50# Q for BG

BigAl...

Member
hey Brian,

I read on one of your pages that you had gotten the external WG to work with the stock solenoid. when you finish the 50# ultimate will you have an option for external WG?

P.S. is the 50#er gonna have the 3 different timing levels and the different boost settings like the current ultimate?

P.S.S. WHEN? WHEN? WHEN? WHEN?

TIA
BigAl...
 

smeagol

Active member
The external thing would just throw another variable in the mix, and you'd have pretty damn good control with a regulator setup on an external. So probably not.

Not sure of anything on the 50s. Testing is always being held up. I don't have tons of time, I can't keep everyone's truck running, and weather and such... ick.

BG
 

BigAl...

Member
hey Bri what do you mean by "and you'd have pretty damn good control with a regulator setup on an external" are you talking about the simple bleed valve like you would get at Grainger or any hardware store?

TIA
BigAl...
 

smeagol

Active member
I mean that an external wastegate is usually setup with dual ports, and once you have it configured using the dual ports, with a good base boost level, and an air compressor regulator (very cheap setup) the control is usually very good.

Brian G
 
HI ALL
BRIAN, I FOUND MYSELF INTRIGUED BY THE TOP O' THIS PAGE - I HAVRE BEEN WANTING TO RUN BOOST CONTROL OEM STYLE (YOUR 10-1 LED) BUT WITH THE TYPICAL ATR/KB ETC EXTERNAL WASTEGATES - WHY IN HELL CANT THE SOLENOID JUST FEED THE WG PORT, RATHER THEN OFF A GIVEN EXTERNAL BLEEDER VALVE? - I BEEN WANTIN TO UPGRADE TURBO, BUT DIDNT WANNA LOSE BOOST CONTROL FROM INSIDE.
YOUR THOUGHTS?
SEEMS IT SHOULD WORK FINE.
TALK WITH JIM BELL - HE DUNNO, ATR DUNNO EITHER.
THANKS
 

smeagol

Active member
Well it all depends on the way you hook things up. The external wastegates *should* be hooked up in dual port mode, just works best in that configuration. Done that way, with the stock solenoid in the system, it works, just need very custom programming, as the duty cycle versus boost response is backwards from stock. Stock, open solenoid, 0% duty cycle is base boost. With external, open solenoid, 0% duty cycle is max boost. Not a huge issue, but the base boost on every person's external wastegate is gonna differ, and that requires more boost table calibration. Too much time, money etc. I can't even get a damn 50# chip done.

I had my Typhoon setup in open loop boost mode, a set wastegate duty cycle operating the external wastegate. I made several programs of varying duty cycle, and settled on one that gave me good results.

BG
 

BigAl...

Member
Got it BG,

come up with a price for the ext WG programing, alot of us want to keep the ability to control boost with the ultim8. If I can afford it I will definitly do it, I would just need you to tell me what to set my base at and as long as I follow the rules everything should workout.

TIA
BigAl...
 

0966Sy

Code what?
Hey Brian'

I was planning on mounting a Turbonetics Racegate on my crossover pipe soon in january. I just recently bought your chip from mike lee at a&r, Would i run into problems with using a external wastegate with your chip? I want solid boost, would this workout with your chip or is your chip "ment to be" ran with the stock integral wastegate and solinoid.

Appreciate your info brian'
Erik
 

smeagol

Active member
I just recently bought your chip from mike lee at a&r, Would i run into problems with using a external wastegate with your chip?

Well it all depends on the way you hook things up. The external wastegates *should* be hooked up in dual port mode, just works best in that configuration. Done that way, with the stock solenoid in the system, it works, just need very custom programming, as the duty cycle versus boost response is backwards from stock. Stock, open solenoid, 0% duty cycle is base boost. With external, open solenoid, 0% duty cycle is max boost. Not a huge issue, but the base boost on every person's external wastegate is gonna differ, and that requires more boost table calibration. Too much time, money etc. I can't even get a damn 50# chip done.

I can't spend the time on custom programming for these modifications, as I have too much going on. If someone wants to get into the custom programming for this stuff, I can help out a bit. So, Erik, unless you have custom programming, you will run into issues. I can't even guarantee good results using the stock setup with an external, as I haven't FULLY tested it myself. I do know that you can spend $30 on a regulator & vacuum lines, route the regulator in cab, and have good control from there.

BG
 

0966Sy

Code what?
BG'

There are control knobs that allow you to increase or decrease boost with the External turbonetics gates. If i used the stock gate with your method you mentiod with a bleeder valve it would be the same as using the external with a control knob, as long as the gate was set at a desired level around the level of boost you where to run on your programs on your chip. I dont see where you would run into any problems with using a control knob with the external that you would with a bleeder valve in the cab with the stock gate.

Im simply getting cunfused as of why this wouldnt work well with an external, or even if the stock gate would hold better performance with your chip then the external would w/ a control knob?

I learn new issues every day'
Erik
 

smeagol

Active member
Egads.. you haven't been paying attention.

The external can dump a LOT more exhaust than the stocker, and can do it much faster. You can also change the base boost of an external gate, which is important because the farther off your desired boost is from your base, the worse the boost control. Stock base boost is 8-10psi, as soon as you want to run 15-20, you will run into problems.

Integral wastegates *can* work well, they just do NOT work well in the Syty application. Externals are pretty easy to make work, provided you work within their operating range, and have adequate flow.

The Turbonetics piece is just an air compressor regulator, like you can buy at Sears etc.

BG
 

0966Sy

Code what?
brian,

Ok, Im getting your point now, but am still somewhat confused. So what can i do with an Integral to get solid boost performance. Do i need to tight'n the spring or just leave it at factory spec. I know mine is way over factory spec. Can i get an upgraded integral, Did you go 11.05 with the stock gate? What Chip? the Ultimate?

Thanks for your time brian'
Erik

<font size=-1>[ This Message was edited by: Erik on 2001-12-15 17:39 ]</font>
 

bdubb

I am teh kingpin!
he went 11.05 with an HKS external wastegate, the same one i have on my syclone right now.
 
Top