EGR Chip Mod

sytyguy

Moderated User
Okay....here's a quick rundown of what I did for better gas mileage via EGR in the chip. I hope to write a more detailed "how-to" in the near future.

I had spoken with BG sometime ago on this subject, and we spoke about how almost anyone who tried to get better gas mileage via F29 or F30 would run into problems with fueling transition from this lean cruise spot to other places (accel, decel, stabbing it, etc...). My truck (back when I used to lean out F29) would have a bad stumble on the freeway when you'd accelerate out of this cruise condition.

The cure? Use the EGR tables to pinpoint the area you want to address fueling at and keep the VE tables the same (for the most part). Obviously, this requires a truck to have the EGR blocked off, but from there, just enable EGR at whatever temp you'd like via 0x06CD (KEGRTEM1). I set mine to enable only in fully warmed up conditions since all other extraneous fueling factors (coolant temp dependent tables, etc....) would be out of the equation.

Once enabled, there are 3 main tables to concentrate on......the first:

F4 - 0x02FF - EGR Spark Advance vs %EGR..........this table adds in timing to the total timing advance during whatever condition (in this case %EGR). For the most part, my truck responded best to a max of 2-3 degrees advance with timing tapering off as the % decreased (affected by F72....just a minute ;-)). Remember this table only adds advance when the EGR is enabled, so it's a non factor as soon as you exceed the EGR enable criteria.

next........

F72 - 0x06E5 - Desired EGR % vs Vac & RPM.........this table controls the amount of EGR "emphasis". Basically, it has control over F4 and F28 and when and how much desired EGR is allowed dependent on Vac & RPM. Obviously, cruise conditions are between 1600 and 2400 and 10-20" vac for most trucks, so that's where I put emphasis. I found that if you have too much desired EGR at too low a vac reading (10" to 0), that you could still run into some stumbling issues. For my truck, this range (10" to 0) was a point of accel and a lot of EGR was not needed (none in my case), so I had the desired EGR taper off towards this range (as well as my timing in F4 and my "lean-ness" in F28). Another thing I noticed is that this table doesn't quite match actual real world vac readings. Might just be my truck/gauge, but you may run into this also.......15 in the table was actually closer to 10 real world for me IIRC. I didn't really go too high (1-12%) on the desired EGR in this table either, since the range I was tuning for is so small (1600-2400 and 10-20" vac). It also has a huge effect on F28, which I'll get to in just a second. I can go into further detail about this table, but that's it's immediate and most noticeable affect.

lastly........

F28 - 0x040E - Base Pulse Constant vs Desired EGR..............this table is a direct fueling multiplier based on desired EGR %. This value needs to be numerically lower when EGR is commanded. I tested the limits of this and lets just say that you can render the truck useless if not careful here (you can go WAY lean).....so use baby steps here. I started off by dropping each value from 1-12.8 (see desired EGR % in F72 - above) about .002 points (from 89 to 87) and testing. Basically, I'd get to freeway speeds and with wideband and Datamaster handy, I'd see which desired EGR % (vac dependent via F72) was where I wanted the fueling to be, then go back and adjust from there. *BTW, using the Romulator while doing this is incredible!*. Where did I wind up? Well my truck would have a bit of a stumble coming out of EGR command (accel), so I added some fuel to the 1.6 value of F28 to help the transition. Didn't take much to make all the difference. As far as how lean to go.....that will ultimately lie with your build and comfortability. I went from .091 to .077 from 1.6 to 12.8 (.002 increments stepped accordingly) on my chip. This table can be gone into with further detail later as well, but that's it's main function. Remember, this table DIRECTLY affects your fueling, so watch your O2 and check your plugs!


My truck really likes it this way. With the timing tapering off towards lower desired EGR %, I have no stumble during transition and regularly see around 20-22 mpg (up from 17-19) at freeway speeds when driven "sensibly". Obviously YMMV, and your tune may not take to this mod as well as mine did, but it's a worthwhile test anyways. FWIW, here are my mods (that affect this test):

- 412 cam
- open exhaust
- 50# injectors

This experiment was a result of this - http://www.syty.net/phpBB2/viewtopic.php?t=25005&highlight=f28

Oh yeah.........don't forget to disable Code 32. :)

If I missed something or left something unanswered, please slap me with a reply. :)

Hood
 
Last edited:

Sy769

Donating Member
Good post. 8) We should make threads like this stickies in the tuning section so they don't get lost in all the garbage.



Any chance you'll share that bin so I can have a look to go with what you typed? :D
 

BillC

New member
Great post! Sounds like a great idea (both you and BG).
Sy769 said:
Any chance you'll share that bin so I can have a look to go with what you typed?
Or at least, please post those three tables into this thread (the "Export Selected" function under the "Tools" menu in Promgrammer might be helpful). Thanks!
 

smeagol

Active member
I'm glad this idea worked well. It was another one of my '... never had time to try this....' thoughts.

Anyways, anyone with stock injectors that wants to try this, you'd have to determine the % change of the BPC and apply it to the stock injector BPC value, then use the same EGR cal info as Mike has determined.

These running conditions MAY create hot EGT's and such. Catalytic converter damage is possible ! Playing with timing may also help/hurt with this tuning... and there is an EGR specific timing table that could be used.
 

sytyguy

Moderated User
Touching a little more on what BG mentioned........you will need to monitor your AFR and EGTs heavily when modifying F28 (esp. those of you running a catalytic converter). I don't have this issue and as long as the numbers were within reason and I wasn't ruining plugs, I let it fly. I'm working with this mod on a buddy's Typhoon as well, so I'll have some stock injector input (for F28) here soon.

FWIW, I tried to tune EGR in the upper rpm and lower vac areas (part throttle accel, going thru the gears, etc...), but the fueling was too erratic........always hitting a rich/lean spot and felt like driving a truck with an intermittent injector problem. Wasn't worth it IMO, so I concentrated on the higher vac/lower rpm regions.

BTW, for anyone looking to modify these tables (and this applies to all tables and aspects of tuning), I encourage you to not make nice "pretty" tables (like I initially tried to do), but rather to do what your truck wants. Making tables that "look" good don't always work well.

Hood
 
Last edited:

smeagol

Active member
sytyguy said:
BTW, for anyone looking to modify these tables (and this applies to all tables and aspects of tuning), I encourage you to not make nice "pretty" tables (like I initially tried to do), but rather to do what your truck wants. Making tables that "look" good don't always work well.

Hood

Excellent point.
 

SBNova

New member
Re: EGR Chip Mod

Thanks to all for pointing me to this thread- its very interesting. I do have one question though, why must the EGR be blocked off to use it? I understand the EGR function and theory. Is it that this mod commands EGR at an inappropriate time? I thought the EGR was commanded at high vaccum/low load moderate engine speeds.
 

sytyguy

Moderated User
Re: EGR Chip Mod

This mod emulates EGR operation w/o actually having an EGR system physically on the engine. Basically, you're tricking the computer into thinking EGR is still there so that it'll command fueling/timing tables under these specific conditions. This gives you absolute control over "highway mode" without having the EGR valve physically mess up the formula.

There would be a level of control even with EGR in place, but you lose clarity and consistency due to a mechanical valve being added as another variable in an already cluttered equation.

The initial goal was to give access to tables that would be otherwise unused (in setups w/o EGR) and use them to alter fueling/timing at cruise w/o hacking up the VE tables. It works beautifully if you put in the seat/laptop time, but I must warn that it's quite easy to run too lean, so MAKE SURE you have a WBO2 (and EGT if possible) before monkeying with these tables.

My truck will run @ 15.0-15.5 AFR at cruise at any mph above 60, and yet, there are no hiccups, dead spots, or transitional degradation when applying throttle out of this area (20"-5" vac and 1600-2600 rpm). Watch the WBO2 and the AFR just gradually richens up as you increase throttle. I have a ton of time in getting it to this point, but it was well worth the effort for me.

Hood
 

SBNova

New member
Re: EGR Chip Mod

Sorry to keep digging this up. I think its prime time for this type of tuning with gas prices climbing though. My Ty just got 13mpg around town. My 71 Nova +/- 400hp 355ci with a 750 double pumper Holley gets 15-17mpg with a 3500 stall and 2004r OD tranny. My Ty mileage SUCKS. I do need to change the wires on the Ty- thats the only "tune up" part I havent gotten for it yet. I also have a very slight stumble that seems to happen only at cruise, like an occasional miss. I logged a short run today noting the EGR function and it happens primarily when the EGR is open/working. I think I'm gonna take it apart and clean it all out. I dont have any codes stored. I did take the TB off today and clean it really good- got all the carbon off it and out of the IAC passages. My IAC counts have since dropped signifigantly at the same idle speed, but the truck idles the same. Anyway- on to my question....

So when the BPC vs EGR (F 28) is changed won't the ECM correct it if it finds that its leaner than stoich?

I just loaded a bin into my autoprom making some changes as you've outlined. I went very mild. I changed F 28 by .0089 ( down to .0800 from .0889) in the areas you noted and I only added a max of 2 degrees tapering quickly to 1 degree then to 0. I dont think I will have time to log it tonight but I am eager to try it out.

Another thing, in my desired EGR % vs Vac and RPM I have RPM labeled from 800 at the bottom up to 5200 on the left, but the column tops are not labeled, they all just say "%" "%" "%" "%" accross the top.

What XDF are you using, or how do I fix my table? Ive got 58_2&3bar.xdf
 

sytyguy

Moderated User
Re: EGR Chip Mod

Be careful with F28....this is a direct fueling multiplier (or the closest thing we have @ the moment) that acts as not only a lookup for EGR use, but the rest of the chip cal as well. A tenth of a value decrease could be too much under certain circumstances. You're headed in the right direction, but remember that the biggest gains with these changes are done under open loop. Closed loop adjustments will often be masked/negated due to the ECM self-correcting. F28 will affect fueling regardless of what "-loop" your running, but feedback from the O2 could cause the ecm to compensate when you don't want it to under CL.

Another point, make sure that you're getting pretty decent economy beforehand. While these changes can be a big help to fuel economy, they won't fix an existing problem and could possibly exploit it even more. Do whatever is necessary to get your truck healthy first (tune up, fuel filter changes often, correct FP for your cal, etc...) before jumping into this mod. My advice, use closed loop to get you close fueling-wise (get the BLMs happy at cruise/idle), then switch to open loop, and (using a WB if possible) start in on these maps if necessary.

As far as F72, my changes were done with Promgrammer, not Tunerpro, so I'm not sure if theres an issue there or not. I'll check tomorrow.

Hood
 

SBNova

New member
Re: EGR Chip Mod

I logged some today with the changes I made. It was a cool morning and the truck actually drove better than usual during warmup. Ive had the WB on the truck before and it showed nearly idntical AF ratios as the commanded ratio. Usually spot on, but no more than .1-.2 off, except under WOT where I am lean at 13.5 (gonna get a new pump- pressure is good at idle, dont currently have a way to check it under WOT but thats another story).

I noticed that even by adding 1-2 degrees of timing while egr is enabled I am still only running 24-28 degrees at cruise, 50-70 kpa, at 1600-1700 rpm. My "spark adv. vs RPM vs Map 2-bar" says I should be at 32 or so. How come I am not seeing full advance? The only hiderance I can see is the "spark adv adj vs manifold temp" which has some odd "-4.92" timing corrections sporadicly placed. I compared a few bins and its the same with all of them. Even that doesnt account for my missing 8 degrees though. Any ideas where I am losing timing at? Oh yeah, there are no knock counts or knock retard happening here either.

Another Q, on "EGR spark advance vs %EGR" (F4) I see timing adjustments up to 19.2% EGR, but reviewing my scans I can only view EGR duty cycle, which has been running 50-70% at 1700 RPM at 50-70 kpa. Either I cant scan the correct field or my values are way too high. Is duty cycle the same as %EGR in F4?

Oh yeah, on F28 I only reduced the BPC by 8 thousandths, where you noted you changed it much more.

Thanks alot for all the help.
 

sytyguy

Moderated User
Re: EGR Chip Mod

Just for dialing in cruise/part throttle fueling, try zeroing out the extraneous timing tables that might reduce the clarity in your particular testing range (ie 2000-2500 rpm, 50-80 kpa, etc...). This should remove any adders or detractors from the timing equation and give you a more accurate reading of timing. Kind of a moot point really, because if you add timing back into the these tables, the clarity will, again, go out the window. But, just for the sake of testing, try zeroing out in that range in the Boost Spark Advance Correction vs MAT vs Boost table and Coolant Temp Compensation vs MAP table.

You never did say, are you tuning in OL or CL?

Hood
 

SBNova

New member
Re: EGR Chip Mod

Closed loop, when the ECM commands it. Its almost always "closed". I did notice that under "flags" I see a field that says "learn control" and Ive never seen it say "enabled" its always "disabled". Even when scanned with the stock chip I cant recall seeing it enabled. I am modifying a BBZB bin now. I am driving and logging with a light foot, as I would if I were trying to achieve decent mileage. Im trying to stay away from any boost so I dont get any multipliers involved.
 

JSM

Active member
Re: EGR Chip Mod

I always like to tune in open loop and wideband. It is amazing how much your eyes will open up with wideband.

Closed loop can cover a lot of sins you won't see unless in open loop. Tune in open, then set for closed when your done. IMO
 

sytyguy

Moderated User
Re: EGR Chip Mod

There will still be a lot of multipliers/variables when in vacuum, so don't think that not being in PE or boost saves you from that. Like I said above, stick to OL for fine tuning and clean up some tables that might cloud what's really happening. You'll need those tables later, but for the time being, it could help you see the magnitude of your changes.

Hood
 

SBNova

New member
Re: EGR Chip Mod

I'll give it a shot. I changed the timing table some earlier "spark adv. vs RPM vs Map 2 bar", by advancing the timing in the 1400-2000 rpm 50-80 kpa cells. Most of them I upped by just over 1 degree, and tried to keep it somewhat "smooth" with no large gaps between cells.

I had somewhere to be this afternoon, so this is the bin I drove on for a 40+ mile round trip. Ive got to say it drives better. My little miss or sputter at lower RPM cruise (when EGR kicks in) is virtually non-existant. It could be just coincidence I guess, but it feels better too. I still havent cleaned out the EGR yet like I planned so thats not what made the change. I'll probably get to that Thursday.

My wideband is at a friends house right now so I cant get a current reading. I will give open loop a shot when I get the WB back. So far I am pleased though. I doubt I will pick up much if any mileage from this but every little bit helps. At least it feels better and drives smoother.
 
Top