When is knock audible?

It's just a six

Super Member
Hey guys,

just asking at what point is knocking audible on our Sy/Tys?

6*,8*,10*,12* or more of KR?

I have seen as high as 16* of KR & not even hear any knocking.

Thanks
 

BMFB

Not to scale
Re: When is knock audible?

I've only heard mine knock once, and that was at 23 psi of boost at 15:1 when I was first learning to tune it (starter bin has that set as default, didn't realize till I did it once) that was pretty serious and kr was maxed out at -15 degrees
 

Don W.

Stab it and steer it
Re: When is knock audible?

If your motor is loud to begin with you may not ever hear it. I've heard it a couple times and it was very difficult to seperate the noise from all the other noise going on. I'd say trust your sensor not your ears. It's not a noise you want to hear anyway...
 

RealFastV6

@jb_and_his_coffee
Re: When is knock audible?

I am admittedly not nearly as familiar with the SyTy ECU as I should be, but generally speaking it's my understanding that just because the ECU is pulling more timing; doesn't mean there's "more" knock in the sense that it would be audibly louder.

It just means that the amount of timing that's been pulled out already didn't solve the knock, so the computer is pulling even more out. It's more of an indicator of the number of times (very quickly) that detonation has been heard by the ecu, rather than how loud it is.

Maybe somebody else can maybe confirm if the SyTy ECU works this way?
 

KETCH-UP

New member
Re: When is knock audible?

My truck is fairly quiet. I log data constantly. I have gotten used to listening carefully for knock and reviewing data logs. My audible threshold is ~ 3-5 deg knock retard. I am never able to hear knock that occurs at shift points, and wonder if is real. The knock sound is in very short bursts and sounds to be somewhat above the 88th key on a piano. It does have a metalic ping sound, but much shorter than a ball peen on metal (crisp and no ringing). There is sometimes a secondary sound like marbles in a soup can, somewhat like a diesel truck. The knock sensor system seems to really work well. Anytime I hear knock, it is surely there in the log. The trouble is the log often shows knock that I do not hear. It has traced to a loose bracket on the engine or motor mount in some cases. Some of the time I cannot find any reason for it.In that case I add some leaded fuel, and ~80% of the time it goes away. Sometime I would like to spend more time looking with the oscilloscope. In the past I havent been able to trigger the scope on actual knock events.
 

It's just a six

Super Member
Re: When is knock audible?

Thanks guys.

I know exactly what knock/detonation sounds like.

I am just wondering @ what KR is when you can hear it.
 

nallj92

Active member
Re: When is knock audible?

If its pulling timing it should'nt be audible at all! if it is, its not pulling timing fast enough, or you have other issues, back down the targeted timing or adjust fuel. There's no real set KR that you will or will not hear it.
 

It's just a six

Super Member
Re: When is knock audible?

I actually only heard my Sy knock one time, when I initially started running cose 59 & the bin was way off for my size injectors. I used a 40 lb bin & I have 36 lb injectors. It was way too lean.

I seem to think some of the KR I see is a false knock because run after run, the engine does not knock consistanly & in the same areas.

It will actually have less KR the longer I datalog.

It seems that the first run I datalog will have the most KR.
 
Last edited:
Top