Converting to MAF

Status
Not open for further replies.

smeagol

Active member
If you want to setup a crank trigger & cam sensor that mimic the Buick sensor signals, you could do it. Then you'd need to do some wiring stuff (new injector harness, adapter or rewire the plug to the ECM).
 

Methuselah

New member
Why would you want to do this? A MAF sensor is basically a heated wire or grid, the airflow is measured by how much current is needed to heat the element up to a target temperature which is roughly proportional to the amount of flowing through it.

In our application if you place one say, before the throttle body, then the charged air wont give a valid reading because the compression caused the temperatures to skyrocket...and Im guessing not too many people have an efficient enough intercooler system to get temperatures within ten or so degrees of ambient so the readings still make sense. I imagine if one were correctly calibrated for our specific application it could work, except that the element would probably have to me more than the 200*F or so it is now...and that just makes the resitance element more fragile, and suspect to failure in the often high-pressure there.

If one were to place it before the turbo, then I still think there is a problem. In a turbo application I think it's only important what it happening behind the throttle plates. That is, if we let our foot off the throttle and those plates shut, we can quickly develop a vacuum in the upper intake manifold, but there is now a excess in pressure in the intercooler and piping after the compressor wheel. This charge will (A) push its way through the compressor housing and throw the MAF off (more or less so depending where it is located in the stock airbox) or (B) vent through an aftermarket blow-off valve and well...I think everything is okay in that situation.

I wondered this same thing but I couldnt think of a more reliable way to measure airflow than to measure the preasures in the intake manifold...it seems a logical and direct connection into what the engine is getting. It responds more quickly to engine vacuum and turbo compression.

Feel free to slap me around for missing something.
 

smeagol

Active member
It seems to work *fairly* well for Buicks, considering they've run into the 8's with 'em, not to mention Mustangs. (sarcasm)

The biggest thing about MAF systems is that they are flexible for modifications, as long as your range of air metering covers your airflow.

Funny, those guys usually want to convert over to speed density systems.
 

Methuselah

New member
I see what you are saying about the variability of a MAF system... but isnt that because MAF systems more or less directly calculate the injector cycle whereas MAP systems use tables with a finite amount of precision due to memory limitations?

It seems to me that a table-based scheme would lend itself better to tuning. Rather than changing parameters to influence equations in the MAF situation, you can change table values based on empirical evidence, and possibly vary the interpolation algortithm between table elements for a different response. Multiple tables could even be used if one could program heuristics that "identify" driving patterns....assuming the ECM can address that much memory.

Im talking out of my ass anyhow...havent had the Typhoon running long enough yet to get a working knowledge of the stock ECM/PROM setup.
 

smeagol

Active member
Both systems use fairly sophisticated algorithms for fuel calculations, with many tables for lookups in the calibration. It's a flexible enough setup as it is, taking all of your sensor readings into account for that calculation. Small changes are even accounted for. Granted, it could be 100 times more complicated, and that is the way most engine control setups are going, but you need 100 times larger calibration space as well. Calibrations for these types of computers takes teams of people months to do usually.

Table based tuning, as you put it, is crucial in both systems. The MAF systems actually measures the amount of air going into a system, where the speed density is relying upon a calibration table for volumetric efficiency to determine the amount of air consumed. So anything that affects the VE of an engine really needs to be taken into consideration for that calibration in a speed density application.

While any of the older computers are by no means Pentium level machines, they are dedicated to their engine controlling functions, and don't really suffer in the computing power areas for their particular programs. The Syty has a 32bit inj pulsewidth resolution; I'm pretty sure the Buick does as well.

I'll just keep on waiting for the neural net computers :smile:
 

Methuselah

New member
On 2002-02-01 12:05, mr.sparkle wrote:
I'll just keep on waiting for the neural net computers :smile:

You can roll your own ECM instead using last months Poputronics article for reference. I'll lay the circuit out and etch the board for you for a quick prototype before the production run :smile:
 

UNIsackV6

Member
Funny, those guys usually want to convert over to speed density systems.

Oh yeah Mr. Sparkly Guy, well I heard some guy named SPOOKYDOG is gonna mix and use all types of engine management systems on his Big Boost, NOS, Alky, High Compression morph motor. To control everything he's gonna use a MAF in between the throttle plates and the acutal upper intake that goes to a Buick computer. Then retain the stock computer with a KB 10sec chip and the MAP sensor as is. Then for further clarity he's gonna run in ALDL mode to Data Log. To tune he's gonna use the tried and true RR assdyno method heard it works really well! Oh yeah don't forget the NOS controller to dial that in along with the MSD Knock sensor to manually adjust for knock who needs the chip to do it when you can decide when the knock is too loud yourself? Throw in the ATR light show err I mean knock sensor guage and what do you have? The new sheriff in town!!!
 

charles

New member
Us 240sx guys that are running ALL original factory sensors on our SR20DET setups have found our MAF setups are fairly responsive to mods.

Stock rating is 205hp at 7psi. Normal list of mods including larger diameter downpipe+exhaust, FMIC, Walbro pump, and bump the boost to around 1 bar can net up to a 40% increase in HP(around 280hp) with stock driveability and economy.
 

Daron

Active member
On 2002-02-01 15:46, OddfireV6 wrote:
Funny, those guys usually want to convert over to speed density systems.

Oh yeah Mr. Sparkly Guy, well I heard some guy named SPOOKYDOG is gonna mix and use all types of engine management systems on his Big Boost, NOS, Alky, High Compression morph motor. To control everything he's gonna use a MAF in between the throttle plates and the acutal upper intake that goes to a Buick computer. Then retain the stock computer with a KB 10sec chip and the MAP sensor as is. Then for further clarity he's gonna run in ALDL mode to Data Log. To tune he's gonna use the tried and true RR assdyno method heard it works really well! Oh yeah don't forget the NOS controller to dial that in along with the MSD Knock sensor to manually adjust for knock who needs the chip to do it when you can decide when the knock is too loud yourself? Throw in the ATR light show err I mean knock sensor guage and what do you have? The new sheriff in town!!!

ROTFLMAOASCOOMN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

(rolling on the floor laughing my ass off and spitting coke out of my nose)

<font size=-1>[ This Message was edited by: Daron on 2002-02-01 21:01 ]</font>
 

Tooky

Serious about performance
Funny. Here we have Daron "Self Appointed Police of Off-Topic Posts" Hartvigsen giving pats on the back to someone who has posted a hugely off-topic post in the holy Tuning section. Anyone else find that interesting?

Hey Daron, do you need some friendly reminders from me to keep it on topic in the tech areas? Or will this proof of your own faults be enough to make you come to your senses about harassing me?
 

Buster

New member
On 2002-03-03 19:47, TookyCat wrote:
Funny. Here we have Daron "Self Appointed Police of Off-Topic Posts" Hartvigsen giving pats on the back to someone who has posted a hugely off-topic post in the holy Tuning section. Anyone else find that interesting?

Hey Daron, do you need some friendly reminders from me to keep it on topic in the tech areas? Or will this proof of your own faults be enough to make you come to your senses about harassing me?

You must be looking to turn this into a flame war, are you bored, not enough action this last week? Daron makes one off topic post in the last year, and your right here to point it out. You on the other hand have made dozens of off topic post which is what pissed everyone off in the beginning.

Mark L
 

Tooky

Serious about performance
Your suggestion that I'm the one trying to start a flame war is preposterous. I've purposely tried to avoid responding to any of Daron's posts. The only one starting a flame war is Daron continuing to harass me at every turn. He goes out of his way to respond to my posts, there exists a huge trend showing that. Especially when people make off topic posts prior to mine in the same thread, and then he gives me shit about responding to theirs. Face it, he's got issues and I'm not about to put up with his shit because I've had it. Are you trying to defend his harassing actions towards me?

You on the other hand have made dozens of off topic post which is what pissed everyone off in the beginning.
In the beginning of what? And your generalization of "everyone" is a bit much.

<font size=-1>[ This Message was edited by: TookyCat on 2002-03-03 20:57 ]</font>
 

Buster

New member
I'm glad someone finally stopped you from responding to every post with your mindless comments, So yes I'm defend Darons harassing actions towards you, one off topic comment every now and then is fine, but you over did it in the past.

Mark L
 

Tooky

Serious about performance
And that warrants a harassment sentence till the end of time?? You're out of your gourd..
 

Buster

New member
Tooky did you get your fix yet? Your always looking for trouble, you knew damn well that pointing out Darons off topic post would surely get something going, so quit playing Mr. innocent and face it your an a**.
 

Tooky

Serious about performance
Always looking for trouble, what a gas! Who is the one who constantly harasses me and points out almost every single god damn post of mine that could be remotely offtopic? Give me a freakin' break.. No I don't go looking for trouble but when someone goes out of their way to cause trouble for me, I'm not gonna let it slide.

Talk to Daron and ask him what his problem is with me, he obviously doesn't care about off topic posts or he wouldn't make them himself here AND he wouldn't let everyone else's offtopic posts slide..
 

bdubb

I am teh kingpin!
cryingfawkingbaby.jpg
 

Daron

Active member
Dook's post here is just further evidence that he doesnt get simple concepts.
Some folks rarely post off topic, Dook is not one of them. I dont hassle folks who digress once every blue moon, but I refuse to tolerate a complete free for all. Dook's social life is here on this board. Fine, just as long as he stays on topic in the tech areas.
Thanks for ruining an otherwise productive topic Dook...
Now, take it elsewhere.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top