new MSD 6A... more knock !!!!

typhoon4ever

New member
this sucks. after spending $140 on a 6A,i run the truck with datamaster and the truck is knocking more than before. When i disconnect it and run stock ignition, knock is reduced. I have the original gm coil.
 

SyTyJedi

Jedi Council
Could it be interference from the MSD that is affecting the knock sensor?

I recall Daron having an odd problem with his MSD that led it to being mounted somewhere near the frame on the pass side and he also added some extra grounds.

Was this MSD related or something totally different?

Are you using the MSD plugin harness?

I would maybe swap coils with another truck. What condition is your cap, rotor, plugs and wires in? The hotter spark may be making an ignition problem more apparent, and cause more knock?



Tyler
 

UNIsackV6

Member
On 2002-01-02 21:40, typhoonrider wrote:
this sucks. after spending $140 on a 6A,i run the truck with datamaster and the truck is knocking more than before. When i disconnect it and run stock ignition, knock is reduced. I have the original gm coil.

Remember what the MSD's purpose is, to amplify your ignition pulses. So if something is wrong in the first place the MSD will only make it worse. Is this bad? Short run yes, long run it is good. Why? Because it is uncovering something that is wrong anyways and hopefully you fix it before it causes other problems. Good job on the Scantool keep that thing on as much as possible and your truck will live. If you take the MSD off and go back to the stock set up your knock should drop back down to where it was. Do like Tyler suggests, check ALL ignition components, 3 times if you have to it is the SYTY curse. We've seen small cracks in plugs cause problems so don't rule anything out when it comes to ignition. Ignition help for the SYTY community is on its way, more to come on that later.
 

Daron

Active member
Ryan is very correct here.. Check and double check. Not sure I would MSD an already knocking motor. Tyler recalls the problems I had with getting power to the MSD. My truck was very picky about where power for the MSD could be accessed. The instructions say go as close to the battery as you can with the positive lead, for good reason. I also had to experiment with ground locations and ended up making a fresh ground on the frame.
 

tyndago

New member
Sy/Ty's have some weird ignition issues. The MSD helped my truck .

Like the other guys said - I think it is probably helping to bring out an ignition issue...plugs , wires , cap ,rotor.

MSD can be hooked up wrong if you dont have the plug in harness. You can hook it up backwards... could cause an issue
 

UNIsackV6

Member
MSD can be hooked up wrong if you dont have the plug in harness. You can hook it up backwards... could cause an issue

I hate when I put the square plug in the round hole!!!! Very good point double check your work. Change one thing at a time if possible when switching ignition components because ideally like to find out what was actually causing you problems so you can avoid it if possible in the future. Consult with Rojo Canyanero or Daron Harvistingerer as they have lots of good info on wires and plugs :cool:
 

Tooky

Serious about performance
check ALL ignition components, 3 times if you have to it is the SYTY curse. We've seen small cracks in plugs cause problems so don't rule anything out when it comes to ignition.
That's it! That could be my own problem. I have checked my ignition parts once and twice and some three times. But not ALL three times, I suppose I foolishly thought that my efforts were already enough. Ryan I will owe you one in spring if this is the fix. :smile:
Ignition help for the SYTY community is on its way, more to come on that later.
It's later now, any more info on what's going on? Can you email me? I wanted to private mail you but you don't have an email link. Thanks.
 

bdubb

I am teh kingpin!
maybe if you didnt piss of BG and other chicago members you would of been imformed on it.
 

smeagol

Active member
It's just running LS1 coils on a Syty.

If it works, we'll post details. No rocket science, just parts & some creative fabrication labor.
 

JoeLutz

New member
Don't the older FWD 3.8s with coil packs get the signal off a crank sensor? If you do away with the distributor, whats going to drive the oil pump? Just curious. I remember seeing some type of aftermarket coil pack conversion that used a kind of dummy distributor that drove the oil pump and had a Hall sender for the engine speed and position. Just was flat on top with no rotor or dist cap.


<font size=-1>[ This Message was edited by: JoeLutz on 2002-01-23 18:56 ]</font>
 

UNIsackV6

Member
On 2002-01-23 18:33, JoeLutz wrote:
Don't the older FWD 3.8s with coil packs get the signal off a crank sensor? If you do away with the distributor, whats going to drive the oil pump? Just curious. I remember seeing some type of aftermarket coil pack conversion that used a kind of dummy distributor that drove the oil pump and had a Hall sender for the engine speed and position. Just was flat on top with no rotor or dist cap.

Not sure about the FWD 3.8 but everything is still in development mode but the idea will be to make it as simple as possible without changing a bunch of parts. So it will keep the stock distributor to drive the oil pump. Chitown trucks are starting to come to life again so this should move forward quicker.
 

smeagol

Active member
The computer/ignition module NEEDS to know cam signal, either actual signal or determined via other variables (don't ask).

As far as I know, all the 3.8s used crank & cam signals. The eDist to be used with the DIS setup we are doing WILL need a cam signal. Just has to have it. No other way to signal to the computer that it is at ignition TDC and not exhaust TDC.. make sense? Also have to keep your stock 'crank' signal from the distributor. I know that sounds weird, but it really is just a crank signal, since it just signals RPM.
 

Syclone#892

Member
Hey BG what do you think about MSD's new coil pack setup. It says it works with 6 and 8 cylinders, has a dummy distributor for oil pump and cam sensor (thats what I got out of it on there website, msdignition.com) and I believe you can hook it up to a laptop to fine tune it. Oh I had emailed you and wondered if you had gotten around to it yet, Thanks.
 

JoeLutz

New member
On 2002-01-29 20:03, typhoonrider wrote:
whats the advantage of a coil pack over the stock distrabutor?
No cap or rotor to give trouble and usually beter spark and timing control.
 
Top