Knock issue

Sean Krupa

Moderator
I've been having a Knock issue since last year. I also had a overboost problem which is fixed with the JSM DP. I changed my broken motor mounts with Solids, which I thought would've fixed it. The KR isn't as bad as last year, but it still is high. I don't hear any audible knock, so I'm thinking it's false. My dad has been helping me with the Datamaster runs. I tried just about everything. You guys think I should add some Xylene? If so, roughly how much do you think I should add?

I can send you the DM File, trying to figure out how to post the file on here.

Thanks,
 

Beavis

Still plays with trucks
Re: Knock issue

You can try high octane and see if it still there. That will tell you if it is real or false. I found some false in mine, down pipe shielding, trans lines rattling, fuel lines rattling, loose crossover bolts, and a few other odd things like that.
 

SYCLONE#1531

'MOFOFAST
Re: Knock issue

Order you a case of torco accelerator. Stough works really nice!! Should solve your knock problem!!:2cents:
 

Sean Krupa

Moderator
Re: Knock issue

Thanks for the reply. I removed the DP heat shield, insulated fuel lines, Solid Motor Mounts, Timing at 0*. Thinking about trying some Seafoam. I will try to find some High octane. If it goes down with High octane, what does that tell me other than it's real? I have a pretty much stock truck and I don't think I need to run High octane on stock boost.

I don't get on it all the time, just want to get it running 100%, so I know it's running right in the back of my head.

Thanks,
 

sharkbait

New member
Re: Knock issue

if you put real gas in it, it shouldn't have any knock. if it still has knock, then its a equipment issue ie, dp touching something, tranny lines rattling, etc.

how does the truck feel performance wise?does it fall on its face under boost?
 

Sean Krupa

Moderator
Re: Knock issue

The truck pulls really hard. Doesn't fall on its face at all. Being that the knock is high, I would think I would hear it. My dad heard it many years ago so he knows what it sounds like. I'll try looking at the trans lines and crossover bolts. I have the FP @43psi and wondering if I should go higher. Being that I did the JSM DP w/out a Cat, all the Turbo porting, maybe I need more fuel. I will also find some high octane.

I can send a DM file if anyone is interested.

Thanks,
 

johnboy89

Member
Re: Knock issue

How much knock are you seeing??? I thought knock only became audible after it pulled as much timing as it could 12deg or so??? Best bet is to post up a file on media share so people can take a look at it.
 

Sean Krupa

Moderator
Re: Knock issue

(1st File) I raised my FP to 50psi and it didn't really (no at all) make a difference in Knock reduction. It seems that when I hit 3rd gear, the Knock and boost rise. The boost is decent 1st and 2nd, but when 3rd hits, boost is around 15 but it doesnt spike.

(2nd File) I bought 2 gallons of Xylene and it made a noticeable difference in Knock reduction. Again, once 3rd hits, is when the Knock amd Boost rises. If you look close towards the end of 3rd, the RPMs cut off for a sec. It felt like the engine studdered for some reason. Could it be the Xylene?

Let me know if the files open up. I think you have to save the file and then open Datamaster.

http://www.mediafire.com/file/2ktkl215dk4lyck/4-11-11 50psi FP.uni
http://www.mediafire.com/file/a39zco2d1g6dpwi/2 gallons Xylene 50psi FP.uni
 

Don W.

Stab it and steer it
Re: Knock issue

Two thoughts. First retard timing a couple of degrees. Don't insist on -exactly- 0 and see what happens. Also knock seems to follow boost so I'm guessing that it's not false. Can you get it to stay below, say, 18 for testing. Don't want to loose that motor.
 

It's just a six

Super Member
Re: Knock issue

Yes, retard the timing a couple degrees,drive it,see if it knocks,if it does retard it a couple more degrees.
What octane fuel is in the tank?

How much fuel was in the tank & the 2 gallons of Xylene was added?
Stock chip?
Forgot , what the overboost pressure is set @ w/stock chip?
 

Sean Krupa

Moderator
Re: Knock issue

I have a Stock chip. I had about a little more than half tank of 93, which I always run. I will try to retard the timing a couple degrees being that I basically exhausted everything else. I wrote Mike Hood to see if he could help. I would like to get a 3bar/chip from him being that it looks like I'm flowing enough air now to effect my tune. Do you guys think I need a new tune because of all the mods below, or should I keep trying to figure out my knock on the stock chip first?

I don't want you guys to think my truck is falling apart. This thing pulls extremely hard. I don't hear any audible knock, boost spools up real quick. I just want it 100%. It looks like when I hit 3rd, boost rises to 15-15.5psi. Maybe that might cause some knock with the stock chip.

The boost control is decent being that I have straight exhaust. The JSM Dp really helped with boost control being that last year I was overboosting. I think I should turn the wastegate out a turn or so being that it hits 15.5 in 3rd gear.

Thanks for all your help guys,
 

Don W.

Stab it and steer it
Re: Knock issue

More :2cents: comments. If understand things correctly a stock chip is lost above 14# (2bar). Your DM shows you exceed that and that's where spark retard jumps. IMHO you need to get that boost down to less than 14#. Again it's my understanding that once boost goes over 14# the chip doesn't know to keep adding fuel. Notice the inj duty cycle actually goes down. No offense if somebody smarter than me throws this out the window but that's what I think.

I'd bet with a proper chip and a 3bar this thing would fly.:tup:
 

BMFB

Not to scale
Re: Knock issue

If its over boosting to 15.5 its not that the computer doesn;t understand how to fix it, its that it doesn't see that its happening at all, all it knows is 14.7 (ish) and thats all the fuel it can do. If your overboosting, and its running fine until that happens, your timing is prolly ok. I would say look at your exhaust, if its to free flowing (different muffler can even do it, let alone a cat delete or..anything to make it flow better) it cannot control boost as well. If this is the case then there is a few roads to go down, but you have to find the cause first.
 

MikeRenz

not stock
Re: Knock issue

have you tried locking your convertor. if it doesn't start until 3rd gear i'd check the convertor.
 

Sean Krupa

Moderator
Re: Knock issue

My boost stays around 13.9-14.5 in 1-2 gear. Once it shifts to 3rd is when the boost goes to 15.5 and stays there. I have knock throughout the whole run, but 3rd gear is the worst.

I'm running 3" open exhaust. No cat/muffler. I have the JSM DP for stock turbo. That controls the boost fairly well. I'm going to install my ATR muffler to quiet it down a bit. I will also turn out my wastegate rod a turn.

With the 2 gallons of Xylene, knock was around 1-2.5* in 1-2 gear. When it shifted to 3rd is when boost is 15.5 and I get more knock.

I will let you guys know what happens,
 

WyoSyclone

Active member
Re: Knock issue

I've been looking at the logs this morning Mike.. the KR actually starts after the 1/2 shift.

It looks to me like the tune is just off, caused by the change in the exhaust. After the shift into 3rd the KR really starts to come on; up till then the O2mv is running around 986 and KR is minimal. After that shift the O2 voltage drops down to 968, which is leaner. I think this leaner running is also the cause of the boost plateau after that 2/3 shift... running leaner is generating more heat and the extra heat is building boost. Don's thought on it running past the capabilities of the 2bar are valid... the boost maxes out at 15.5 and just stays there in 3rd.... I think it's actually going higher than that and the ECM doesn't know it needs to add more fuel.

The xylene helped. I don't think altering timing will help much... I think it just needs more fuel and a valid MAP input.

I'd sure take it over to Code59 and get started on a new BIN.... otherwise melted pistons may not be too far away :(

Maybe Dig or Paul or Jeff will chime in and see if they think my thoughts are valid.
 

WyoSyclone

Active member
Re: Knock issue

Screen shot of the Xylene run...

Seanxylenescreenshot.jpg
 

BMFB

Not to scale
Re: Knock issue

for a stock chip and all that done to it I;m suprised its running as good as it is. For all you have done to it, a tune would take care of these issues you have, and make you happy. I'm not sure if you should go the code59 route or just a chip, I myself went code59, and never looked back.
 

Sean Krupa

Moderator
Re: Knock issue

After talking with my dad, he remembers him and Ivan from back in the day were hooking up some gauges and the ATR aux intercooler. This was in 1998. My dad has a log of all the updates since 1994. It seems that Ivan hooked up a 3 bar map sensor which I verified the part number today T'ing into the vacuum line going from the AFPR to the stock 2 bar map sensor. Reading on the Sytyarchives it seems this is not recommended and I am wondering why they used a 3-bar map sensor for the aux. boost gauge. My dad doesn't remember. After taking off some electrical tape I noticed one of the the 3-connectors was broken. I don't know if I broke it or it was like that. They used some push type electrical pins crimped onto the lines. Could this possible be some of my knock problems?

Still waiting to hear from Hood on a tune.

Thank You,
 
Last edited:
Top