Vortec heads: Valve guides

4C FED

Absolutum Dominium
Has anyone looked at a bone stock valve guide on the Vortec's?

I know they're cast iron, which I recently read are better than bronze in regards to wear.

My interest is about knurling of the guide. Are the factory stock guides knurled?

I used to work in a machine shop while I was going to high school, many moons ago. And at that time, knurling the guides was considered the budget rebuild method. The least amount of work to get a few more miles out of the motor.
Is knurling still considered a low budget way to go?

For an all out effort, 600+ HP, should the cast iron guides be knurled or drilled out and replaced with bronze guides?
 

ed hess

race or get outta the way
i just got my vortec heads back from the machine shop. these were waller heads bought 2nd hand by me.

I sent them there cuz i cleaned them ai mineral spirits which ruined the seals. I asked them to check everything out but didnt expect to hear anything since they only had 1100 miles on them.

The springs, turned out they were stock springs with shims under them. I guess to increase the spring rate. The machinist tested them and they were just stock springs. I upgraded them to match the comp cam 412 kit.

The valve guides were 100% bronze. Not what would be used in a cast iron head as they expand under heat wereas the cast iron wont expand. They would have been fine in an aluminum head which does expand with the heat so that the expanding metal is not forced entirely into the center of the guide.

So the bronze can only expand inward, which makes them rub the valve stem and prematurely wear. With 100 miles on them He showed me how the runout was all over the place were it should have been at 2 hundreths consistently ( think that was the number). You could wiggle the valve stem in the guides and feel how loose it was compared to a new cast guide.

However to give me the best of both worlds he installed new cast guides with bronze inserts in them. The inserts are very thin so the expansion from heat no longer becomes an issue with the bronze.

I dont think that waller realizes they heads are built with solid bronze guides and stock shimmed springs. I beleive he has somone else that does them for him. I know the guy i bought them from was quite surprised by all this when I told him.
I would think there might be a lot of people with prematurely worn out valve seats in the next few years. My machinist told me that mine were allready worn because of the stems being able to wiggle in the guides.


ed

I am not bashing waller here cuz i dont think he realizes what his machinist is giving him.
 

4C FED

Absolutum Dominium
Thanks for that info Ed.

My concern is that my $9000 long block has knurled valve guides, bi-metal freeze plugs (brass ones are only a few $ more), 2 exhaust valve guide seals that lifted off of the guide, a deck & head finish that is inconsistent with modern day high performance engine building AND a spun #3 cam bearing, which I was told was typically caused by to tight of a bearing fit.

Some know the story.
If you don't, do a search.
 

ed hess

race or get outta the way
i hear ya,

that why even thought the bottom end and heads i bought used from 2 different people i decided to tear down and overhaul just to play it safe. Initially i wasnt going to do this, but having done it I am now glad i did.

Then again my machine shop bill was only a bit over 1k so i probly got off easy.

ed

btw,i just installed the std sytle of freeze plugs, nothin special there but did use a sealant with them.
 

myclone

Donating Member
Knurling was the way to go back in the day but having bronze guides installed is no longer a "high tech" deal which makes it a cheap repair. Knurling will not last as long and actually increases the wear on the valve stems so I HIGHLY recommend staying away from it.

Have bronze guides installed and forget about em for 100k miles.
 

ed hess

race or get outta the way
no on the bronze valve guides.

have cast iron valve guides with bronze sleeves done in them. Like i said above. Well at least thats what my machinist did for the reasons i said above.

ed
 

myclone

Donating Member
Ive never had an issue with bronze guides in the 1 or 50ish engines Ive ever screwed togeather. Then again times change and technology improves so the iron guides with bronze inserts may be the way to go but I dont see any reason to go through all the trouble to install a iron insert with a bronze insert inside that. IMO its one more operation/part to screw up or fail. If you know anything about me then you prolly know that I stick with what works for me and 100% bronze guide have yet to let me down.

If the valve train geometry is set up correctly then there shouldnt be any issues with accellerated guide wear. Improper geometry increases the side loading and will prematurely wear out ANY guide. If the guide to valve stem tolerance is set up too tight then yes its very possible to pull a guide out or hang a valve with bronze guides but I would assume that this could happen with the guides you spoke of too. Ive seen this happen with bronze guides myself and it was from improper machining or the engine was ran too hot (to nearly the point of engine seizure).
 

jwaller

Evil Genius/SyTy Guru
myclone said:
Ive never had an issue with bronze guides in the 1 or 50ish engines Ive ever screwed togeather. Then again times change and technology improves so the iron guides with bronze inserts may be the way to go but I dont see any reason to go through all the trouble to install a iron insert with a bronze insert inside that. IMO its one more operation/part to screw up or fail. If you know anything about me then you prolly know that I stick with what works for me and 100% bronze guide have yet to let me down.

If the valve train geometry is set up correctly then there shouldnt be any issues with accellerated guide wear. Improper geometry increases the side loading and will prematurely wear out ANY guide. If the guide to valve stem tolerance is set up too tight then yes its very possible to pull a guide out or hang a valve with bronze guides but I would assume that this could happen with the guides you spoke of too. Ive seen this happen with bronze guides myself and it was from improper machining or the engine was ran too hot (to nearly the point of engine seizure).

my thoughts exactly. I've had my heads on my truck, and I only setup up one way for nearly 20k miles now with no trouble whatsoever.
 

myclone

Donating Member
Just cause we agree dont mean I aint still mad at you for not stopping by when you've flown into Roanoke.

Hmph... Affraid to hang out with the lower class huh? Sokay, No more jump starts from me dead battery boy :p :D
 

sytyguy

Moderated User
Waller is lower class.....he did live in Statesboro, GA ya know? :wink: Cops and city officials hated us back then didn't they John? BTW, I was told the EPA was snooping around at the old house. No kidding.

Sorry....nothing productive to add to the topic.

Michael
 

jwaller

Evil Genius/SyTy Guru
EPA hua? damn how did that happen...? 0X and yeah we did manage to piss off about all the locals in one way or another. I believe both of use managed to land in jail at one time or another.. :p and dave if I ever come to va again I'l make sure to call you. BTW I am usually working ~3-6am. so I hope I dont wake you. but I know you work funny hours too.....
 

ed hess

race or get outta the way
So i set out today to check piston to valve clearance on this setup.

CHecked straigtness of all 12 pushrods. I found only 3 that might be straigt enough to to my checking today. But the rest of them are all toast!! 2 have heat marks on them. Rolled them on a formica top then a glass table top. I couldnt beleive it.

These came with the heads i bought.

Perhaps this caused the valve guide wear the machinist found?

Sure hope i didnt upset anyone, especially Mr Waller!!!!
 

4C FED

Absolutum Dominium
ed hess said:
Sure hope i didnt upset anyone, especially Mr Waller!!!!

The facts speak for themselves Ed.
Nobody can ask for anything more.

I know I am not the only one to have had problems with my "M" motor.
People might dis' me, but I have spoken nothing more than what I have found or what other reputable builders have told me.
 

Syclone#892

Member
So the bent pushrods could have caused the guides to wear out in 1000 miles? Why would the pushrods be bent? They were brand new comp cams for roller cams since these are shorter than regular flat tappet cams. I know how to adjust valves and they were correct I know this and so does my dad who as done it many times before. So I am still trying to figure out why they would have gotten bent then I remember I post by someone on the board so I just searched for it and here it is, reasons for pushrods to bend.
http://www.syty.net/phpBB2/viewtopic.php?t=21616&highlight=bent+pushrods
I am wondering if the stock springs had coil bind and that was what did it or possibly the slots in the heads were not big enough? I don't know but I feel real bad buying something for so much using it for awhile and then say my motor is going, burning oil and such so I got a new motor and sell the parts I was told many times are good parts and are right parts and now I find out the heads are bad so my short block is probably fine I don't know. Sorry Ed Sorry Rick for going off topic.
 

ed hess

race or get outta the way
david

at least you dont have to worry about me being upset.

The way i figure it the stuff ws used, and even after paying for machine work i still saved a couple bucks.

what else can i say other than shit happens. :D

ed
 
Top