is this a clogged cat?

ed hess

race or get outta the way
vac line to egr solenoid was plugged when he left here. so egr is in the closed position. did this because the egr solenoid didnt hold vacuum.
 

smeagol

Active member
FWIW, you can still have a bad EGR valve, and it not being actuated.

Not saying that it's a culprit here though.

It sounds like an on and off problem, as in it wasn't there one day, and then it was the next. A clogged cat wouldn't show up like this IMO.

I'd try a different computer, different chip, check the grounds & harness around the engine. It sounds like you have covered the obvious stuff, now it's time to do the PITA work.
 

ed hess

race or get outta the way
fwiw .

he did say it has been getting progressivley worse during the past few weeks. So your opinon of it not being there one day and then it is the next is accurate. It has been progressing, albeit quickly, a few weeks worth.
 

Jimmy

Banned
Did you check out the 02's on DM? I was thinking that if the cat is clogged that it would be running pig rich,which could cause it to knock and make the ecm pull timing/boost.
 

69gtojeff

Member
If you want to verify a clogged cat, check the exhaust backpressure. Do some blacksmith work on a junk O2 sensor to enable a pressure guage to connect to the down pipe. Your truck won't mind running with the O2 sensor disconnected if this is really the problem. I use a 1/4" hose barb connected to a mechanical fuel pump gauge that I duct tape to the windshield. Pretty complicated experimental setup. My ty registered 3 psi backing out of the driveway and pegged the gauge (10 psi) before even registering boost. I "fixed" the cat, and now it runs like it should. Pulsing sounds like an unrelated symptom. Diacom showed tons of knock when the converter was clogged, nothing was audible.
 

ghettosled

SYTY SUPERSTORE
to check for a bad cat, take a temp reading with an infared gun b4 and after the cat. If there is a large jump in temp, you have a clogged cat.

I think it is ignition. Doesnt matter if you changed the plugs and wires yesterday. Especially if it is gradually getting worse.
 

Mad Mike

SYCOSIS
The problem before and after cap,rotor, plugs and wires is exactly the same. Could it be the iginition module? It accerlates and drives fine as long as no boost is added. Alos, the exhaust characteristics in park at idle is a pulsating kinda miss sound. Not regular but a random kinda miss.
 
B

Blake

Guest
That pulsing kinda miss sound is normal for the most part(never heard a stock one that didn't do it). If it is getting worse under boost conditions it goes back to the fuel/spark deal. Really need to do a fuel pressure while driving check. Will help rule out a bunch of things. Just removing the cat will cause overboost with a stock wastegate. I had a nice blue arc going from a plug boot to one of my intercooler coolant hoses. Didn't show a miss and the tach never bounced. No knock. Just had less than expected power. Ignition setup on these things suck. I wish these guys that made the direct fire system would come out of the closet and tell how it went and how to do it(soapbox off real quick). If the needle fluctuates on the vac gauge, it also could indicate an ignition miss. The setup in the GM manual for checking for exhaust restriction has been proven time and time again that it does not work. Cheapest deal is to remove the cat or put in a straight pipe and see how it does. If it improves, you may want to go with a 3 inch cat later on. The bad thing on these trucks (as I unfortunately have discovered) that it is NEVER a case of just one thing being wrong. It is always a damn combination of things as they are getting older.
 

Mad Mike

SYCOSIS
To add to my symptoms I got a code 45 rich O2 sensor. So, I am leaning toward a clogged cat. Question. Will a poorly running truck due to igintion problems also cause this code?
 

Mad Mike

SYCOSIS
I finally figured out my problem today. Not sure which it was but I was getting multiple codes now. O2 sensor rich, O2 sensor lean, ecm Error, speed sensor code etc. Then I remembered this happened before. I replaced the the pink and white wires going from the coil to the distributor but also re-spliced the wires coming from the coil to the main harness as I had replaced those a couple years ago and the connections did not look all that great. Now, I still get 3-4 degrees of knock and full boost buts that's because my intercooler pump is not working. I do not hear any audible knock and do not get any knock until about 10 psi of boost. I feel it's fixed. Nice steady idle, much less pulsating exhaust and no codes. I hope the knock will completely dissappear with a new intercooler pump.
 
B

Blake

Guest
I can read your post. Hmmm. See? The gurus came through again. Ignition.
I hate our ignition on these trucks. Did I mention I don't like our ignition? Thanks goodness you found out your problem. Nothing makes ownership worse than having a problem and not knowing what it is.
Thanks for getting back with the solution. Seems lots of these threads die off and people fix it. Then add no knowledge to the database as far as what they did to remedy the problem.
Thanks,
Blake
 

Mad Mike

SYCOSIS
Blake said:
I can read your post. Hmmm. See? The gurus came through again. Ignition.

Sure, they said igintion but not those wires. I thought igintion the whole time too but I know I bought qualtiy parts and installed them properly, diacom wasn't really helping so it was really throwing me off. I have two trucks and know what and what not to do as far as tuning but this was really stumping me. I changed the cap/rotor, plugs twice, new plug wires, check timing twice, complete vacuum line check, egr, coil, ecm swapped and was just about to remove the exhaust to check for a clogged cat. Just glad I had all those odd codes pop up and jarred my memory about those wires. The last time I replaced them I also had tach flutter but not this time. I think others with similar problems need to replace 'em. They are cheap and obviously a weak point. Now, for the intercooler pump. Who sells the jabsco?
 
B

Blake

Guest
There's a primary and secondary ignition. Primary consists of the coil, the wire going between the coil and the ignition module, and the ignition module, and the pickup coil. Secondary is the Cap, plug wires, rotor button and spark plugs. Any fault in any part of the ignition will cause problems. Right now, my pickup coil is shot. My timing bounces around, the truck stumbles and bogs, etc. I have an ignition problem. Just on the Primary end. The only thing is that if have problems in the future and you can think of something that you have worked on or spliced, check it first. Like I said, I hate the ignitions on these things.
Ron Gregory is the guy to get ahold of for Jabsco. I've bought a couple Walbro fuel pumps from him years ago and transaction was flawless. Highly recommend. He has been around since the inception of SyTy online period. So he is a very dependable person. No fly by night kinda stuff with Ron.
Take care,
Blake
 

ed hess

race or get outta the way
hey mike
canyou buy just the wire that goes between the coil and the ignition module? Part number? Napa? :)

Glad its fixed.

ed
 
Top