FAST-SP knock retard

G

Guest

Guest
For those of you with the SP setup, including knock retard option........ have any of you ever recorded any knock counts???

I'm up to 18 psi (92 octane) of tuning new motor, and haven't recorded even one itty bitty knock event. Knowing I'm NOT that good of a tuner, I'm beginning to wonder if the damn thing works?

I'm seeking feedback from ALL of you with the FAST-SP system, please. TIA, :smile:
 

smeagol

Active member
I know I've told you that I have seen it on my old Syclone, but I was gonna say you may wanna tap the alternator bracket or something to see if you get some retard. I don't trust it anyways. Using those Vortec heads, it is hard to make it knock. Check the plugs for best info. I know many people running LOTS of timing on the Vortecs, so you may just be running that mild on them. I just did some tuning on another big buildup with Vortec heads. I really really really like those heads :smile:

BG
 

UNIsackV6

Member
Hehe its working otherwise you'd be hearing loud noises that would make your pocket book mad and empty :razz: Take it from the SP Guru you have a good build and 18PSI with your set up is nothing I'll be impressed when you post and say "Man I just did some 28PSI runs and still no knock :wink: You should be happy that things are going so well, you could have a turd-fire and be getting nowhere...sounds like you are progressing nicely...btw my e-mail and computer are back up I'll shoot you a mail and keep up the good work...Laters
 
G

Guest

Guest
Thanks guys, appreciate the input. I followed in Rob's footsteps regarding low end timing and AFR...... idles @ 14.7 with 46* timing, cruz 14.6 and 45*........ truck likes it! Was out resetting VE after and general driveability after installing 75#'rs, and following the 60-70 mph speedlimits, I got 16 mpg!!!! NOT bad for a loose non lockup TC :wink:

I'm still wuss and using "reasonable" AFR and timing under boost (BG's old settings). Truck is running strong! As you two are aware, this "puppy" pulls no matter where your at on the scale.

I'll up the boost and test further"if" it evers stops raining around here ??????

I'm still interested in hearing from others. ROB, Peter, Steve, Keith, and the countless others whom I don't know. Thanks,
 

UNIsackV6

Member
Sounds like you're doing really well. How big is the grin on your face when you pull through the first 2 gears in like 3 seconds :smile: You have one fun truck on your hands if I could do it all over I'd do along the same lines as you...wanna trade trucks
:wink:
 

RAACCR

Member
Roland,
I've been out of town...just saw this thread today. When I broke my stock flexplate, it rattled like crazy and the truck slowed way down. I wasn't data-logging that pass, but from the way it slowed down, the Speed Pro must have thought it was knocking and pulled out a bunch of timing.
 
G

Guest

Guest
Al; heads are the McCoy 772's

Ryan: "wanna trade trucks"? Ooooh. Naw, if I did, I would 'prolly just sit and stare at how purty it is and never drive it! I am curious tho...... I sent BDubb the $250 for the cladding, and any idea when it will arrive???

Rob: thanks for info........ think I'd prefer to find out another way other than 'ur example :wink: I may go down and try BG's method....... small sledge and "anything now"? "OK, how about now"?

OTHERS??????????
 

rhaley

New member
Roland, i assume you have a KR module plugged into your SP wiring harness?
I have a very similar engine build and with 91 octane and my alky injection turned off, I can only run 15# boost @20 degrees timing before I start seeing KR. With the alky on, I can go to about 21# before I see KR.
 
G

Guest

Guest
hey Ron;
"i assume you have a KR module plugged into your SP wiring harness?" <------ YES

Interesting results your getting. I'm at 19.8 degrees of timing and have run both with and without alky up to 18 psi. KR wise, no difference, as in none showing. But, it's been cool weather when I've tested. Are your results from cool-hot or both kinda days? I know from last motor, 18 psi in winter on 92 was ok. In summer, I had to use alky to obtain the same results, without knock.

Are you using the same or original SyTy knock sensor??? (I am, and I wonder if there should be something else in there, used with the SP Knock module)

Thanks for the input,
 

smeagol

Active member
Ron, what heads are you running on your motor? The Vortecs can handle a *lot* of timing. I've seen like 30+ degrees at WOT for some calibrations. I ran like 20-22 at 20-21 psi, with alky.

The Speedpro uses the stock knock sensor, but uses the Buick ESC module.

Brian G
 

rhaley

New member
Brian, have you ever used 91 octane without xylene or alky injection? I am running McCoy's heads. I am also at 5000 ft. elevation so 20# equivalent at sea level requires me to actually boost 22.5# because atmosphere here is (-2.5#).
 

rhaley

New member
Roland, I phrased my question wrong. I have the original knock sensor, I meant ESC module when I asked about the KR sensor plugged into the SP harness. I can run more boost when the weather is cooler, it gets over 100* here and the air is very thin at 5000 ft. I would guess that the additional boost requirement to take the air from (-2.5#) to 20# with very little air density is probably heating the air much more than it would at sea level. This is probably why I am so sensitive to knock. I also am using McCoy heads with a final CR of 8.35:1. And 91 octane sucks.
 
G

Guest

Guest
hey Ryan: regarding the cladding, Yeah, I was jus yanking 'ur chain :wink:

Ron: Yes, I have the black module that PTE supplied with the SP, and a new SyTy specific knock sensor.

From what both you and my hero BG say, I have lot's of area to play with before KR becomes an issue. In that case, I'll push forward gently on 92 octane and see when it happens. Only running with 19.8 degrees of timing under boost, so looks like I'll play and push forward gently there also.

Man........ this stuff is fun. Just wish it was dryer outside. I'm at the point that floorboarding the throttle in the wet ISN'T a smart idea :cool: Thanks,
 

smeagol

Active member
Brian, have you ever used 91 octane without xylene or alky injection? I am running McCoy's heads. I am also at 5000 ft. elevation so 20# equivalent at sea level requires me to actually boost 22.5# because atmosphere here is (-2.5#).

Nope, haven't. Just wanted to make sure we were comparing apples to apples here, cuz the heads make a HUGE difference. 91 octane does suck. Have both of you verified your exact timing advance of FAST vs balancer reading?

For timing advance, the one way that I feel would give you a good indication would be to do dyno runs, get some baselines with a stable AFR, advance timing in 2 deg increments. Note the HP gain, check plugs. You will see HP rise with spark advance, provided you are not pushing it too far. I've seen the HP gain tapers off. You might make 35hp more with 4 deg advance, but only 5 more on the additional 4 degrees. IMO, those 4 additional degrees are just pushing your margin of safety and aren't worth it.

I was also planning on seeing if you could handle more timing advance at higher RPM rather than at peak torque (max load). Not sure, just a question I had...

BG
 
G

Guest

Guest
. Have both of you verified your exact timing advance of FAST vs balancer reading?

<--------- uhhhhh, ummmmmm......... no.
I have the Comp. Cam dual timing cover, and with the timing tab in place I can't see enough of the marked balancer to time it with the mark under the timing tab. So.....
I pull the two bolted down cables off of SP, disconnect the ESC and then time it to 16* outside and to the left of the timing tab, and time it while cranking-not running.

I found that to get true "timing" zero, I had to disconnect box and still disconnect the ESC lead. (even going into SP and telling it zero wouldn't work..... per Harry's suggestion)

Obviously, I don't have a dial-in timing lite, and didn't wanna spring for a 3rd timing lite :wink: I do believe the timing is accurate. With my setup and IC in place, getting at the dist. tie down bolt is close to impossible, hence the above method. When I throw the lite on it running, the timing mark is waaaaaay over to the left, as it should be, but I can't truly guarantee it's 100%.
 

rhaley

New member
Nope, haven't. Just wanted to make sure we were comparing apples to apples here, cuz the heads make a HUGE difference. 91 octane does suck. Have both of you verified your exact timing advance of FAST vs balancer reading?

Yes I have Brian, piston stop to verify 0* and I put a mark at 20* on my damper to verify SP. What kind of plugs are you guys running? I have tried Delco R42LTS and NGK TR6 but they break up over 15#. McCoy recommended Autolite 104 and they seem to handle over 20# with no problem. Maybe I should go colder? I have no color on the plugs after several thousand miles.
 

smeagol

Active member
I believe I verified my timing, but this is over a year ago that I ran the Syclone in that configuration.

Plugs - I ran R44LTS, Autolite 103 with boost, no problems. Put NGK TR6's in, and then the motor went..didn't have a chance to try 'em in boost. Weird results you are having though. From every truck I've encountered with Vortecs, they are MUCH more forgiving as far as plug selection goes. I ran Rapidfires on mine even. Was fine until 18psi. I think you may have some other issue Ron.. the NGK, IMHO, are far superior than the AC's that we run in the truck.

BG
 
G

Guest

Guest
I'm running the NGK TR5's, and will move up to the TR6's soon. Plugs are looking good so far (only yanked a couple, not all of them) and as I've mentioned, truck is stout thru 18 psi. (I should mention that I'm running a Crane Hi6 and PS91 coil) I started out new motor with the R44LTS..... they worked fine, and looked good when I replaced 'em. Local Larry G is running the 6's with his Vortec setup and doing well, so I'll follow suit.

I played with timing program last nite and upp'd it a couple degrees under boost. It's still raining like crazy and with truck being freshly waxed, I haven't the heart to go out testing.

Ron: how many jets you running on alky? Size?

I'm using single with a NOS "40". I haven't tested much with it, as I'm not yet encountering knock. Guess I'm just not trying hard enuff :wink:
 
Top