Re: Nissan 240sx swap - please help
Edub said:
I checked out thirdgen, there is a lot of good info. I am familiar with programming EPROMs but I am still a bit confused on memcal selection and why this is important. As for the bin, I was told to use one from a turbo Sunbird because of the way it deals with the turbo. In one ECU swap article the guy mentioned keeping his stock memcal but using the Sunbird bin on his V8. So, you can mix and match bins and memcals? Would I be better off finding something with a closer displacement - would it be set up for boost? My car is actually an SOHC. I guess I'm just not understanding what this whole memcal business is all about. My current ECU just has an EPROM.
As for injectors, is there not an equation that can be modified accordingly?
I know you guys hate all these nooby questions - sorry.
The MEMCAL itself is hardware. It sorta defines the base physical characteristics of the motor- how many cyls it has, how big the cyls are, how the motor "sounds" to a knock sensor. There is also a rudimentary approximation of injector size, for "limp home" mode.
The limp home fueling generally gets ignored, we run 84# injectors on a MEMCAL set for 30s.
The software part of the deal is what's burned into the EPROM that also happens to be on the MEMCAL.
There's some confusion out there regarding MEMCALs, since GM used to use 2 separate pieces, a PROM and a CALPAK (which sometimes gets incorrectly referred to as a MEMCAL).
Even more confusion exists, because GM used both types simultaneously. There's really No hard year cutoff where they quit using the one and started the other. After '94, pretty much everything went to flash PCMs due to federal OBDII requirements.
The long and the short of it is that there are many possibilites out there for MEMCALs, and you can generally program any software image onto them.
An example-
The $58 Mask ID (Program ID) code that runs in the SyTy ran in a 1222749 ECM, with a MEMCAL specific to a 4.3L, 6cyl motor. You can run the same code with a MEMCAL for a 4-cyl (as it did in the Sunbird app), or a V8 MEMCAL from an F-body car that ran in a different ECM model. (a 1222730)
The '730, '749, and '727 (an underhood-hardened version of the '730) are all very close cousins from a hardware standpoint. Most code that ran in any of the above ECMs will run in any of the others.
Ludis' web page is pretty much the Mecca of the GM ECM info world. He's got a pretty complete breakdown of what was used where, and with what motor:
http://www.cruzers.com/~ludis/p4xref.html
If your car is a SOHC motor, a late Sunbird MEMCAL would be a good choice. It doesn't really have anything to do with the turbo, but a SOHC motor sounds different to a knock sensor than a DOHC, or a pushrod motor. GM tuned these specifically to the acoustic signature of the motor they were to be used on, so you're not gonna ever get an exact match, but you should be able to find something that's close enough.
Later,