Promgrammer question for users

Promgrammer question for users

  • All the time

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Sometimes

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Never

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Don't care

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Huh?

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    0

BillC

New member
Howdy,

I'm slowly working on a massive re-write of Promgrammer. It'll look more-or-less the same to users, but it will be totally revamped under the "hood".

Anyway, I have a question about whether people like the comment block at the bottom of each editing window. Do people use this? Do people even care? I don't use it, and I've never seen anyone else use it, and I'd like to take it out. But, I don't want to remove it if a lot of people actually use it. So, let me know how you feel about those comment blocks.

Thanks,
Bill
 

JSM

Active member
Never used the comments.

I tend to use tunercat myself for the main stuff, fuel, spark, etc.

Although tunercat doesn't have everything.

I do find the 3d graphing powerful, and helping me to visually see the maps. I must be more of a visual person.

Only thing I use promgrammer for recently is boost control stuff.

Not sure any of that helps you though.
 

smeagol

Active member
I think it's a nice option, but never used it.

Here's my logic -

It'd be great to catalogue changes, as in I tried more fuel off idle, i changed this value to 76 and it did nothing etc. You can't catalogue in that much detail - take the VE map, are you going to cut & paste and old VE map and say i changed it from this old one to the current one?

Also, you can't do a quick scan of a chip and see what you have changed. The way I typically do chip changes is many variations on a theme at a time, and I have a file I keep of all the changes I am testing, go and test, and keep track of the results. I can go reread that file to see the various changes I have made. If I need to know the exact changes, I can open up promgrammer and see, compare to older chips if needed.

So I say dump it if it makes it easier.

I'd like to ask and see if you can add something as well ;)

There are 3 things that Tunercat has over promgrammer IMO

1-Tunercat is faster (I can deal with that)

2- Graphing of 3d tables, editing while in those tables - I can deal with that as well. I've learned that going to a smooth map isn't always the answer, and sometimes seeing a map in 3d skews your judgement ;)

3- Being able to select multiple cells at a time in any table and increase/decrease, or force a value in them. This speeds up chip testing in a huge way.

So if you can make #3 happen, I'd be eternally grateful :D
 

jwaller

Evil Genius/SyTy Guru
personally I would like to see the ability to select more than 1 table value at a time. and BTW I dont use the comment section. 3d stuff would be neat but not totally nessassery. :eek:
 

BillC

New member
Hey guys,

I could use some more feedback. This posting has been viewed over 100 times, but only 6 people have completed the survey. If you guys don't let me know what you want, you won't get it, and I don't want to listen to all the whining afterward ([wah]what happened to my favorite feature?[/wah]).

Also, could the person who chose "always" please email me? I'm curious about how you are using it.

Thanks,
Bill
 

10secTy

Sy-Ty builder and Tuner
Yep I use tunner cat lots because it is faster to use. I can highlight a entire table and hit the + or - key to adjust the whole table.
I can also adjust in percent which helps when dialing in fueling.
Any thing that speed up the process is peachy with me 8)

Thanks

Nolan Nykyforuk
 

leroy

Donating Member
Bill,

I never use the comments section. If there was just one place for comments, I might use that. Now, I usually write some notes and save it as a txt file with the same name as the bin.

The ability to select multiple cells to decrement or increment would also be a great feature.

I use the "export to csv file" quite a bit. I used to have a macro set up to do 3d maps in excel, but haven't used it for awhile.

Thanks for the work.

Jim
 

sytyguy

Moderated User
PE AFR Table Scale

PE AFR Table Scale

One thing I'd like to see modified is the F61 - PE AFR table. Is there anyway that we could get a little more resolution on the rpm scale? I understand it may possibly require a code hack and some extensive work, but if it's solely in PG then that'd be one thing I definitely like to see changed. IIRC, the current scale is about 800 rpms (3200, 4000, 4800, 5600, 6400, etc...), and the problem for me lies not in the lower part of the scale so much, but more in the upper range. This is where I'd like to maybe do some "easy fix" fueling work, but the stock range is a little too wide for my liking. I'd also kinda like to put in a slight "safety" precaution by substantially richening up the rpm range above say 5400, to kinda act as a buffer (w/o a fuel cut altogether) to say "Hey dumbass, shift me please." It's obviously not an urgent mod as I can fuel more definitively thru the VE tables, but this would act as a quick way of richening certain rpm ranges.

Other than that no other gripes and I am extremely pleased with PG, and used to use the comments section, but started just keeping notes in notepad as a quick reference for what changed in what set of bins.

Thanks for the hard work!

Michael Hood
Syclone #1596
GAST
 

Daron

Active member
You could take the comments section out Bill, I note changes manually and cant imagine why else I would use it. BTW, thanks for the work on the program.
Daron
 

sytyguy

Moderated User
Weak Waller....you ass. :2gunfire:

I was just throwing out a slight suggestion on the F61 table....not really much I can think of to change (that hasn't already been mentioned) and remember'd not liking the scale on that one table....not really bitching :D as I use the F30 table anyway.

Thanks for the tip Green, keep up the good work Bill, and Waller....I'm not building you anymore trucks :wink:

Michael Hood
Syclone #1596
GAST
 

turbodig

Active member
BillC said:
Hey guys,

I could use some more feedback. This posting has been viewed over 100 times, but only 6 people have completed the survey. If you guys don't let me know what you want, you won't get it, and I don't want to listen to all the whining afterward ([wah]what happened to my favorite feature?[/wah]).

Also, could the person who chose "always" please email me? I'm curious about how you are using it.

Thanks,
Bill


I'd say skip the comment option, the hard-core research guys have a
notebook along, usually.

The biggest thing, though, is the child-window interface... TC's MDI
window works nicer. Although, TC is kind of a pig, memory-wise.

Biggest feature addition?

I'd like to see the menu bar like this:

File Options Fuel Timing Boost Other

Within each functional menu, there should be:

Tables ->
Constants ->
Flags ->

From there, you select the table or const you want, and it pops up the grid in a child window on the Programmer "desktop".

"Other" is things like IAC, EGR, that kind of stuff.

The order of things in the tables and constants menu needs to be definable,
under the Options menu.

Also in Options... "Enable emulator support" :)

Also in options.... "Define new table/constant"

Of course, I realize this isn't really a straightforward change, but hey,
you asked. :).


Later,

Dig
 

BillC

New member
turbodig said:
Also in Options... "Enable emulator support" :)
Get me the protocol and I'll work on it. :p

turbodig said:
Also in options.... "Define new table/constant"
What would you use this for? Are you looking to display existing tables/constants in a new manner, or are you trying to create new parameters in the chip?

As for the other stuff, don't hold your breath waiting. :p I'll work on improving the interface after I get done re-writing the underpinnings.

BTW, this designing/writing software stuff is more time-consuming than working on our trucks, and not nearly as straightforward -- by a long shot! Anyone who doesn't believe me is welcome to come over for proof.
 

turbodig

Active member
BillC said:
turbodig said:
Also in Options... "Enable emulator support" :)
Get me the protocol and I'll work on it. :p

turbodig said:
Also in options.... "Define new table/constant"
What would you use this for? Are you looking to display existing tables/constants in a new manner, or are you trying to create new parameters in the chip?
.

To add new tables, mostly. With the 3d boost init Dc tables, I'd like to
be able to tune it once I have it set up. Same for an extended MAP VE
table.

As for the other stuff, don't hold your breath waiting. :p I'll work on improving the interface after I get done re-writing the underpinnings.

BTW, this designing/writing software stuff is more time-consuming than working on our trucks, and not nearly as straightforward -- by a long shot! Anyone who doesn't believe me is welcome to come over for proof.

Don't need to prove it to me.. I've seen the code. :eek:

Later,

Dig
 
Top