CL & OL or just open loop

cvcsmkr

Donating Member
I started working on using the stock boost solenoid with my pte44.
i noticed the boost tgt window was blank and after research found out that i need to be in closed loop correct?
heres my question,
i am tuning the ve tables right now, and looking at the wot stuff.
lets say after ive got a good baseline should i switch chip back to closed loop enable?
or is the ecu going to change the VE tables?
thanks
 

jwaller

Evil Genius/SyTy Guru
Re: CL & OL or just open loop

dont think so. howelse would it limit the first boost to 8psi? leave it in open loop you will always have a smoother idle and easier tuning. closed loop cant change ANY tables it can and does change the BLM and INT whcih is a factor in the final fueling PW.
 

cvcsmkr

Donating Member
Re: CL & OL or just open loop

waller, why do you say i will have better idle in open loop?


well its kinda weird.

with me changing nothing in the Bin file im using(was told an original ultimate bin).
i was checking out the f70 & f71 tables.
the values in the wg duty cycl vs delta tps are all 35.
with it like that i get 15 psi across the board.
nothing in the boost tgt window.
if i bump the 100% value to 90
and the 87% value to about 60 i get 15 psi for a few seconds then the rest of the wot run i get 19 psi.

i just dont want to trial and error too much and hurt the motor.

i guess i will put the closed loop enable back to 25*c.
and see how the afrs go, and screw around with the boost tables some more.
 

turbodig

Active member
Re: CL & OL or just open loop

cvcsmkr said:
I started working on using the stock boost solenoid with my pte44.
i noticed the boost tgt window was blank and after research found out that i need to be in closed loop correct?
heres my question,
i am tuning the ve tables right now, and looking at the wot stuff.
lets say after ive got a good baseline should i switch chip back to closed loop enable?
or is the ecu going to change the VE tables?
thanks


Need to separate some terms... there's 2 kinds of "closed/open loop" that get confused.

The boost control algorithm is independent of fueling closed loop- the o2 sensor, integrator, BLM, and the like.

Closed-loop boost, is another matter.

While you can use closed-loop boost to control boost on a PTE/Garrett turbo, the parameter settings you use are quite different than what the stocker likes. You need to slow things waaay down for the PTE servo canister.


Try this: (Using Paul's NWSTP Tunerpro def files here)

Turn the 'wastegate scaling hack' on... set it to 50.

Set your F70 Desired boost table to whatever your desired boost is. Set all the values in the table to be the same.

Set your POSITIVE STEP ADJUSTMENT TO WASTEGATE and
NEGATIVE STEP ADJUSTMENT TO WASTEGATE to 0%.

Now set your initialization duty cycle table (F71) to a relatively low value, like 40%, all the way across the table. Go for a WOT pass, logging your boost across the run. Get a good long run, through 3rd and 4th gear.

This will likely get you a relatively flat boost, probably pretty low boost at that. You might
have some small spikes at the shift points and TCC lockup.

Up the init value until you get your desired boost across most of the run. This will take a few passes to get right, and keep in mind that a cool motor will respond differently to init dc than a warm one will.

Once you have that, turn the step adjustements back on, but only to like 1-2 ticks, .7 -1%.

Then, you need to check your positive update rate and negative update rate... make sure both are above 1 second.

This will allow the closed loop boost algorithm to correct, only a lot slower than the stock tune did.

At this point, you should be pretty close. You may have some spikes on the shifts, or initially at launch. This is where the scaling hack comes in... the hack changes the F71 table to be MPH based.

Look to see what MPH your spikes occur at, and decrease the init DC in those areas (also, the adjacent ones around it.

Normally, you'll end up with something that looks like this:

MPH 00 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
70 70 60 55 55 55 55 40 40


The last thing to test is kick-down boost from a cruise- drive along at 40-50 MPH, and punch it. Boost should stay within 1-1.5 psi of your desired. If it doesn't, you need to change the init table at 40, 50 MPH.

Takes a bit of time to get 'er all dialed in, but it works pretty well once you do.

The new 59 code adds the ability to have different desired boost values for different MPH and RPM, which means you can do different boost in each gear. Future versions will also include an init correction vs. MAT temp, so cold-weather spikes can be corrected as well.


Later,
 

cvcsmkr

Donating Member
Re: CL & OL or just open loop

thank you very much, dig
i did a lot of searching and couldnt find much.
okay so fueling cl use's o2 for feedback.
so whats difference of cl & ol in boost control?
to properly use the stock boost control, should i have a value in the boost tgt window?
will what you described fix that issue im having, or something else?



i am so excited at how well this tuning is coming along the truck is running sooo good, and ive just started,
hell i still need that code59, come on js stop teasing us:)
 
Last edited:

turbodig

Active member
Re: CL & OL or just open loop

cvcsmkr said:
thank you very much, dig
i did a lot of searching and couldnt find much.
okay so fueling cl use's o2 for feedback.
so whats difference of cl & ol in boost control?
to properly use the stock boost control, should i have a value in the boost tgt window?
will what you described fix that issue im having, or something else?



i am so excited at how well this tuning is coming along the truck is running sooo good, and ive just started,
hell i still need that code59, come on js stop teasing us:)


Closed loop boost control:

Boost control system is using the MAP sensor (actual boost pressure) to provide feedback , and adjusts WG duty cycle to achieve a target boost. Ie, if boost is too high, pull WG DC out, if it's too low, add it back in.


Open loop boost control:

Boost control system outputs a fixed duty cycle... a *guess* at a particular wastegate solenoid position to achieve a desired boost. If it doesn't achieve that boost, it doesn't try to adjust. You get what you get... similar to a bleeder.


Your boost target should say something while in boost. If it doesn't, it means either your scan tool is reading the data stream wrong, or that you have the wrong values in your F70 table. ( there are a couple other settigns to check, but I have yet to see a chip that had these screwed up)

Generally, if you go through the procedure I posted, the system should work properly. It's tough to say what's wrong with a given bin without knowing what base it came from.


Later,
 

cvcsmkr

Donating Member
Re: CL & OL or just open loop

turbodig said:
Closed loop boost control:

Boost control system is using the MAP sensor (actual boost pressure) to provide feedback , and adjusts WG duty cycle to achieve a target boost. Ie, if boost is too high, pull WG DC out, if it's too low, add it back in.


Open loop boost control:

Boost control system outputs a fixed duty cycle... a *guess* at a particular wastegate solenoid position to achieve a desired boost. If it doesn't achieve that boost, it doesn't try to adjust. You get what you get... similar to a bleeder.
now i get, thanks


okay one more question so that i am not chasing ghosts.
my base bin was supposed to be a 50lb ultimate street setting.
i am using an ostrich, with the correct ads and xdf files.
when i say i have nothing in my boost tgt window, i am refering to datalogging with DM.
i havent quite figured out the datalogging w/tunerpo yet.
but with all of those definition files, should the TGT window in DM read something?
 

turbodig

Active member
Re: CL & OL or just open loop

cvcsmkr said:
now i get, thanks


okay one more question so that i am not chasing ghosts.
my base bin was supposed to be a 50lb ultimate street setting.
i am using an ostrich, with the correct ads and xdf files.
when i say i have nothing in my boost tgt window, i am refering to datalogging with DM.
i havent quite figured out the datalogging w/tunerpo yet.
but with all of those definition files, should the TGT window in DM read something?

Boost tgt should say something, yes. If first time boost mode is still turned on, it won't
until after the first foray into boost.

I've got a few DM files here from Ultimate-based bins, and they all have a target boost.

Which ads and xdf do you have, specifically?
You'll probably need the ALDL patch posted last week to get TP to datalog properly.

Later,
 

cvcsmkr

Donating Member
Re: CL & OL or just open loop

im using 122749 2&3 bar_58_rev6a.ads
58_2&3bar_beta_0.9.1.xdf

i dont understand how this scaling hack works?
 
Last edited:

turbodig

Active member
Re: CL & OL or just open loop

cvcsmkr said:
im using 122749 2&3 bar_58_rev6a.ads
58_2&3bar_beta_0.9.1.xdf

i dont understand how this scaling hack works?


It's actually changing code... you're swapping internal variables used in the table lookup.

Basically, you set it to 50 and forget it. :)


Later,
 

turbodig

Active member

cvcsmkr

Donating Member
Re: CL & OL or just open loop

is this f71_mph for code 59?
because i cant find it anywhere in tunerpro.
 

turbodig

Active member
Re: CL & OL or just open loop

cvcsmkr said:
is this f71_mph for code 59?
because i cant find it anywhere in tunerpro.

Nope.... been around for years.

No matter. Right click on your F71 and select "edit item XDF info". Hit the tab that says Rows.

In the row table, type in the new numbers:

0,10,20,30,40,50,60,70,80.

Hit Apply and ok. Then save your XDF. (XDF->Save XDF.)

Not particularly magical.
 

cvcsmkr

Donating Member
Re: CL & OL or just open loop

turbodig said:
Nope.... been around for years.

No matter. Right click on your F71 and select "edit item XDF info". Hit the tab that says Rows.

In the row table, type in the new numbers:

0,10,20,30,40,50,60,70,80.

Hit Apply and ok. Then save your XDF. (XDF->Save XDF.)

Not particularly magical.

cool, its done.
thanks again dig:tup:

actually now that i think about it, it makes sense now.
i only upped the 87% and 100% values.
and my boost curve would start out at 15 and then end up at 20.
so that tabled has always been mph, hhhmmmm.
 
Last edited:

turbodig

Active member
Re: CL & OL or just open loop

cvcsmkr said:
cool, its done.
thanks again dig:tup:

actually now that i think about it, it makes sense now.
i only upped the 87% and 100% values.
and my boost curve would start out at 15 and then end up at 20.
so that tabled has always been mph, hhhmmmm.


Not necessarily. 100% TPS (the stock code) will be where most people drive at, as far as boost is concerned.
 
Top