Code 59 or FAST management? ---

SloGN

9Sec Alky V6
Re: Code 59 or FAST management? ---

Code59 has Closed Loop Wide Band Control that you set AFRs in a table. It works well. You want to run 13.0 AFR at X RPM and y MAP. BAM it will go to 13 AFR. Only caveat is it doesn't work yet when you get into PE Mode (basically anything in Boost).

The stock code goes OPEN loop (runs the VE numbers only that are in the F29x tavble) once you go into PE so it drops out of the closed loop routine where the Wideband Code that Dig and Don added is making the adjustments to the fuel in Code59. In the future we may change that and allow the Wideband to make adjustments in PE Mode. Hmm.. something I will to bring up in the Black Chat Friday (11/27 9:30pm EST) Dig is having on the SyTy Chat to see if he wants to do that and when.



Well having wideband fuel control @ PE will be the best thing. If not there is not one single advantage in code 59 VS a stock bin that has been tuned for x boost and x timing.




Whats kinda kewl is that a megasquirt ECM can do closed fuel control and almost all of the functions the stock ecm can do for the same price as buying all the stuff for code 59.
 

turbodig

Active member
Re: Code 59 or FAST management? ---

The greatest adavantage the FAST/BS3 has over the stock ecm/code59 is it has closed loop fuel control that you set in a A/F table. so if something goes wrong the ecm can compensate. IE: overboost, failing fuel pump,

I don't think the stock set-up can do that even with a wide band feeding into the ecm. I was told the only reason for the wideband is for the datalogging features only.


The Biggest problem when using a stock ecm and somewhat stock code. Job 1 is clean air and then job 2 is performance. so you have to know what affects what when making changes in the stock code.


Both systems can make great power and do it safely. but with a aftermarket system you can get it tunned much quicker VS the stock ecm.

You have to spend time with either. It's probably a bit more user-friendly in the aftermarket world, but you won't get the starter bin support or support for our platform.

People believe that the full-throttle closed loop absolves them of having to have a decent tune.... it doesn't.
You still have to get your VE table within a range that allows the ECU to correct. And, even if you do, the WB can't correct instantly... it takes some time.

A good tune, whether you have a FAST, BigStuff, or Stock ECU, is the one that the WB doesn't have to correct.

As far as the original question, if I already had a FAST, I'd sure use it.
 

SloGN

9Sec Alky V6
Re: Code 59 or FAST management? ---

You have to spend time with either. It's probably a bit more user-friendly in the aftermarket world, but you won't get the starter bin support or support for our platform.

People believe that the full-throttle closed loop absolves them of having to have a decent tune.... it doesn't.
You still have to get your VE table within a range that allows the ECU to correct. And, even if you do, the WB can't correct instantly... it takes some time.

A good tune, whether you have a FAST, BigStuff, or Stock ECU, is the one that the WB doesn't have to correct.

As far as the original question, if I already had a FAST, I'd sure use it.


I agree Dig.

I understand that a properly tuned VE table shouldn't need a WB correction. but there is always those times that something happens. say a vac line comes loose from the Fuel pressure reg. The aftermarket systems can compensate for that. The stock ECM can't do that and there you have a smoked engine. Whats a engine rebuild gonna cost ya?


BTW dig when you buy a aftermarket system from a vendor. They will supply a start up file. If not it's not very hard to start from ground zero. don't all the code 59 bins use alot of the stock parameters? so your not starting from zero anyhow.
 

turbodig

Active member
Re: Code 59 or FAST management? ---

I agree Dig.

I understand that a properly tuned VE table shouldn't need a WB correction. but there is always those times that something happens. say a vac line comes loose from the Fuel pressure reg. The aftermarket systems can compensate for that.

What people don't understand, is that Wide-bands aren't that fast. There isn't any system that's going to recover from a loss of fuel pressure.

The stock ECM can't do that and there you have a smoked engine. Whats a engine rebuild gonna cost ya?

Same thing it costs you when you're trusting a WB to correct at WOT and the sensor fails.


BTW dig when you buy a aftermarket system from a vendor. They will supply a start up file. If not it's not very hard to start from ground zero. don't all the code 59 bins use alot of the stock parameters? so your not starting from zero anyhow.

Unless they do a lot of SyTy work, what a vendor gives you for a startup file isn't likely to be all that close.
I've seen quite a few FAST calibrations that weren't what I'd call fantastic.

With any of the systems, if you work on the tune you'll get good results. It's really not a whole lot different from one system to another, aside from features and subsystems.
 
Top