Engine Knock at low RPM

TYTILIDIE

METH HEAD
Starting last night, at cruise mode or slower, I hear a knocking sound. It almost sounds like a rod but not incredibly loud. I hooked up DM and get no KR. It sounds like its coming form the motor but cant tell for sure. At WOT or under acceleration, I dont hear it at all. Anyone have any ideas of what it could be?

Mike
 

Lynn D. Brown

New member
Re: Engine Knock at low RPM

Mike,

I hate to say it, but it sounds exactly like a Rod bearing. Typically rod knocks occur when U let off the throttle 2 cruise. U will want to take care of it before U throw one. I wiped out my block that way. Unfortunately, I didn't get a warning.
 

Deanzsyclone

New member
Re: Engine Knock at low RPM

typhooner0073 said:
Im thinking I have to totally rebuild it correct?

Mike

Well actually you can pull the oilpan from underneath (youll need a car lift) and then you have access to all six rod bearings. Might as well do all of them since they are so cheap.
It's hard to do but I've done it before.

But if you decide to pull the motor to do them then heck do at least a standard engine rebuild.
 

93ty475

Donating Member
Re: Engine Knock at low RPM

does it knock at idle? if so, then hook up a timing light and see if it knocks as the light blinks....if so, then the crudest method of determing a rod knock it to unplug each plug wire one by one to see if it goes away...be careful, this is a very easy way to get zapped....if it goes away, you likely have rod knock....
 

TYTILIDIE

METH HEAD
Re: Engine Knock at low RPM

93ty475 said:
does it knock at idle? if so, then hook up a timing light and see if it knocks as the light blinks....if so, then the crudest method of determing a rod knock it to unplug each plug wire one by one to see if it goes away...be careful, this is a very easy way to get zapped....if it goes away, you likely have rod knock....

It doesnt really knock at idle. It sounds more like lifter tap but I have heard both sounds at the same time. I was jsut out messing with it nad noticed it doesnt make the noises above 2000RPm at all. Ive spun bearings and flattened out cams manytimes before and this knock sounds a bit different. Plus in my experience, usually gets crazy loud on acceleration and WOT. Im going to get under there tomorrow and do some investigating, had a thought earlier that my Vette had a similar problem and had turned out to be the converter bolts fell off but it was a much more hollow echoing knock.

Mike
 

TYTILIDIE

METH HEAD
Re: Engine Knock at low RPM

Oh yeah, it oesnt seem to do it going down hill either. Up hill it does. The knock never gets any better or any worse.
 

berzerker

wookie
Re: Engine Knock at low RPM

you sure its not something in your driveline ? maybe propshaft about to let loose on you. u-joint ?? maybe downpipe loose .
 

crashing_sux

Blow Me?
Re: Engine Knock at low RPM

I thought you had to pull the block in order to turn the crank and get rid of the flat spots you get from having rod knock?


deanzsyclone said:
Well actually you can pull the oilpan from underneath (youll need a car lift) and then you have access to all six rod bearings. Might as well do all of them since they are so cheap.
It's hard to do but I've done it before.

But if you decide to pull the motor to do them then heck do at least a standard engine rebuild.
 

TYTILIDIE

METH HEAD
Re: Engine Knock at low RPM

I think Im pretty confident I found the problem. Its gotten much worse throughout the day. This evening it started missing so I went home and starrted going through the ignition. I found that #2 spark pluf was fouled pretty good. Tomorrow Im going to go get a new plug and change the cap and rotor. I recently changed all the plugs and wires. We did an OHM test and all wires seemed to be ok.

Mike
 

TYTILIDIE

METH HEAD
Re: Engine Knock at low RPM

So I replaced all the plugs, cap and rotor and wires. Still knocked. I pulled the driver side valve cover and noticed #2 exh valve nut loose as all hell almost fell off. So I tighten it up and agjust valves. It ran like a champ. Still had the knock though. So the other day, Im driving home and just as Im getting to my house, it starts tach flutering like crazy, chugging and backfiring. Im like WTF!!!! So it dies juuuust as Im pulling up to my house and now I cant get it started. So far, Ive found an exhaust leak. #5 Cyl manifold bolts were way loose. I tightened them all up and still no start. Just pulled driver side valve cover and one of the rockers is so loose that you can twist it off the pushrod. It also pushes down into the lifter way further than all the others. Very easy to push. Not too sure what to do next but Im getting suspicious of a flat spot on the cam. What do you guys think?

Mike
 

Bill Z

Donating Member
Re: Engine Knock at low RPM

You could have more than one problem. Your rockers backing off are certainly a problem. These trucks come with roller cams and lifters. A roller could have gone bad messing up the cam but that is rare.

Since your truck doesn't start you may be having oil problems and everything is starting to get loose. These trucks have an oil pressure switch that turns off the fuel pump if the oil pressure isn't x pounds. When you pulled into the drive (a turn I am thinking) the oil in the pan sloshed to one side. Pump may have just been able to do the work. The sounds could be some or all of the mains, rods, lifters....

I am sorry for you. I mean that.
 

TYTILIDIE

METH HEAD
Re: Engine Knock at low RPM

Yeah me too. It did run 1/2 quart low on oil. I had checked the oil and it looked watery. It was really hot though. I checked it today and it looked normal. No gas smell or anything. My plan is to pull the intake this weekend and turn the cam and see what there is to see. Anyone think its worth it to replace a cam in this situation or do you suppose a rebuild will be necassary. Oil appears to be pretty clean. The only reason I have a hard time believing its not rod knock, is cause Ive had rod knock before and the knock would always get worse and louder with more RPM. This noise never got worse or better, it wennt away under acceleration and at WOT. Starter has been having a hard time engaging so Im wondering if torque converter bolts cvame loose. But that wouldnt explain the backfire and stall.

Mike
 

nightdiver

Active member
Re: Engine Knock at low RPM

Oil pressure has to go lower that 4 psi to stop current to the fuel pump. So thats not your problem
When you adjusted the valves did the pushrod stay at 0 lash with no up and down play ?
Usually the old hydros make you adjust the valves the wrong way cause there is oil loss from there.
One thing is for sure.......you got to change the nuts :)
 

TYTILIDIE

METH HEAD
Re: Engine Knock at low RPM

nightdiver said:
Oil pressure has to go lower that 4 psi to stop current to the fuel pump. So thats not your problem
When you adjusted the valves did the pushrod stay at 0 lash with no up and down play ?
Usually the old hydros make you adjust the valves the wrong way cause there is oil loss from there.
One thing is for sure.......you got to change the nuts :)


Im not really sure what you are talking about. The one nut was replaced as it was the only one that backed off. The way I adjust valves is to run the motor and turn em down til it stops clattering and then I give it 1/4 turn. Im alm,ost positive its not rod or main knock cause I really dont believe that It would start to backfire then just all of a sudden quit. When the motor is cranking it sounds smooth.

Mike
 

nightdiver

Active member
Re: Engine Knock at low RPM

I just say that valve adjustment is not accurate with old/used hydro lifters, specially when we use double or triple springs with high lift cams.
When you turn the engine to adjust the other end the stress make the lifter loose some oil , so the adjusment is off.
 

TYTILIDIE

METH HEAD
Re: Engine Knock at low RPM

My lifters are only a year old and have 30k on them. With the rest of the motor. Im starting to wonder if the ignition module is bad. Im taking it to be tested tomorrow. I hope thats it cause Im dieing wihtout my truck.

Mike
 

TYTILIDIE

METH HEAD
Are me and Crashing Sux related?

Are me and Crashing Sux related?

OK! Got to do some digging and here is what I found. I think me and CRAHINGSUX are related. First off, I had the rocker nut that had backed off. That was adjusted then the truck died onme nad had to have it towed. So I get it in the garage Saturday and start trouble shooting. I realize I have no spark. I remove my IGN MODULE and take it to have it tested and its toast. So I get a new one with the warranty and put it in. Then as I go to start the motor the starter just doesnt seem to be engaging. So I get under to pull the started and notice gray oil on the flywheel cover. I take the cover off and can find absolutely none of this gray oil anywhere else. Stillnot too sure about that one. So I take the starter down to AZ and it is indeed toast as well. Get the new starter in and go to fire up the motor and now the friggin key wont turn in the ignition. Im like WTF!!!!! Even threw my rachet across the room which is something I never do. So I had to hotwire the truck, drive it donw to AZ, buy a new lock and key and install it in the parking lot. The bad news is, that damn knock is still there. My machine shop asked me to bring it down to hear it so I did. With the hood up I power braked a little to let him hear the knock and now notice that my motor mount is broken. Machine shop is fairly positive it sounds like main bearings. Anyone think it would be a waste of time to pull the oil pan to see or would you just pull the motor.? I also had a 2-5lb. average drop in oil pressure which the machine says is usually main bearings. What do youguys think?

Mike
 

bezerk

New member
Re: Are me and Crashing Sux related?

Re: Are me and Crashing Sux related?

typhooner0073 said:
I also had a 2-5lb. average drop in oil pressure which the machine says is usually main bearings. What do youguys think?

Mike

really not sure about that part.
you could have your oil analysed to see what shit is in there, or cut open your oil filter.
i had a spun main. and i could even see metal flakes on the dipstick.

Pull the engine.
you can pull the engine in a few hours, and you could clean up some things.
front diff drop also takes alot of time. and you only have acces to a few things.
 
Top