snapped another crankshaft in half

rarebit

New member
snapped another stock $500 crankshaft in less then a year. this time it started out with a knocking sound and rapidly progressed over about 7 seconds into a grinding, rattling, scraping sound. at this point i shut it down. rods r fine, no traces of knock, pistons r good, oil pressure was strong all the way up until i shut down. damn, i didnt even have time to take it to the track and get a time slip for the most recent build. i think i need a crank thats a little stronger. the block isnt four bolt but it is studded. i was thinking about going oddfire or buying a high dollar even fire steel crank. anyobdy have any ideas or parts for sale(even fire or oddfire)?

engine right now is- stock crank*broke*, two bolt(studs) main, trw pistons, eagle rods...it just wont hold.
 

Loeryder

New member
Was it shotpeened, nitrided, or cryogenically hardened?

those are all things you can do to the stock crank to make it harder.

Or just point it to the Mile High SyTy photo shoot in off topic. Look for 5000+ views...
 

FLSY2730

New member
Dam, there are alot of people running fast with stock cranks and lasting, just curious are you beating on it hard, high boost?
 

10secTy

Sy-Ty builder and Tuner
What boost levels where you running? What rpm? please send some details.
How much knock retard did you get on the run?

Thanks

Nolan Nykyforuk
 

rarebit

New member
it was just a gm crank from pace. not treated specially or anything. the highest boost i ever ran was 20psi with a t72 turbo. i did notice a rattling sound a few days prior to it going out. it would act up at about 3k rpm and then it would completely go away around 3.5k rpm. that's the only sign i had that something was up. i didnt pay much attention to it. i though it was the t/c which i was planning on replacing. i wasnt even boosting...in a matter of seconds while i was idling at a light it went kapoot. i killed it and pushed it into the gas station

i have driven this truck really hard on the freeway a bunch of times. so its not like i was always babying it.

i checked to see if i was getting any knock counts as soon as i noticed the rattling sound and found no traces.

maybe the main caps gave? i havent cracked open the engine yet but judging from the way the harmonic balancer shaft is wobbling my best guess right now is that i need another crank.

the crank before this one split between the bearing and #3 journal...not the weak spot(like between 3&4) if i ever get a digital camera ill take pictures.
 

smeagol

Active member
What was the buildup? (rest of engine/computer controls)

What power levels were you at?

Any signs of detonation?
 

V6 Kompressor

New member
Are you having the crank balanced with the rod and piston combo you are running? You know that the eagle rods weigh 50 grams more than the stockers and the trw forged pistons weigh just about as much more than the stockers. So if the complete rotating assembly is not balanced, with the flywheel and harmonic balancer, then you could be having symptoms of a severly unbalanced combo.... I think it costs aboout $150 to get the balance job done, but it is worth it, expecially if the engine sees an occasional blast in the 5000+ rpm range... Barnett Performance does this in the Atlanta, Georgia area as well as other competent machine shops in the us.... ask them if they know about mallory metal, if they don't know, then run to another shop....
 

rarebit

New member
it's a stock block bored .020 over w/ 2 bolt stud mains, eagle rods, trw pistons, clevite bearings, arp studs, brodix heads, crower roller rockers, stock push rods and lifters, stokes grind comp cam, mildon oil pump, stock balancer, after market timing chain/gears(i forgot which).

using wide band batch fire speedpro efi. max ve was 88%, max timing was 50 degrees lower map/rpm band. highest timing at 14-20psi boost was ~20 degrees.

some traces of knock when i was expermenting with running 91 octane gas at 14psi and 22 degrees timing. other times it would knock when the inlet temps would reach 200 degrees F. i would never let it knock more then once or twice without pulling my foot out of it.

as far as i know they balanced the entire rotating assembly. at least they billed m for it. i cant estimate the power levels but it did show 12.40 on the g tech pro w/ somewhere around 14psi-20psi...i cant remember.
 

myclone

Donating Member
FWIW... Ive built bottom ends exactly like you have and havent had a bit O problem with cranks...

A bad/misaligned TC or misalinged trans input shaft could be causing this. Have you checked to make sure nothing is wacky with the trans input shaft? How bout the other two cranks that broke? Did they break in the same location? Notice any wierd main bearing wear on tear down/inpection?

You mentioned a prob with your existing TC. Did you use the same TC with the other cranks that broke? How bout the line bore on the main caps? Was it checked/performed when you built the eng? How bout when the other cranks broke? Was it checked/line bored then?

IMO breaking a crank happens.. Breaking two is a fluke/bad luck but three times means something is amiss in crankville.
 

rarebit

New member
ive only broke 2 cranks total so far. i get a weird vibration from something when i hit 65 mph. any higher or lower and no vibration. i suspect the tc. im not sure how to check the input shaft or tc. yeah, same tc with both cranks. had a line bore done both times. i suspect this crank broke somewhere around #1 and 2 judging from how sloppy the harmonic balancer is. i'll let you know in a few days for sure.
 

Falco

Donating Member
V6 Kompressor said:
... So if the complete rotating assembly is not balanced, with the flywheel and harmonic balancer, then you could be having symptoms of a severly unbalanced combo....

I thought that the flywheel and the hb dould be balanced separately. If they have a neutral balance once (as they supposed to come from GM), you don't have to deal with them any more. Am I right?
 

V6 Kompressor

New member
I thought that the flywheel and the hb dould be balanced separately. If they have a neutral balance once (as they supposed to come from GM), you don't have to deal with them any more. Am I right?[/quote]

The Balancer appears to be neutral balanced but the flexplate does have a weight on it.... Most machine shops that I have dealt with want to have the balancer and flexplate that you are going to use, mounted to the crank before they will spin it in the machine.... Even if it is 350 small block or a 427... When balanced like that, it is a true balanced assembly....
 

JoeLutz

New member
I am assuming you used new main cap bolts. If so, did you cycle torque the bolts? Torque, then loosen then retorque several times. New bolts exhibit very unpredictable clamp loads for a given torque at least the first five times that they are torqued. In Winston Cup engines, when the blocks are linebored, all the mains are torqued, loosened and retorqued at least 8 times before the block is line bored, Then the same bolts are used in the final assembly with the exact same torque and lube. The reason in the variation in clamp load is the fact that the work done in torquing a bolt is mostly gone into overcoming friction which increases markedly with contact pressure. As you cycle torque the bolts, the threads and mating surfaces are polished so friction is reduced. Its not uncomon to see clamp loads double from the first torque to the 5th time at the same torque value. Also Engine oil or loctite on the threads and mating surfaces reduces the necessary torque for a given clamp load by 30-40% Most engine builders overtorque because they use some lubricant on the threads and torque it to the dry torque specs. This is the kinda testing I did this summer at Hedrick Motorsports.
 

rarebit

New member
i did use new main cap studs. i did not cycle torque the studs or nuts. so your thinking a stud or nut came loose? thanks for the info. do i still have to cycle them even after a year of use?
 

myclone

Donating Member
rarebit said:
i did use new main cap studs. i did not cycle torque the studs or nuts. so your thinking a stud or nut came loose? thanks for the info. do i still have to cycle them even after a year of use?

Damn... I always "cycled" the mains/rods myself.. I thought I had an original idea until now. :( :( I have never said anything about it here or even to my local buds that do engines as I figured theyd say I was nuts or "you dont need to do that...". Ha, jokes on them. Neener neeener.. :p

Anyway, I misread your first post and thought you had broken 3 cranks instead of two (which is 2 too many for the bank account Im sure).

Something that Im wondering is how the line bore checks out from side to side. A verticle line bore misalignment can be correctd with a line bore but a side to side misalignment cant (for the most part). You can clean up the "tight" side of the misalignment but the "loose" side isnt affected and wont give you the proper bearing crush at the mating point of the bearing. This is why I asked what the bearings looked like on inpection/tear down. Im sure the main bearings directly in front of and behind the break look bad but what about the others?

IMO unless you got two cranks with internal casting flaws (possible but youd prolly have a better chance of getting hit by lightning on a sunny day) then there is a prob with the line bore somewhere or another component is misaligned and putting latteral stress on the crank. A misaligned TC or trans could, IMO, cause this. How bout the TC hub that fits into the front pump on the trans? Does it have any weird wear marks? How bout the bushing in the front pump of the trans where the TC hub rides?

As for balancing... Every machine shop Ive talked to/did business with wants the flex plate/fly wheel and the harmonic damper. Even if its a "neutal balance" eng like ours they still want it as manufacturing tolerances arent always right on the money with these parts. According to them you will prolly never have a prob but it costs no more money to have these components on there when the assembly is balanced so why not be safe and balance the ENTIRE rotating assembly instead of "guessing" that the damper and flex plate/flywheel are 100% correct. I always play it safe and supply the machinist with the damper/flex plate. Costs nothing extra and Im all about cheap. :wink:

Keep me/us posted on what you find as Im curious to know whats going on since youre build is a mirror of build Ive done many times with zero probs (cept for some crappy machine work a couple of times but thats another story all togeather).
 

JoeLutz

New member
I don't think that they came loose. You see the thing is, all metal acts like a spring, meaing when you put a load on it, it deforms slightly. This material property is calle the Modulus of Elasticity. So what I am saying is if the machinist didn't cycle torque the new studs before the engine was linebored or you installed new studs after it was linebored or the two of you used different torque methods or lubricants on the threads, maybe in the final assembly, the mains were not exactly round or coaxial with each other due to variation in calmp load and resulting non dissimilar distortion of the metal. The idea here is to as closely as posible simulate the final assembly clamp load conditions when the engine is linebored so that the distortion in the main caps and block are the same. So the scenario should go something like, machinist or whoever cycle torques the studs to polish thier threads to provide closer to 'ideal' clamp load before the line bore, then the engine builder torques the studs using exactly the same lube on the fastener as the machinist did and exactly the same method of final torquing----SLOW.

Polishing the threads is dependant on how many times the nut has been run down on the stud under load-- cycle torqued-- not on how long the component has been together or ran.

If you plan on reusing the studs and your studs are not damaged, This is what I would do. Get new nuts. clean the stud threads. With the caps off, run the nuts down on every stud with your fingers to check for burrs or hard spots. Make sure all threads are smooth and the nut threads easily. Now install the main caps and using engine oil on the threads of the studs and face of the nut, torque the mains down to 70% of the max torque listed in the manual. Repeat for every stud at least 5 times. Make absolute certain that the main caps and nuts stay with the same stud in the same position. You may want to number them. Make sure the machinist torques the mains with the same engine lube and exactly the same ammount and way you torqued them....May want to bring your torque wrench. Since they've already been cycle torqued, you will not need to repeat. When you assemble the engine, make absolute certain the mains and nuts are in the same position and with the same stud. Clean the threads with carb cleaner. Using the same type eng oil, final torque the fasteners to 70% of the max dry torque specifications, exactly the way its been done when you cycle torqued it and when it was in the machine shop. That means take the max dry torque specs and multiply it by 0.7 and use that value every time with the oil. This will still give you clamp load thats a bit on the high side. Good luck
 
Top