranks as it is. I have personally magnafluxed at least a dozen cast even fire v6 cranks and they are often cracked when abused.
 

92 Ty 1173

Active member
Re: What kind of cast?

Is 4340 correct for an OEM cast crank? That doesn't seem right to me. I was told by a reputable source on here that they were told that nitrided was the better. I don't know that there is a local source for cryoing for me. I have someone to nitride it, just need to know the grade.
 
Re: What kind of cast?

Broke out some of the ole' materials engineering notes... okay I'll admit they aren't that old. From a class I took last semester:

AISI #___Tensile Strength (MPa)__Yield Strength (MPa)__Ductility %EL in 50mm__Applications
1040__________605-780___________430-585______________33-19_________Crankshafts
_________________________________________________________________Bolts
4340_________980-1960__________895-1570______________21-11_________Bushings
_________________________________________________________________Aircraft Tubing
6150_________815-2170__________745-1860______________22-7__________Shafts
_________________________________________________________________Gears


I'm not sure what the General was using back then, but I would guess 1040. Not sure how you would find out the specific alloy though.
 
Top