knock only in 2nd gear

J-bird

Member
I'm not sure if this is the right place to post this, but it is tunning related.

I have been tuning my ty with code59 for a while now and have learned so much, but I'm still having knock problems.

I have my timing set back 4* at the balancer just to be safe. My A/F never goes leaner that 12:1 and some times goes richer that 10.5:1 in boost, I'm still working on getting that all smoothed out to a constant 11.2:1. I also have never seen over 110* intake temps under boost, but I'm only running 15psi boost.

What I have noticed is that I have a shit load of knock retard in 2nd gear, but in the same conditions (load and RPM) in third there is no noticeable knock. and sometimes in 2nd gear just driving around in low load areas, I get some random knock counts.

I had assumed that this was something wrong with my tune, but now seeing that this only happens in 2nd gear dose this sound like the trans maybe on its way out?

I just recently changed to solid motor mounts, put a new knock sensor in, and moved the turbo oil feed line to the front of the motor in hopes that this would fix some of my knock. I believe that I this did help, but not in 2nd gear.

I guess I need to get some xylene or get a alcohol injection kit and see if this goes away, If not I've got other problems.

Has anyone ever see anything like this before? Just loosing 2nd gear?

Thanks,

Jeremy Franke
 

91blazins10

Active member
Re: knock only in 2nd gear

My guess is that it is false, def put some xylene in there just to make sure. My typhoon will sometimes knock very little when it shifts also. I think your transmission is fine, does it shift nice and hard into 2nd?
 

J-bird

Member
Re: knock only in 2nd gear

yea the 1/2 shift is firm, but at speed i has kind of a whine. Also at idle I can hear what sound like a faint rod knock, but sounds more like it is coming form the trans not the motor.
 

MikeRenz

not stock
Re: knock only in 2nd gear

maybe your 4 piece downpipe is rattling in 2nd gear. Did you make sure you snugged everything down? Did you support the pipe at all?
 

J-bird

Member
Re: knock only in 2nd gear

MikeRenz said:
maybe your 4 piece downpipe is rattling in 2nd gear. Did you make sure you snugged everything down? Did you support the pipe at all?


I'm almost positive that everything is tight, but a good idea to check this again!!
EDIT: There was one spot that was tight, but I don't think that it was hitting the frame. I was able to loosen the clamps and rotate the pipe to gain more clearance.

Is there any reason the trans or converter would make more of a racket in one gear than another?
 
Last edited:

cameronsclone

New member
Re: knock only in 2nd gear

try in 4th gear O/D with the converter locked up. If it shifts into 4th around low 40 mph and grinds or doesn't respond well to the throttle, it may be your converter.
 

sy1907

SYCOTIC
Re: knock only in 2nd gear

Yeah, could be converter clutches. Diagnos per above suggestion. Also, wrap your fuel lines in rubber fuel hose of something if they're riding on the bell housing.
 

TYTILIDIE

METH HEAD
Re: knock only in 2nd gear

Is it around 23-3200RPM? If so, go to the timing table and pull 15* out as Ild bet there is about 30 in there. If not, I dont know what to tell you. I know I had this problem when I first started out with 59 and it just turned out to be the bin. I tore into everythign on my turck, went as far as re-adjusting my valve lash, tossing the heat shield over the DP, tweaking the DP away from the manifold, I did it all man. Full tune up you name it.
 

UR50SLO

V6+2=LSXCamaro
Re: knock only in 2nd gear

I had the same exact problem (well still do actually) Even low throttle would set it off and knock timing out of it causing a bog. There's no way it was actual detonation.
I took the ESC Attack rate all the way "down" so it would just blink retard but you could not notice it by driving it.
Before it was very noticable bog. Not the right way to solve the problem but it made it driveable since I knew it was false knock. No downpipe hitting on mine but I do have solid mounts also.

Jeff had re-located the knock sensor towards the front of the intake manifold to resolve some of these problems due to transmission noise. Might try that.
Your not alone!
~Scott
 

turbodig

Active member
Re: knock only in 2nd gear

J-bird said:
I'm not sure if this is the right place to post this, but it is tunning related.

I have been tuning my ty with code59 for a while now and have learned so much, but I'm still having knock problems.

I have my timing set back 4* at the balancer just to be safe. My A/F never goes leaner that 12:1 and some times goes richer that 10.5:1 in boost, I'm still working on getting that all smoothed out to a constant 11.2:1. I also have never seen over 110* intake temps under boost, but I'm only running 15psi boost.


Jeremy Franke

I'd suggest trying a tank of really high-octane gas. If the knock goes away, you know it wasn't false.

Generally 110 octane and 14 psi won't knock... ever.

Also, be advised that too rich can cause knock as well. If your 10.5 is where the knock is, that's where I'd look.

Where exactly is the knock occurring? Look at the places that knock counts increase... (not KR) is it around a shift point? Does it happen at high RPM? Does it only increase one time, and then goes away?
 

J-bird

Member
Re: knock only in 2nd gear

turbodig said:
Where exactly is the knock occurring? Look at the places that knock counts increase... (not KR) is it around a shift point? Does it happen at high RPM? Does it only increase one time, and then goes away?



When this happens my knock counts are at 2561 at 2225rpm, 118Kpa, AF 10.40
the very next frame I'm at 2669 at 2275 rpm, 122kpa, AF 10.50
Then there is nothing until 3325 RPM at 200KPA, AF of 11.30 my counts go to 2831
After that my knock counts go up a few counts at a time until the shift.

I have a few ideas to look into:
Need to get the A/F leaned out in a few areas, get to a steady 11.2 to 1
I noticed while trying to take the tc inspection cover off that I have no bolts in my trans mount, so yea I'm guessing that its a little loose!
still need to get that dam inspection cover off and check the tc bolts.

If I can find the some bolts for the trans mount, I'll make a new run and post it. what I have now is a longer data log that I was using for autotune and there would be too much shit to weed through.

Thanks,

Jeremy
 

turbodig

Active member
Re: knock only in 2nd gear

J-bird said:
When this happens my knock counts are at 2561 at 2225rpm, 118Kpa, AF 10.40
the very next frame I'm at 2669 at 2275 rpm, 122kpa, AF 10.50
Then there is nothing until 3325 RPM at 200KPA, AF of 11.30 my counts go to 2831
After that my knock counts go up a few counts at a time until the shift.

I have a few ideas to look into:
Need to get the A/F leaned out in a few areas, get to a steady 11.2 to 1
I noticed while trying to take the tc inspection cover off that I have no bolts in my trans mount, so yea I'm guessing that its a little loose!
still need to get that dam inspection cover off and check the tc bolts.

If I can find the some bolts for the trans mount, I'll make a new run and post it. what I have now is a longer data log that I was using for autotune and there would be too much shit to weed through.

Thanks,

Jeremy

Lean it out... it's likely just too much fuel.

Your kpa readings are kind of odd... Your boost is dropping to near nothing after the 1-2 shift? 118 kpa .

You could just post the CSV data from the WOT portion of your autotune data... from 0 MPH until you get out of the throttle.
 

J-bird

Member
Re: knock only in 2nd gear

turbodig said:
Lean it out... it's likely just too much fuel.

Your kpa readings are kind of odd... Your boost is dropping to near nothing after the 1-2 shift? 118 kpa .

You could just post the CSV data from the WOT portion of your autotune data... from 0 MPH until you get out of the throttle.


Most of the time I don't get on it in first gear. The numbers were from a roll in second gear. I n my mind I don't want to beet the snot of of first gear when my tuning is not as close as I would like it to be. I don't know why I think the things I do sometimes.
 

turbodig

Active member
Re: knock only in 2nd gear

J-bird said:
Most of the time I don't get on it in first gear. The numbers were from a roll in second gear. I n my mind I don't want to beet the snot of of first gear when my tuning is not as close as I would like it to be. I don't know why I think the things I do sometimes.


Just do a no-launch stomp... that would be the most informative. Less damaging to parts that way.
 

J-bird

Member
Re: knock only in 2nd gear

Well hell!!

I put some bolts in the trans mount and that may have been part of the problem.

I got some new logs like dig suggested, and i didn't have any real knock(less than 2* at shifts).

log files


I did however still see some some knock after I did these logs when rolling into boost in 2nd gear. I think when doing a run from a stop the engine never gets back down to the rpm where it starts knocking. I think it may just be that the fuel or timing is off in the lower rpm range while in boost.

Another thing that I noticed is that after running it for a while the trans starts to slip going into 3rd and this creates a lot of knock!!! and it gets worse the more you beat on it(imagine that)!

I think the first step is to drain and refill the trans, I'll probably get a deep pan at the same time.

I also have an alcohol kit that I plan to install soon, so hopefully this help further with the knock. I know this will open a new can of worms for my tune.

later
 
Top