Low Boost DM File (SEL777)

Sean Krupa

Moderator
Steve (SEL777) has been having some trouble with his Boost being low. After he installed his 20g turbo, the Boost hasn't been to 14psi no matter what you do with the WG rod. He bought the HD wastegate from the GP and the boost is still low at around 8psi. He also isn't running a Solenoid which the guy from the GP said not to use.

Steve will write in here, just giving a quick summary.

SteveDM.jpg


Any tips/suggestions would be appreciated!
 

RealFastV6

@jb_and_his_coffee
Re: Low Boost DM File (SEL777)

Ok, I'll bite. If he's not using the solenoid- what's he using to control boost?

If he has the wastegate plugged directly into the turbine housing (or other manifold pressure source), and the spring on the HD wastegate actuator is 8lbs (which is probably right), then I'd expect he'd see exactly what we're seeing.

If you're not going to use the factory solenoid, then you need a boost controller. Adjusting the rod isn't boost control.
 
Last edited:

WyoSyclone

Active member
Re: Low Boost DM File (SEL777)

Ok, I'll bite. If he's not using the solenoid- what's he using to control boost?

If he has the wastegate plugged directly into the turbine housing (or other manifold pressure source), and the spring on the HD wastegate actuator is 8lbs (which is probably right), then I'd expect he'd see exactly what we're seeing.

If you're not going to use the factory solenoid, then you need a boost controller. Adjusting the rod isn't boost control.

x2.... you can see that the ECM is commanding more boost (100% WGDC) to try and meet the 14.3 target. I'm surprised the boost curve is that flat with it set up the way it is. It should be pretty easy to tune in a flat boost curve at the desired PSI. Get the solenoid hooked back up and see what happens (get the rod adjusted back to spec).
 

Sean Krupa

Moderator
Re: Low Boost DM File (SEL777)

I said before to install the solenoid to see what happens. Erik specifically says that you are unable to use the Stock solenoid to control boost with his HD Actuator. So IDK. His stock turbo made 14psi all day. After the 20g install, boost only hit 8psi. Steve will chime in later for more info.

http://www.syty.net/forums/showthread.php?t=78765
 

sytyguy

Moderated User
Re: Low Boost DM File (SEL777)

You can use a manual controller or use the stock solenoid and tweak the control settings. Our solenoid is an electronic bleed valve.....nothing special or incompatible about it. Might need to money with WG settings to fine tune, but to say it won't work with a particular WG is dead wrong.
 

SEL777

One of 101
Re: Low Boost DM File (SEL777)

When this was first installed it was with the stock 20G WG, and the boost solenoid hooked up.I ended going with the Forge WG, since I could not get more than 10# with the 20G the way it was. Like Sean mentioned, I followed the instructions Erik made in the GP for the Forge WG once I decided to spend the cash on that. Erik said that without messing with the WG solenoid settings in the computer that it would not run right. He has used a few of these on stockers, and 20G's w/o the issues I'm having. In additon to this I spent countless tries to adjust the rod...but as mentioned above this is not really doing anything to my boost. The hole for the pin on the rod was too large too, so I drilled the correct size to just slip on the pin, eliminating any play. I changed to the larger WG spring and did not see any changes in boost either. The only other thing I can think to mention is that when the stocker turbo was connected, the factory boost gauge and my electric AM boost were in sync, now my stocker shows 15#, and the AM shows 8-9#. These are the readings you see in the file we did Friday. And until then I did not really know what I was getting 8-9 or 15#. I want to get to 15#, but then be able to turn it up a bit once I save a few more bucks for Hoods code 59 kit, and WB02, (I got my ALKY kit already). So for now I didn't want to mess with the computer settings if I could help it. I think I'll try to plug the boost solenoid back this weekend in to see if that makes any difference. I'll ask Erik to chime in too. As always, thanks in advance for the suggestions and help.
 
Last edited:

sytyguy

Moderated User
Re: Low Boost DM File (SEL777)

Without the ability to modify WG control settings, you may be inviting a unwelcome guest by hooking up the solenoid. Won't know till you try, but I'd ease into boost.
 

JSM

Active member
Re: Low Boost DM File (SEL777)

Parts have been changed, and the tune will need changed accordingly. It can work and work well if done right.

The ECM can't control boost with things unhooked.
 

0966Sy

Code what?
Re: Low Boost DM File (SEL777)

I dont know what realy could be the problem. I've installed three of these wastegate's and have had no problems with boost control. Im using the blue spring wich yeilds me 14/15psi steady. I have no problem building boost either with a stock TC on a 14cm 20g, spools just as fast as a stock turbo.

I know your DM file is showing 8psi steady, do you have a manual boost guage? The first thing i would check is that you have your preload set right on the gate. With the flapper closed on the exhuast side of the turbo you should only have to pull the rod back 1/16-1/8th of an inch max. Give or take 1 revolution of the turnbuckle to make a .5-1psi adjustment. A mitty vac handheld vacuum and pressure pump is a good tool to check the wg is functioning properly.

Hook the handheld pump up to the gate installed and check what psi it begins to open and that it does not bind when the rod extends. Im using the blue spring and i dont believe it should start to open till about 12psi. You would have to check with mike at forge. I would deffinatly make sure you have the spring installed correctly inside the housing, The spring is cone shaped and only goes one way. If you have a leak past the cup/seal inside the housing it could cause the gate to help itself hold closed. There is a plug on the spring side of the housing, used only for a dual port option. Might want to remove it and see if you blowing your pressure past the cup, it would then seap out the oposing side of the housing past the cup/seal. Before you remove the plug or tear the gate apart check to see if it holds pressure and does not bleed down. It's been a while sence i had them apart but i believe they are sealed by an o-ring.

Dig made it clear how the stock boost control solinoid is designed to work with the duty cycle programmed in the ECM. Hooking up the factory solinoid is not going to work.

We want to make sure everything is functioning correctly with the new wastegate before we go suspecting other things. If it means tearing it down on the bench again and installing the old gate prior yeilding only 10psi. We want to find out what is causing the turbo to only produce 8psi. When you changed from the yellow to the blue spring did you get a differance in boost level?

We are doing what any intregral gated PTE turbo kit is doing to control boost. We are using a "spring pressure" to control our boost.

The factory 20g turbo begins to bleed of turbo pressure at 5psi, thats why we cant build more than 8-10psi with the damn thing. Adding a higher spring rate that will allow the gate not to open untill 12-14psi will yeild faster spool up and the boost level desired. I think we are having a problem with the wastegate on your truck.
The gate is the slave and controls the turbo of how much boost it produces, unless the turbo is worn and will not produce above 10psi and takes to long to get there.

I will stay informed as i have had absolute good results with these gates and would like you to enjoy the results i am having.
 

It's just a six

Super Member
Re: Low Boost DM File (SEL777)

Im using the blue spring wich yeilds me 14/15psi steady. I have no problem building boost either with a stock TC on a 14cm 20g, spools just as fast as a stock turbo.


Dig made it clear how the stock boost control solinoid is designed to work with the duty cycle programmed in the ECM. Hooking up the factory solinoid is not going to work.

No matter what spring is used in a 20 G 14 CM turbo, it will not spool as fast as a stock turbo & stock torque converter.:2cents:
There is & there will be a delay, you have to wait for it to spool up.
Once it (the 20G turbo) sees boost it is OK, but IMO, it's a bit lazy as compared to a stock turbo & even more so when running a stock torque converter that only brake stalls to 2100 RPM.

With a stock turbo I could hold the brakes & boost to 20 PSI or more,, & that's w/a stock wastegate actuator of what 6 PSI ?
So, even when the wastegate valve was open when I have brake boosted to 20 or more psi, it was not problem to boost @ all even w/the wastegate valve open & yes it was open.

I made it clear also,,, that you can hook up a different actuator & use the stock boost control solinoid, I ran it this way for years. My base boost pressure on my actuator is 15 PSI.
Yes, the factory set-up is more accurate @ controlling boost pressures, but just saying there are ways to get around this.
The main problem w/the stock boost control working correctly when boosting higher that stock or free flowing exhaust set-ups is the stock wastegate valve is too small & or the hole is too small to vent enough exhaust to control the boost.

It ( the factory solinoid) did control the boost pressure & @ different settings on my Ultimate chip.
All done in conjunction w/the 15 psi actuator.

This is my personal experience & my opinion.
 
Last edited:

JSM

Active member
Re: Low Boost DM File (SEL777)

The factory 20g turbo begins to bleed of turbo pressure at 5psi, thats why we cant build more than 8-10psi with the damn thing. Adding a higher spring rate that will allow the gate not to open untill 12-14psi will yeild faster spool up and the boost level desired. I think we are having a problem with the wastegate on your truck.

This is not totally true. Yes if nothing is hooked up 4-5psi is seen, but that is the BASE boost or as you should know as the minimum controllable boost you can run. Now we add in pressure onto the WG canister and that level goes up. I've run 27psi+ on a stock canister.

I don't blame the new canister, it is probably just fine. It has a base boost of say 14psi. Perfect if your minimum boost to run is 14psi. From there using a solenoid and logic (either from stock ECM, manual boost controller, aftermarket) we can increase the boost by adding pressure to the canister basically a 2nd spring pressure. This is simply done by holding the WG canister CLOSED. Manual boost controllers/bleed valves do the same thing.

When you see the ECM commanding 100% DC that is saying to put FULL pressure behind the canister. Stock ECM logic then knows after boost reaches X level to reduce the WGDC so that boost does not overshoot.

I could go on about boost control but I see WAY too often confusion on how the logic works and blame the ECM/WG, etc.

The fact is if there was a problem prior and his old WG canister was good, a gold plated aftermarket will not help one bit.

As a test run boost pressure direct to the WG and go for a drive, BE CAREFUL as if the system is working you should get boost very quickly and exceed 30psi if your not careful.

Now unhook it and do the same test, you should have whatever boost the spring pressure gives, or minimum boost. If you don't get MAX and MIN with these tests you have mechanical issues and no boost controller in the world will fix it.
 

0966Sy

Code what?
Re: Low Boost DM File (SEL777)

This is not totally true. Yes if nothing is hooked up 4-5psi is seen, but that is the BASE boost or as you should know as the minimum controllable boost you can run. Now we add in pressure onto the WG canister and that level goes up. I've run 27psi+ on a stock canister.

I was talking about what pressure the wg begins to open on a stock 20g actuator.

As a test run boost pressure direct to the WG and go for a drive, BE CAREFUL as if the system is working you should get boost very quickly and exceed 30psi if your not careful.

If you run compressor output directly to the waste gate you are going to get only your spring pressure on your wastegate. A stock turbo begins to open at 2psi, a 20g gate opens at 5psi. You would get maybe a few more psi than spring pressure but certainly not 30psi.

Now unhook it and do the same test, you should have whatever boost the spring pressure gives, or minimum boost. If you don't get MAX and MIN with these tests you have mechanical issues and no boost controller in the world will fix it.

Now unhooking your compressor output from the wastegate is going to cause a leak at the compressor if you dont plug the line, and will certainly give you max output pressure of the turbo not using the wastegate. Keep in mind he is not using the factory solinoid to control boost.
 

0966Sy

Code what?
Re: Low Boost DM File (SEL777)

This is not totally true. Yes if nothing is hooked up 4-5psi is seen, but that is the BASE boost or as you should know as the minimum controllable boost you can run. Now we add in pressure onto the WG canister and that level goes up. I've run 27psi+ on a stock canister.

Adding pressure to the wastegate opens the wastegate, venting more exhuast past the turbine yeilding LESS turbo output (boost/psi). We control the output of the turbo with pressure to the wastegate, adding more psi will open the wastegate till it cant open anymore. A manual regulator to a wastegate works this way, your regulating how much pressure you want to apply to the gate to control boost.
 

Sean Krupa

Moderator
Re: Low Boost DM File (SEL777)

Steve put the Solenoid back on, but the Boost is still around 8-9psi. I thought it had to do with the stock chip limiting it to base boost the 1st time you go WOT. We did another pull and same boost.

We got back to his house and I wanted to check if the WG was sticking. The rod is soo tight that you can't get it off. So their should be no reason why he is only getting 8-9psi. I think the next thing to try is another Solenoid. I checked his 20g for play and it's fine.

Any suggestions would be appreciated.
 

It's just a six

Super Member
Re: Low Boost DM File (SEL777)

Have you looked @ the wastegate valve or the housing where the hole is?

The wastegate valve could be cracked or missing a piece or housing could be cracked.

Wastegate valve maybe not sealing, sitting cocked/crooked?

Have you tried to safety wire the wastegate valve closed & see if it can overboost? If you want to try that, be carefull, it should overboost very quickly.
 
Last edited:

Sean Krupa

Moderator
Re: Low Boost DM File (SEL777)

Steve has that Billet Actuator on his 20g. He has it really tight. After the run, I couldn't even get the rod of the pin to check if the flapper was sticking. Theirs no way that the flapper would be able to open with that much pressure against it.

Steve will have to inspect his Housing to see if their is any cracks. It's a shame he can't get the boost to 14psi. The stock turbo hit that no problem.
 

It's just a six

Super Member
Re: Low Boost DM File (SEL777)

Did he port the hole for the wastegate valve?

It's possible to port/open the hole up too much causing the wastegate valve to sit cocked & never seal.
 

SEL777

One of 101
Re: Low Boost DM File (SEL777)

Man, the 8-9 now feels pretty good.....but, I want15#. Then maybe 18-20#. So, the recap is stocker turbo to 15# all day. Switch to 20G w/it's stock wastegate and boost solenoid connected and I got 8-9. Change to the new wastegate w/o the solenoid = 8-9...adjust the rod lengths no change, change WG spring to Blue= no change. Boost solenoid re-connected to 20G, and again no change.
 

It's just a six

Super Member
Re: Low Boost DM File (SEL777)

Updates, did you safety wire the wastgate shut? It should over boost like crazy.
Take off the downpipe to look @ the wastegate valve yet?
 
Top