Methanol VS. Methanol & water.

It's just a six

Super Member
I was wondering if anyone has tried the 50/50 methanol & water then switched to 100% methanol & could telll me there findings when it came to controlling detonation.
Which one worked better controlling detonation???
Thanks :tup:
 

0260IN3

Engine Builder
Re: Methanol VS. Methanol & water.

It's just a six said:
I was wondering if anyone has tried the 50/50 methanol & water then switched to 100% methanol & could telll me there findings when it came to controlling detonation.
Which one worked better controlling detonation???
Thanks :tup:


Straight meth for sure. Water is not a fuel and can cause stubles and hesitations. Methanol is a fuel (very high octane as well) so it cools amd burns well and is a better cooler than water anyways.

We played with this and methanol is way better hands down.
 

Jer

Don't taze me bro!
Re: Methanol VS. Methanol & water.

Yeah, funny how some on other forums will argue endlessly though that 50/50 is better because you get better cooling from water than methanol. Uhhh.. methanol is a solvent. Pour a little methanol on one hand and then water on the other hand and tell me which is colder. This coldness is caused by the advanced evaporate characteristics of alcohol.

100% meth for me!
 

bezerk

New member
Re: Methanol VS. Methanol & water.

water also spreads the feul better, and gives you a higher compression cause of the steam.
 

It's just a six

Super Member
Re: Methanol VS. Methanol & water.

It seems that we cannot agree which one works better here.
I am going to run straight methanol & see what happens.
Thanks :tup:
 

scotts4

ADDICTED
Re: Methanol VS. Methanol & water.

i run meth i have never tried 50/50 but i just dont like to spray anything that doesent burn into my engine . I am sure it works fine but that is just me .
 

Lynn D. Brown

New member
Re: Methanol VS. Methanol & water.

Either is OK, but water has much superior heat transfer properties - the best of any normal liquid. I have published these properties before, so they're in the archives somewhere. MeOH is an organic liquid and essentially all of them have inferior properties to water.
 

JSM

Active member
Re: Methanol VS. Methanol & water.

Lynn D. Brown said:
Either is OK, but water has much superior heat transfer properties - the best of any normal liquid. I have published these properties before, so they're in the archives somewhere. MeOH is an organic liquid and essentially all of them have inferior properties to water.

On paper I am sure you are correct. In actualy testing from my experience the theory doesn't hold water. (sorry pun intended).

Water helps with knock.

Meth helps with knock AND octane.

In the end meth in my tuning is always faster, less knock and less heat.

I do live in Indiana though, and being I am not from here this place is different than the rest of the world for sure.
 

Robert Lone

MUTANT
Re: Methanol VS. Methanol & water.

I think I'll try 100% water! Yeah, that'll work great!!!

Actually I've seen it done on a blown gas Keith Black Hemi. Since it was a gasoline class, Meth in the system would have gotten him disqualified. When questioned about the contents of the system, he opened the peck-cock on the res into a paper cup and drank the stuff. He then told the tech guy where he could shove it, walked behind the trailer, puked, and spent the night in the ER. 100% water I tell you!!!:)
 
Re: Methanol VS. Methanol & water.

I copied this from another site...

Water injection properly setup, slightly re-writes the rule book. Almost all internal combustion engines are knock limited for power. If you put a high enough octane fuel in them, and make the appropriate changes to take advantage of that octane you can substantially increase power output.

In typical street applications you only get small gains with WI because most people do not optimize the tune and engine build for the higher effective octane. In boosted applicatons you can use all that octane by bumping up the boost.

WI does several things many people are not aware of besides increase effective octane.

It reduces negative work performed on the compression stroke because the compression is more isothermal than adiabatic, ie the charge does not heat up as much under compression due to the high latent heat of evaporation of the water and alcohol injected. This returns some "free power" that other wise would have been wasted.

It lowers combustion temperatures and raises the effective octane of the fuel air charge. This gives two confilicting results, (1) -- your peak cylinder pressures drop a bit, but (2) the engine has less thermal load so it can now be pushed to levels of performance that would have melted valves or triggered runaway pre-ignition before.

It also has a little appreciated side benefit that following combustion there are more combustion products produced, this means cylinder pressure does not fall as quickly as the piston descends on the power stroke. Your effective power stroke is longer, so again another small incremental power increase.

It also slightly slows combustion time, so it moves the peak pressure time to later in the power stroke, depending on the engine this may be good for mechanical effeciency or require more ignition advance to get peak cylinder pressure to occur at the proper time.

The above is where most people end their tuning. If you use WI with a rich fuel mixture it will absolutely cost you power. To make power with WI you need to run fuel mixtures that would turn your pistons into molten slugs without the WI. Ignition timing, compression ratios and manifold pressures also need to be pushed into areas that most people would not even consider based on normal tuning experience.


For example when NACA was investigating WI for use in ADI systems (Anti- Detonation Injection) on WWII military piston engine aircraft here are some of the numbers they came up with.

Tests were run on a 6.65:1 compression ratio dual spark plug 4 valve engine.

The convention when these tests were run was to use water injection scaled to the fuel used. IE a 0.5:1 ADI rate ment you were injection .5 lb of water for each pound of fuel the engine was using. As a result water usage actually drops as you lean out the mixture. The also prefered to specify mixture in terms of fuel air ratio rather than the common air fuel ratio used in the automotive performance community.

Report E5E18
The following tests were run at a fuel air ratio of 0.08, inlet air pressure 50 in-hg absolute (about 10psi boost).
Peak imep psi
internal coolant water only
gasoline + 0 internal coolant/fuel ratio = 229 psi spark timing of 31.5 deg
gasoline +.2 internal coolant/fuel ratio = 241 at spark timing of 31.8 deg
gasoline +.4 internal coolant/fuel ratio = 250 at spark timing of 42.5 deg

Simply adding timing and increasing internal coolant rate was worth about 9% increase in imep. In effect you are creating a synthetic compression ratio by over advancing the spark.

Higher ratios were tried but did not return any additional power.

With a 50/50 mix of water and ethanol alcohol they got the following.

Gasoline + 0 internal coolant/fuel ratio = 229 psi at spark timing of 29.5
gasoline + .2 internal coolant/fuel ratio = 236 psi at 30 deg
gasoline + .4 internal coolant/fuel ratio = 233 psi at 31.5 deg
gasoline + .6 internal coolant/fuel ratio = 235 psi at 34 deg
gasoline + .8 internal coolant/fuel ratio = 237 psi at 37.6 deg

As you can see above the alcohol mix needs less timing to get to peak imep because of its faster burn speed, but in this case produces slightly less output.

Note that these tests were all run with the typical fuel air mixture you might see on any street engine, of 12.5:1 AFR, 0.08 Fuel air ratio.

Now lets look at what happens in a WI application if you lean the fuel air mixture out.
Data from NACA report 812

On gasoline only peak in imep was achieved at 2 different fuel air ratios.
lean max imep = 285 psi @ 0.05 FAR ( 20:1 AFR)
rich max imep = 290 psi @ 0.082 FAR ( 12.2:1 AFR)

with 100% water mix at coolant to fuel ratio of .5:1 we get:
lean max imep = 340 psi @ 0.06 FAR (16.66:1 FAR)
rich max imep = 360-365 psi @ 0.105 FAR ( 9.52:1 FAR)

on 70%/30% methanol water mix at coolant to fuel ratio of .5:1 we get:
lean max imep = 580 psi @ 0.044 FAR ( 22.7:1 FAR)
rich max imep = approx 460 psi from 0.075 - 0.09 FAR ( 13.3 - 11.11)

The engines running with internal coolants could run much higher manifold pressures to achieve these numbers. Knock limited manifold pressure for the 70/30 water alcohol mix went up to 150 in-hg (75psi), on pure water they got to the same manifold pressures at slightly leaner mixtures.

The maximium relative power ratio that they achieved in this test on 100% water internal coolant, was at a coolant to fuel ratio of 0.6:1 = 1.52, on 70/30 methanol water at a coolant to fuel injection ratio of 0.08:1 they got to 1.80 relative power ratio.

Most tuners would not even think of attempting these tuning numbers so this is, for the most part unexplored territitory outside the turbocharged imports, unlimited air racing, and tractor pull environments.
 

supersports10

New member
Re: Methanol VS. Methanol & water.

i use e-85 ETHANOL in my sy in the fuel tank, and let me tell you the power on t3 is friggin amazing!!

SS
 

HotRudyRod

New member
Re: Methanol VS. Methanol & water.

I've used only denatured rubbing alcohol 100% so far and it's given me great results and its only 2dls a quart here in Mexico. Once i get the truck runnin again and a better lap top cable to run DM and instal the MSD knock monitor i'll start tunning the system and tryin different types/mixes of alcohol and solvents.
I'm wondering if paint thiner will work better than alcohol or meth, i know it cools up very quick as it evaporates but again i never seen methanol. Any opinions? Thanks.
 
Last edited:

Robert Lone

MUTANT
Re: Methanol VS. Methanol & water.

David told me that he used to add VM&P Naptha to the fuel tank on my truck when he was going to crank the boost up manually. He said it "slowed" the burn rate of the fuel/air mix enough to get rid of the knock thus making mo-powah...

Again, I really need to get him on here if he ever gets off the drugs... What a waste.
 

HotRudyRod

New member
Re: Methanol VS. Methanol & water.

Hummm, that might work. I'll have in consideration, thanks again.

Ps. IMHO David's personal life we should leave for reality TV or rehab programs tho.
 
Top