I go more for simple functionality. It isn't outdated, it's basic.
I like to look to the Turbobuick guys to see what works for them, their vehicles are much more similar to a syty than any high revving manual Jap turbo car. Seems like every Buick guy uses one of several options - 1 - chip control of integral - 2 - external controlled by regulator - 3 - Boost Commander control of integral - 4 - bleeder control of integral wastegate. I haven't read up on any other controllers being used; the Innovative one that Mike sells is the next one I'd recommend if you want to spend some cash.
Why spend $400-600 if $160 or $10 worth of boost controller does all you need? If the expensive ones are guaranteed to control boost 100 times better...than i could see the need, but no one has proven that the PTE setup won't work with simple boost controllers like I have mentioned.
The Boost Commander is nice... basically it offers you direct open loop control of the solenoid. The solenoid duty cycle is directly controlled by the knob. The TPS trigger allows for ramping of the duty cycle based on throttle position - so the solenoid won't pulse until XX % throttle, based on what you set it at. The extra trigger input can be used in many different ways - you can set it so at TC lockup the duty cycle drops a bit, helping control boost spike - you can set it so if your low alky light comes on, duty cycle drops huge, so your 22psi setting for boost with alky on drops to 16psi when low alky light comes on. You can set 2 boost levels, one for track, one for street, flip a switch and be in race mode. I'm considering looking into the possibility of using the IC pump turnon output for something to trigger the boost controller - aka if > xx degree of knock, the wire goes 12v hot, and lowers boost by whatever amount you set in the controller..
Granted there are some mega buck boost controllers with some added features, but you pay big bucks for something doing the job that a less expensive controller may do fine. Buick guys are using $10 bleeders and are happy with those.
If we determine the PTE stuff is difficult to control... I may have to recommend some other form of control...but I don't see that being the case.
I like to look to the Turbobuick guys to see what works for them, their vehicles are much more similar to a syty than any high revving manual Jap turbo car. Seems like every Buick guy uses one of several options - 1 - chip control of integral - 2 - external controlled by regulator - 3 - Boost Commander control of integral - 4 - bleeder control of integral wastegate. I haven't read up on any other controllers being used; the Innovative one that Mike sells is the next one I'd recommend if you want to spend some cash.
Why spend $400-600 if $160 or $10 worth of boost controller does all you need? If the expensive ones are guaranteed to control boost 100 times better...than i could see the need, but no one has proven that the PTE setup won't work with simple boost controllers like I have mentioned.
The Boost Commander is nice... basically it offers you direct open loop control of the solenoid. The solenoid duty cycle is directly controlled by the knob. The TPS trigger allows for ramping of the duty cycle based on throttle position - so the solenoid won't pulse until XX % throttle, based on what you set it at. The extra trigger input can be used in many different ways - you can set it so at TC lockup the duty cycle drops a bit, helping control boost spike - you can set it so if your low alky light comes on, duty cycle drops huge, so your 22psi setting for boost with alky on drops to 16psi when low alky light comes on. You can set 2 boost levels, one for track, one for street, flip a switch and be in race mode. I'm considering looking into the possibility of using the IC pump turnon output for something to trigger the boost controller - aka if > xx degree of knock, the wire goes 12v hot, and lowers boost by whatever amount you set in the controller..
Granted there are some mega buck boost controllers with some added features, but you pay big bucks for something doing the job that a less expensive controller may do fine. Buick guys are using $10 bleeders and are happy with those.
If we determine the PTE stuff is difficult to control... I may have to recommend some other form of control...but I don't see that being the case.