Desensitizing knock sensor for built motors

SyTyAddict

Member
I have been having trouble with knock across the board from idle in park to WOT. Today I bought another knock sensor and moved it to the front of the lower intake, the knock continued with little to no change. I pulled it back out and put one wrap of teflon tape around the threads and torqued it the 12ft lbs instead of 14. It continues to show knock at idle and with slight increase in tps, but it disappears after 1400-1500 rpms. The motor has headers, crane gold roller rockers, and forged pistons; I think the knock sensor is picking up one or several of these things.

What I'm thinking is to make the ecm ignore the knock sensor below roughly 1600 rpm, and hopefully it continues to not show knock above that number. It does show a little knock as the throttle transitions but it is very slight and short lived, it is also gone with the throttle held steady. Does anyone see a problem with this, such as the sensor being desensitized too much? I was trying to chase down these issues before I put my code59 stuff on it.

Thanks
 

dgoodhue

BuSTeD 4.3
Re: Desensitizing knock sensor for built motors

The motor has headers, crane gold roller rockers, and forged pistons; I think the knock sensor is picking up one or several of these things.

If the knock sensor is operating properly it shouldn't be picking up any of these noises. It would be more likely that its picking up an exhaust rattle.
 

SyTyAddict

Member
Re: Desensitizing knock sensor for built motors

There was a post a while back where jwaller said he torques the knock sensor to 12 ft lbs instead on 14 on motors with forged pistons and roller rockers. From what I've been reading the knock sensor was tuned for stock motors, when noisier aftermarket parts are added, the knock sensor confuses the noises for knock. I have looked everywhere trying to locate the issue, I've had a stethoscope on everything and nothing seems out of the ordinary. I have spent plenty of time looking around underneath it, having just done solid motor mounts.
 

SY-1193

Active member
Re: Desensitizing knock sensor for built motors

.... I pulled it back out and put one wrap of teflon tape around the threads and torqued it the 12ft lbs instead of 14.

The sensor is one wire so it grounds thru the block...correct? It is actually a tiny microphone inside the metal can. Do you suppose wrapping it with teflon is making a poor ground? The sensor comes with a red loctite type substance on it but I think it has to have a good ground and the teflon tape might not help. Also a guy at GM told me they are a once and done type sensor screw it in to torque and that is it. Retorquing messes it up and reinstalling it is no good. Also make sure you have the correct part # if it has been replaced there are different part #'s and if you get the wrong one it can be +/- sensitive.

A question for you: Do you have chip or carrier with the original chip piggy backed on the board? (aftermarket chip) I recently went to help someone with knock issues and his truck constantly was showing knock I found he did not have the original chip piggy backed onto the pins on the board and his knock was just cycling constantly - and retarding timing. >> Picture Here<<
-The clear part of that chip in picture circled in red controls knock counts and if it isn't plugged in correctly or is bad you will have problems. It is not always the sensor.

HTH
 
Last edited:

SyTyAddict

Member
Re: Desensitizing knock sensor for built motors

It had the correct part number and the box appeared to have never been opened, so it should be correct. From what I've been researching, wrapping it in teflon is somewhat common practice to desesitize it slightly. I had read that they are one time use, if that's the case, then this will start getting expensive quick. This thing has a ton of knock, it'll hit the timing retard limit (12.66*) at 9% tps.
 

johnboy89

Member
Re: Desensitizing knock sensor for built motors

The sensor is one wire so it grounds thru the block...correct? It is actually a tiny microphone inside the metal can. Do you suppose wrapping it with teflon is making a poor ground? The sensor comes with a red loctite type substance on it but I think it has to have a good ground and the teflon tape might not help. Also a guy at GM told me they are a once and done type sensor screw it in to torque and that is it. Retorquing messes it up and reinstalling it is no good. Also make sure you have the correct part # if it has been replaced there are different part #'s and if you get the wrong one it can be +/- sensitive.


HTH

I would think the teflon tape would have some effect on grounding, but why is there a red loctite with a new one, unless that stuff is conductive?????
 

SyTyAddict

Member
Re: Desensitizing knock sensor for built motors

I tested the ohms on it before I put in it, I can touch the ohm meter to the lower manifold and the outgoing line on the sensor and it ohms the same as when I took it out of the box. Also testing voltage, the voltage reads the same regardless if I touch the sensor output or use the engine as a ground. I think that it is grounded fine, but I've been wrong before.
 

dgoodhue

BuSTeD 4.3
Re: Desensitizing knock sensor for built motors

I know from own experience that mounting the Knock Sensor on the Intake desensitizes the sensor a little bit, I have heard of the teflon tape and loosening the knock sensor trick to desensitze the knock sensor.

You've tried 3 different techniques to desensitize the Knock Sensor and its still picking up false knock. I would atleast remove the teflon tape and properly tighten the sensor and then figure out what the noise the sensor is picking up (or problem) rather than trying to find a way around the real issue. Doing this will probably create problems later when your trying to tune and pick pick real signs of detonation,
 

SyTyAddict

Member
Re: Desensitizing knock sensor for built motors

That's what I was worried about, it may be so desensitized that it doesn't fully pick up real knock. I dread having to track down this issue, I'm sure I'll eventually find the cause, but it'll really suck to track it down. I really suspect it is picking up internal engine noise.
 

T-Bone

Active member
Re: Desensitizing knock sensor for built motors

Might be a good time to sell that heap of junk back to me and I can save you all the false knock tracking headaches.
 

Daryl H

Donating Member
Re: Desensitizing knock sensor for built motors

The knock sensor output is in an alternating current form just like a microphone.
One can hook up the wire to the knock sensor straight to a computer and listen to the motor.
(Don't forget a return ground wire)
This works best if you have an adjustable line input on the computer so there is no clipping of the signal.

The knock sensor is not tuned to the motor. It doesn't care.

GM MEMCALs from:http://www.syty.org/old/promguide.html

The MEMCAL is a large brown and blue 'T' shaped plastic carrier that plugs into a special 50 pin socket inside the ECM. Half of the MEMCAL is an EPROM [27C128 - 128Kbits - 16K bytes, 150ns or better] that contains the computer software and look-up tables for a specific vehicle. The other half of the MEMCAL is that neat little board covered in "squishy stuff" and a couple of chips beneath it. That is the Electroninc Spark Control [ESC] module for that vehicle. The ESC "listens" to the knock sensor and sends a yes/no signal to the ECM to indicate the presence of knock. As you can imagine, an incorrect PROM can cause a car to run bad, or not at all. An incorrect ESC module can tell the ECM that knock is there when it in fact isn't, or worse yet, NOT tell the ECM when knock is present.

Hope this helps.
 

SevenT6Vet

New member
Re: Desensitizing knock sensor for built motors

I've always heard LT1 guys using an OEM LT4 knock sensor for this reason. No clue if it will fit the SyTy's though.
 

SyTyAddict

Member
Re: Desensitizing knock sensor for built motors

Sadly the lt4 module wont fit our ecm, the LT4 had the same rockers this motor has, they were noisy enough to necessitate GM to create a knock module just to ignore them.

Also I don't have a prom piggy backed, but there are two proms in the prompaq. This is where it gets interesting, if both proms are not in the prompaq, the truck will run rough or start and die depending on which prom is used. If I out the prom and seat it directly in the ecm it will not run properly. I know if a chip is not seated correctly it can cause knock issues, there is still a chance this could be chip related.
 

sy#2921

BAMF
Re: Desensitizing knock sensor for built motors

Personally I would fix the noise issues instead of masking the knock sensor. Never had an issue with a built motor tripping the knock sensor in these truck unless it was actually pinging.
 

SyTyAddict

Member
Re: Desensitizing knock sensor for built motors

I agree I'm going to hunt down the issue, I am worried desensitizing it would mask the real issue.

I do have some good news, the esc module on the chip carrier was different than all the other syty chips that I have around, so I de-soldered the prom from the carrier and placed it in the G1 adapter that I bought to run code59. I also piggybacked a known good chip to the esc pins on the adapter, and it now runs smooth as glass, but it still has knock. Previously it would shudder when the tcc locked in 4th while cruising between 40-45 mph, that is now gone. Something must have been wrong with the prompaq, ribbon cable, or esc portion of the old chip. Previously it would not run right unless both chips were in the prompaq for some reason.
 

T-Bone

Active member
Re: Desensitizing knock sensor for built motors

Bring it to the Kellers SyTy hosted event on Saturday. There will be some tuning Pro's there that I am fairly confident can hone in and help fix the knock issue. Hope you can make it.....I'd like to see the Proto again ;).
 
Top