How much is to much FP?

SeattleSy#1255

Category 5 Conservative
Got alot of knock with the truck set at 52psi running t1 16 (Datamaster Files). I'll list the mods real quick:
K&N Air Filter
160 thermo.
IC Wired
Walbro 255 High PRessure FP
Kenne Bell AFPR
Deleted Mufflers (stock exhaust/cat)
Ultimate Chip
My question is this, i turned it up to 56psi made a run and recorded...s-term says i'm running lean still, o2's are mid to high 800's...still have knock...So I just pulled off to the side of the road, turned it up again (no pressure gauge) and did another spin...knock goes down, s-term getting better, o2's getting into the low 900's now...All good right? I did this a few times untill i got amost no knock, s-term was almost exactly 128, and 02's where around 920-960...I take her home and check the final Fuel Pressure and it settled at 74psi...WOW??? Is this ok? Is this bad? Whats the deal, isnt' this pretty high or do i just have an odd truck? Based on datamaster files all knock seems to be coming from running lean also based on how it gets better as FP is increased, but i could there be another problem...I have the files if you want them emailed to you, but any help, advice, or comment are appriciated...The truck isn't moving untill i know this is ok for the thing or not!

Thanks in advance.
 

Falco

Donating Member
:eek: If it's really this high it's bad. Are you sure that your gauage is working properly?

Also read the plugs... It could tell you what's happening.
 

JoeLutz

New member
I had the same problem with my Ultimate. Too lean causing knock. Here are a few things to consider: Check very closely the Vaccum lines going to the AFPR and map sensor. If possible check with a hand vaccum pump for vaccum leaks. Monitor FP under boost. FP should increase linearly with boost: 1psi FP increase for 1psi boost increase. So with 50 psi base, you should have 55 FP at 5psi boost, 65 FP at 15psi boost, etc. Finally dirty injectors causing the injectors not to flow like they should at a given FP.

Hope this helps
 

SeattleSy#1255

Category 5 Conservative
Here is the recent deal...The plugs where replaced by a shop while i had them install the Holly wires i got...The guy told me they showed evidence it was running rich as did the scope they did on it, so they replaced the plugs about 4 days ago...He said the fp was set at 55psi and put it back down to 47psi...Thus causing it to run even leaner according to datamaster files...I'm not understanding why the plugs shows evidence of running rich, the damn thing smells like it was running rich, but i made a run, or even cruise at 60 and my o2's and s-term shows i'm running lean...also i get knock...so then i turn up the fp and all numbers get better. I think my gauge is working correctly, i tap into the pin thing by cylinder #1, plug the afpr vacuum hose, then adjust, right? Also, how can i monitor fp to boost ratio? the fp gauge is one that has to be tapped in each time?

Thanks again.
 

JoeLutz

New member
You are adjusting the base FP correctly.
You need to get an incab gauge or take your hood off and mount the shop gauge where you can see it or extend the hose on it some way so that you can see the FP when you drive. Here is a look at my gauges.
guage1.jpg


You can't judge the mixture by the O2 at WOT because the stock O2 sensor has a very narrow range and at WOT the mixture is out of its range. You will get flamed by some people for even mentioning that. :wink: The S-terms should automatically go to 128 when you hit WOT because it goes into open loop. Pull a few plugs and look at them yourself. If possible make pics to post so others can see. The plugs in a turbo vehicle usually should appear to look a little richer than most clean burning NA cars, because we have to have a richer mixture under boost. What plugs and Gap are you running? Have you done all the FAQ stuff?

_________________
Joe Lutz
My Typhoon is a money thieving whore
Ty4redweb.jpg

communities.msn.com/joeelutz

<font size=-1>[ This Message was edited by: joemama on 2002-01-14 00:01 ]</font>
 

SeattleSy#1255

Category 5 Conservative
Well, i'm new at this, but i don't understand something. The o2's bounce around like crazy if i'm not at WOT, which i understood to be normal, so how do i read anything from it then...Your correct about the s-term, it does sit at 128 at WOT, which i understand to be normal as well. So my question is, to this quote "You can't judge the mixture by the O2 at WOT because the stock O2 sensor has a very narrow range and at WOT the mixture is out of its range." Then when can i meassure the O2's as an accurate measuring tool? Again it bounces around like crazy if not at WOT. Also, the o2's numbers which started in the low 800's, got better as i increased the FP, and knock went down as well...So can't i assume that it is accurate at WOT? I'm thinking it could be a bad fuel filter or even dirty injectors. Thanks again for your insite...I'm new to datamaster so perhaps i'm all messed up here...What ya think?
 

SeattleSy#1255

Category 5 Conservative
sorry forgot to mention that the s-term i was meassuring was at cruise speed, 60mph...thats how i was judging the s-term...sorry if that confussed ya..my bad!
 

JoeLutz

New member
Well the thing is most people on here agree that you shouldn't pay attention to the O2 at WOT because it is inaccurate. However you can watch it for trends, I'm a little fuzzy on this as well. You see, the O2 can give different readings at WOT irregardless of the actual mixture. Thats why most tuners use a wide band O2 metering instrument that can be used in this range. The fluctuating O2 reading at idle or part throttle are interpreted by the ECM and that is what the ECM uses to set the S-terms and L-terms. So what most people watch for is a O2 that is fluctuating too slowly or goes too high under WOT, because that can be an indication that the O2 sensor is going bad.
For example, my O2 mV are in the 1050mV region at WOT. This is not because my Ty is running rich, on the other hand, I believe its actually running too lean judging by the plugs. What this does mean is that most likely my O2 sensor is getting old and needs to be replaced. Different stock O2 sensors can give very different mV readings at WOT for the same mixture and they can even change from run to run or day to day. Thats why they are considered to be inaccurate. The stock O2 is only designed to be accurate arround the stoch. mixture of 14.7:1. When under boost our mixture can go as rich as arround 11:1, way outside of the range of the stock O2 sensor.

On the other hand, and I may get flamed for this one, I also can tell a difference in the O2 mV between when my Ty is running good with little to no Knock and when it is knocking like a bitch. When it runs good, the O2's are generally higher.

What were your s terms at cruise?

Some people who are more knowledgeable about the SyTy specific tuning stuff; jwaller, BG, Daron, just to name a few, could probably help you more.
 

SeattleSy#1255

Category 5 Conservative
Just to answer a few of the questins above...My cruise speed was about 60-65mph where i got my s-term readings of about 123-135...I understand this to be good right? I'm using the plugs everyone suggest, the cr42ts...But again, i get good s-term numbers with my FP at 74psi, which was my original concern...This reading the 02 thing is getting confussing, but i am following ya for the most part...I wonder what others think about this...Anyone else, use there datamaster 02 reading for tuning or did i just lean a big lesson? Thanks again, group.
 

Tooky

Serious about performance
Hi, I have a question, does your truck run faster and faster with the higher FP or does it turn into a total dog at one point? When I turn my FP up too high it begins spooling very sloowwwly and feels really doggy. I like to use the DataMaster quarter mile calculator feature to gauge how much faster I am going when I tune something like that. (After ensuring the knock retard is within control).

What I do is find a nice open flat long road with no traffic (I live close to the country) and I find a spot to start and then I do WOT blasts to about 70 and use DataMaster's Quarter Mile Calculator to find out how fast my 0-60 was. Rather than using a boost launch and beating on my drive train I use about a 10" Vacuum launch, just enough to preload the drive train, and much easier to remain consistent. This has worked well for me but I am by no means an "expert tuner".

As for the O2 I agree it is hard to know what to do. On one hand lots of people say it is useless and unreliable. But on the other hand you can find those same people commenting on a run and say "Judging by your O2 mV you are running lean". I think the stock O2 is a poor man's tuning tool because few have the means to run the "proper" Wide-Band O2, but everyone has the stock O2 sensor. Like JoeLutz, my truck generally runs better with less knock as the O2 mV increase. For me when they are at 870, 890, my truck is knocking more than 5*. When they are at 920 or better, my knock is dissipating down near zero.

One last thing, I would try to get a more permanent gauge setup. It sounds like you are rigging yours up each time you test FP. This could eventually wear on the "schraeder valve" on the fuel rail which is known to be fragile and prone to breakage. My truck's previous owner installed a mechanical gauge permanently mounted under the hood. The in-cab electrical is the best option (although more costly), but even what I've got has to be better and more consistent than hooking up a gauge to the test port every time. Just my thoughts, hope it helps.
 

kwick6

Donating Member
Turning up the fuel press, running rich, to lower your knock is more than likely just covering up ignition problems.
 

Hu Ryde

Donating Member
How new is your Ultimate Chip? I just got mine and it seems to do the same things. Lot's of knock a low fp reading. I have tried a couple of things. It's gotten to the point that I ordered a accufab regulator and new plug wires.
 

SeattleSy#1255

Category 5 Conservative
Kwick6,

I don't believe this to be the case...maybe, but i have new plugs, new wires, new conrad cap/rotor...I also just replaced the fuel filter the other night, but haven't had a chance to take a datafile because now i got another prob...That damn wastgate solenoid prob...now i'm only running base boost...prolly not related, but just another prob i gotta figure out...But as it remains, it seems logical to get this fueling problem under control first before worry about the boost!

Tooky,

It seems that the conclusion i am coming to about 02 readings from datamaster is to use it as a VERY GENERAL tuning tool...watch for extreme readings, and watch for rapid changes at idle etc. to assure o2 sensor is at least working correctly.

Hu Ryde,
the Ultimate is about 1 year old...i'm not even considering it being a prob. untill i'm at the bottom of my list...I think it is working fine....Also, shouldn't you have a AFPR on that truck before you put the ultimate in? Or do you mean your replaceing an AFPR that you already have with a different one?

Still open to comments about the fueling prob. Like i said, the fuel filter is replaced, but have got a file on it yet...Would dirty injectors really cause this big of prob?

Thanks for the responses!
 

kwick6

Donating Member
Well all I am saying is that cranking on the fp can mask other potential issues.

I am sure you have heard about the combustion chamber design of the stock heads, and that they are prone to detonation.

Timing in our trucks is a sensitive issue.
It could be a beneficial to retard your base timing 1-2 degrees.

It could also help if you had the ability to go in and pull some timing out of the chip when you see knock.

Scott
 

smeagol

Active member
The Ultimate is made to run with higher FP, so you need an AFPR and Walbro pump to run it. Should start with base FP at 47-50psi.

It sounds like Seattle's truck is running lean (based on knock & 02 values) at WOT, i'd check to make sure the fuel pressure is keeping up at WOT, and that the fuel filter is fresh.
 

smeagol

Active member
Another thing - 02's

NO you can't say for sure that you should have 920 mv, or that 920mv is about 12:1 AFR.
(FYI it will toggle FAST when in closed loop, warmed up - cruise, idle etc)

What you can generally do is get an indication of performance or safety from those values. If your truck *generally* runs good when you see 02s at 950 at WOT, and the next day you are having problems and you see 02s in the 400s... you know something is up with fueling.

We just fixed a problem with the Braphoon (before it was launched into a swamp) where the 02s would drop immediately in boost, and it would pop & sputter. Checked FP in boost, it was not keeping up 100%.. but seemed to be doing ok (hard to determine to the exact psi when you have a gauge taped to the windshield). Swapped fuel filter and solved the problem instantly. A busted FPR will show the same symptoms, as will an FPR that is not getting an accurate signal (if you are at 15psi of boost, but the FP is not rising at the FPR because the signal to the FPR has a leak, or is only at 5psi..).
 

SeattleSy#1255

Category 5 Conservative
Kwick6,

I hear ya on the masking thing, but i origanally thought that the actual problem was to do with the fueling...Thats why i thgouth having to turn it up to 74 psi was crazy...I don't really have a way at watching for FP to rise with boost, because i don't have a gauge in the cab...But good point...and ya i have heard about the detonation probs. with the stock heads...don't knwo much abou it though...but i don't think it is the cause of getting a spark retard of 15-18 OUCH! but what do i know, not much...

Brian G,
Like i mentioned above, i don't really have a way to see if FP is keeping up with boost, because i don't have a gauge in the cab? Is there another way of doing it? Good point abou the signal to the FPR, how can i check this? The FPR is pretty new, but ya never know. I think i'm understanding the 02 thing...use it ass a basic tool so to speak, while watching for changes in it comapred to how the truck is running i.e. good or like crap.

A few more questoins...Roland and i where thinking that if could be something as simple as a kingk in the fuel line somewhere...So i'll check for that...Also, he raised a good point, what ya guys think of this? Perhaps the fueling is adequate but the motor itself isn't using it "properly" so to speak? Any thoughts on this? Also, i got a new fuel filter in, but again haven't had a chance to see what it will do because now i got boost probs. Thus, i can't mimic the same amount of boost, because my wastgate solenoid is toast i think and i can't get past base boost.
 

smeagol

Active member
You can put a cheap fuel pressure gauge on the fuel rail and read out the gauge thru the windshield. This is the best bet to show if you have a physical fuel supply problem.

If you don't have fuel pressure keeping up at boost, then you have to determine why that is..

leak to the FPR line - use a mityvac or similar to mimic boost pressure to test

bad FPR - changing the fuel pressure and the above test should help determining this

kinked fuel line preventing higher pressure - turn your pressure up and see if the pump can raise pressure high enough.
 

kwick6

Donating Member
When your trying to get an aftermarket chip to work with your truck, you have to remember that not every engine is going to like the timing in the chip.
Do you have the same problems with the stock chip?

You have done quite a bit to resolve ignition problems. These trucks become more and more difficult to tune once you start adding things. I would recommend pulling the ultimate and go back to a 2 bar and see if the knock goes away. Getting your truck back to stock will be the easiest way to troubleshoot, and you won't be buying all kinds of stuff to throw at it to fix it.

Retarding the timing a couple degrees shouldn't hurt performance, but you also want to verify TDC on #1, very accurately.

Scott


<font size=-1>[ This Message was edited by: kwick6 on 2002-01-29 17:11 ]</font>
 
Top