Nitrided/Cryoed crank question

AXXE

Member
I am building a motor with 412 cam, vortecs and I am not sure what turbo yet. I am hoping to run mid 11s. How necessary is it to get the stock crank treated?
 

Tooky

Serious about performance
Ryan, are you aware of some type of stock crank failures that no one else is?
 

TurboManiacal

Donating Member
No,

But I am still waiting for an explanation from Waller on what he said before I send $300 and a core crank his way for Nitriding that he recommended. But thanks for deleting my questions (mod corner)
 

myclone

Donating Member
Sigo said:
No,

But I am still waiting for an explanation from Waller on what he said before I send $300 and a core crank his way for Nitriding that he recommended. But thanks for deleting my questions (mod corner)

What questions? If ya dont mind me butting in I can offer what I know about cryo and nitriding..

Nitriding is a surface treatment for the most part. Im not sure exactly how the process works but after pestering several engine builders Ive came up with a general idea. When a part is nitrided the treatment increases its resistance to wear as in the surface is now "harder" than it was originally. I dont really know what nitriding can do for the torsional stresses that a crank shaft would see so I will leave that open for someone who does know. My personal theory is that by nitriding you increase the crank shafts resistance to wear but since its only a surface treatment you retain some of the needed "bendability" of the crank. Also keep in mind that since nitriding supposedly only goes ~.030" deep if the crank is reground a significant amount from multiple rebuilds or what have you it will have to be retreated.

Cryo treating seems to be a little tougher to get straight answers out of the ppl that do it. Ive read a HUGE amount on it and spoke with an engineer from the company 300 Degrees Below about its pros and cons. The fellow I spoke to coroborated the studies Ive read about the resistance to wear that cryo treating does but couldnt give me a straight answer on if it improved the torsional strength of something like a crank shaft. I questioned him concerning what would happen since theoretically the crank would be more brittle after treatment so it would seem to me that it would possibly not be a good idea for a crank shaft which needs to have some "bendability". He couldnt give me a solid answer wheather that was true or not but rather said that was one way to look at it. So, I dunno really.. I prolly will have it done but to be honest I dont know if it will really help that much as Im not a metalergist(sp?).
 
Well, ill add what i have found out from my loacal machine shop that has a very good reputation here in Houston, they said nitrading a stock cast crank really isnt worth the expense, and they have never had a crank or other parts crioyed, but the process seems to be big with the import crowd. They said the best theing for a stock crank is to have it shot peened, best bang for the buck, and that a cast crank is alot stronger than most people think, as long as you have good rods and pistons, or at least good rod bolts in your stock rods.

So I was going to have my stock crank frozen, nitraded and shot peened, but now i think ill only have it shot peened, unless somebody can shed somemore light on this.

Oh, and i forgot to add, that i heard the criyo was suppose to improve grain structure, so that is more with the flow of the crank, kinda like a forged crank, if that makes any sense. :eek: :eek:
 
4C FED said:
http://www.hekimianracing.com/cryomain.html



That makes for some interesting reading, maybe it helpsandmaybe it dont, but for 200 bucks plus shipping to get a V6 crank done, may not be to bad.....i guess. According to them it helps with surface hardness as well, along with stree relief.


They have some nice thermo and bearing coatings that sound pretty good, and there prices seem resonable to me
 
Well, ive only really heard of the import crown really being into that sort of stuff, in my years of building engines and various cars and trucks ive only heard of the nitrading and shot peening for stress relief, but have never dont it to any of the motors ive built, but none have been asked to do what im looking for from this little v6, 280 cubes of fire.
 

4C FED

Absolutum Dominium
HotRodV6 said:
4C FED said:
http://www.hekimianracing.com/cryomain.html



That makes for some interesting reading, maybe it helpsandmaybe it dont, but for 200 bucks plus shipping to get a V6 crank done, may not be to bad.....i guess. According to them it helps with surface hardness as well, along with stree relief.


They have some nice thermo and bearing coatings that sound pretty good, and there prices seem resonable to me

Nitriding=surface treatment.
Cryo=all the way through. Brittle? Maybe. I think of it as being a denser structure after the cryo.

I had my crank cryo'ed & coated along with the bearings.
For me it was a cheaper alternative to a forged (it'll be delivered when?) crank.
 
Nitriding=surface treatment.
Cryo=all the way through. Brittle? Maybe. I think of it as being a denser structure after the cryo.

I had my crank cryo'ed & coated along with the bearings.
For me it was a cheaper alternative to a forged (it'll be delivered when?) crank.


Well, since you had this process done, have you gotten the motor built yet and ran it, do you think it made a difference, what kind of numbers you making, how much boost, any track times, and what kind of total cost did you pay with shipping to have this done.

Sorry for all the questions, but this process makes me courious, and also did you have the crank machined, and or turned down and repolishe dbefore you sent it to be trated or after??

Thanks
 

4C FED

Absolutum Dominium
I knew you were going to ask that.
It's a long story and hopefully I will have everything back together and running someday soon so I can relate my experiences.

For the cryo, I believe you want to have the machine work done after the cryo-treatment, then the coating can be applied, if you opt for it.

I think the price to have the crank cryo'ed ($200) & DL-5 coated ($200) + shipping ~ $40-$50.
 
Thanks for the info, i just got of thr phone with the guy there and he is going to work up a price quote for s few things we talked about and send me an email later today. Doesnt sound too bad, for 850 bucks plus shipping you can have yout complete motor crioyed, block, crank, rods, pistons, heads, valvtrain parts, intake, cam and lifters, timming chain, oil pump, i mean everything. He said one other thing the criyo does it keep the parts from moving around so much when things heat up, so bearing clearences stay truer, and wear is greatly eliminated.
 

jwaller

Evil Genius/SyTy Guru
Sigo said:
No,

But I am still waiting for an explanation from Waller on what he said before I send $300 and a core crank his way for Nitriding that he recommended. But thanks for deleting my questions (mod corner)

I never told you to nitrite. I told you thats a waste of money. and if you were goin to spend money on crank treatment then I would cryo treat it.
 

4C FED

Absolutum Dominium
The proof is out there.
Maybe not much in the motor realm, but certainly for brakes.
When rotors are cryoed they last longer and braking distances are reduced.
 
Well after talking to the guy for about an hour yesterday, im sending my entire motor to him and having it cryoed, I mean everything, for 850 bucks plus shipping. So well see what it does, I guess if the motor doesnt break then it did somethink, Kinda of a crude testing method i know.
 
Top