When it is unplugged, I believe the 02 sensor reading is about that (mid 400s)
I'd wager there is an electrical problem - bad connection, bad wire, etc, as it mimics having NO sensor whatsoever.
Get a voltmeter and start doing some continuity testing from the ECM connector, to the sensor plug. If you locate some damage, see if there was any damage to the harness that may cause other problems as well.
If you find any, it might not be a bad idea to go through the harness some more with the voltmeter, hunting for wiring/connection issues.