Burning Oil, Good Compression

berzerker

wookie
Re: Burning Oil, Good Compression

sucks to do all that work . but new valve guides and stem seals will fix you right up !!
 

tbauer03

TRBOBOX
Re: Burning Oil, Good Compression

I took the head down to a nearby machine shop. They pulled the valves apart and said the valve guides and valves were worn like a car that had 100K miles on them but didn't think they were worn enough to cause the amount of oil consumption that I have been seeing. The motor has around 10k-15k miles on it.
They thought the premature wear might have come from improper geometry but felt strongly that I should pull the motor and have it inspected and freshened up. Most likely they believe the ring lands are damaged from either running lean or detonation.
I wouldn't mind pulling it for piece of mind and taking the opportunity to swap out the ECM and original wiring for a Holley EFI system.
But let me know your thoughts, I always value more opinions.
 

Quickstop [UK]

Combating adversyty.
Re: Burning Oil, Good Compression

Compare the other heads. Presumably the same valve geometry. If that is the case, both heads should have issues. Check the valve geometry first.

Are the rings damaged? Any flakes in the oil? You had good compression. Going through an engine for "peace of mind" is expensive. If it had good compression then I say get the head redone, check geometry and run it again. Holley ECU is unrelated to your issue.
 

tbauer03

TRBOBOX
Re: Burning Oil, Good Compression

Motor is toast. I had a second shop tear it down and like the first shop they said the motor looked like there was over 100k on the motor. There was a lot of metal floating around, it beat out the bearings, pistons, crank shaft, etc etc. So I have a complete rebuild coming soon. The block might be salvageable going 40 over.

This all stemmed from the first shop in 2005, not putting an oil galley plug in and it fired with very little pressure. They supposedly rebuilt the motor but damage was already done. Anyway I cant change the past but I am going to rebuild it similar to what i had before a setup that is capable of a 11 second run.

2015_11_12_10_16_56.jpg

2015_11_12_10_17_05.jpg

2015_11_12_10_17_59.jpg
 

tbauer03

TRBOBOX
Re: Burning Oil, Good Compression

The rods should be reusable and the heads just need reworked and hopefully the block but yeah everything else is Likely junk.Have many gone 40 over with the block?
 

tbauer03

TRBOBOX
Re: Burning Oil, Good Compression

Ted:
Your cranking pressures are high for a SyTy. So your static compression was a little higher than stock, and more susceptible to detonation. I don't know what your tune was, and how much attention there was to detonation, mixture, and timing, but that is all classic detonation damage. The 4 plugs that aren't oiled look pretty good. That kind of main bearing damage comes from detonation. The build-up on the valves looks like aluminum. Again from detonation.

Look at the top ring in the pic of the piston. There's a section of moly missing from between the rails. I've never seen that before, but I'd surmise again, detonation beat the crap out of the ring. The top ring also looks stuck in the groove. The second ring looks normal. The missing moly, and if it's stuck in the groove, there's your oil consumption.

It doesn't help to run an engine with low oil pressure, but the bearing damage shown is very common in SyTy. Even a running stock SyTy usually has worn the center main bearings to the copper by 75-100K miles. Even in a stock truck, the power outputs from 15psi of boost pounds the cranks and bearings that were engineered for much lower power outputs from N/A engines. Severe bearing wear is part of the SyTy deal. Detonation just wears the bearings to the copper sooner. Like in this engine.

A Holley will help you get the tune correct more easily, and quickly on the new engine. Most of what I see in the pics so far points to tuning issues. The engine was pushed too hard with things too far off. It was being detonated.

Please post pics of all the lower main bearing shells side by side and of the piston tops of #2 and #4 and any piston from the driver side bank. Taking a look at these will help confirm my preliminary opinion that this engine died from "bad tune" detonation. Not previous damage from insufficient oiling. Thanks.

Thanks for the insight Dave. The motor is at the machine shop and I may not be back there for awhile. Detonation is probable i'll try to get more pictures whenever I can.
 

RealFastV6

@jb_and_his_coffee
I agree. Heavily indicates detonation. Not likely the bearing damage was related to oil starvation with that kind of piston damage. Since the block wasn't converted to 4 bolt you really might as well get another one. Blocks are cheap and going 40 over on what's expected to be a reliable 11 second build is a gamble out of the gate.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk.
 

tbauer03

TRBOBOX
Re: Burning Oil, Good Compression

I agree. Heavily indicates detonation. Not likely the bearing damage was related to oil starvation with that kind of piston damage. Since the block wasn't converted to 4 bolt you really might as well get another one. Blocks are cheap and going 40 over on what's expected to be a reliable 11 second build is a gamble out of the gate.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk.

It was converted to 4 bolt. The machinist is going to do a sonic test of the block before we decide to go 40 over or a new block. How much of a gamble is 40 over? Is the biggest fear cracking the block?
 
Top