Rocker stud repair

Quickstop [UK]

Combating adversyty.
Re: Rocker stud repair

I dismantled the lifter and then let it all drain out. Clean the parts and reassemble the lifter.

Then, using a big bucket, push the check valve in the bottom with a thin screwdriver or similar and pump the lifter spring whilst submerged in the bucket of motor oil. Get all the air bubbles out.

The good ones should harden up and remain hard overnight. The crappy ones will pump up but maybe drain and be springy - maybe immediately, maybe overnight.

Depending on age and any crap in the oil, you may find that they are refreshed.

If you haven't taken them apart yet then you could check if they are good or not right now. I bought some used from a guy on here and they were all rock solid.

2 of the 12 new ones I bought from CC that came out of my truck were immediately springy, hence the jackhammer effectand the tick. The springiness is what made me think they were bad.

Doing the dismantle - clean - bucket pump routine should give you a good idea of what's up.
 

turbodig

Active member
Re: Rocker stud repair

I dismantled the lifter and then let it all drain out. Clean the parts and reassemble the lifter.

Then, using a big bucket, push the check valve in the bottom with a thin screwdriver or similar and pump the lifter spring whilst submerged in the bucket of motor oil. Get all the air bubbles out.

The good ones should harden up and remain hard overnight. The crappy ones will pump up but maybe drain and be springy - maybe immediately, maybe overnight.

Depending on age and any crap in the oil, you may find that they are refreshed.

If you haven't taken them apart yet then you could check if they are good or not right now. I bought some used from a guy on here and they were all rock solid.

2 of the 12 new ones I bought from CC that came out of my truck were immediately springy, hence the jackhammer effectand the tick. The springiness is what made me think they were bad.

Doing the dismantle - clean - bucket pump routine should give you a good idea of what's up.

Thanks. I haven't disassembled any of them, in fact they're still in the block.

Every AM when starting it, there was a pronounced click immediately after starting, even if the truck had run the previous night. This was louder than the "normal" ticking.

As far as age, they all have maybe 800 miles on them, tops.

Given this test, I should be able to ID the bad ones and replace only those.

When you leave them overnight, do you leave them in the oil, or outside?

As far as "springy".. how much springy is too much?
 

turbodig

Active member
Re: Rocker stud repair

If the tick in the morning goes away (mostly) after oil pressure builds up, that's the classic sign of a leaky lifter.

Any detectable "springy" is too much. There should be none. Test them by pushing on them with a big Phillips screwdriver while they are still in the block. Before you do anything. You may reach the "ah-hah" moment right there.

Pump them in a container of oil until the bubbles are gone. Like Mark suggested. You'll know when they are "pumped up". They will go "solid". Put them back in the block overnight. Just like a "real engine" would be. Test them in the morning for "springy". There should be none.

Disclaimer: I have NEVER had trouble with "bad" lifters in 40 years, and hundreds and hundreds of engine builds. I have never had to QC-proof new lifters. But now that this issue has come up, this is how I'm going to start doing it.

Let us know what you learn.
DaveP

I took and pushed on the rockers that weren't valve-loaded when I first pulled the covers. There were two that I could get some definite deflection of the plunger. Will test as above, and I'm gonna do both sides to verify.

I always thought a working lifter should appear solid to a screwdriver; I just took the installed behavior as "normal" for a new lifter. Moral of the story - never assume.
 

phoonTy

Truckless. For now.
Re: Rocker stud repair

This is turning into a great Tech Post. I will be sure and Vault it when it's all said and done. :tup:
 

turbodig

Active member
Re: Rocker stud repair

BTW. That's a nice post, Mark. It makes a lot of sense, and contains good info. :tup:

DaveP

I agree.

One thing I'm a little fuzzy on is the check valve holding part... you mean, like stick a pick down the hole in the middle where the pushrod ball sits, and hold the disc down while you pump?

I took a couple of them apart... 6 pieces, essentially.

Lifter body
Spring on bottom, in the base of the lifter.
plunger with cup that sits in the spring, locating the spring.
Disc on top of the plunger (check valve?)
Pushrod cup, stis on top of the checkvalve disc.
keeper/snap ring.

I'm guessing I need to figure out the technique on the check valve thing, as I'm pumping like mad in my oil bucket (lifter is totally submerged) and it never hardens. One of these lifters was pretty solid before I took it apart, so I don't think he was defective, but it doesn't pump up.

As far as the in-the-block test, all were really solid, except 2. One was just barely spongy, and the other one, really spongy. I can move the bad one .050 to .080 at least. I suspect he was the noise culprit.

Back to getting oily...

*EDIT* Nevermind.. think I got it. I missed the fact that the spring locator cup held a ball and spring... that's the check valve, not the disc.

There's a notable difference in the stock lifters vs. the Speed Pro jobber... The disc on the speed pro is stamped with concentric circles, and the stock one is flat smooth. There's also a difference in the plunger.

I figured out that I need to hold the ball down in the bottom of the cup, then put the top disc and cup back in.
 
Last edited:

turbodig

Active member
Re: Rocker stud repair

I checked the "good" side and found one lifter that was also a bit spongy.

Maybe it's coincidence, but both of the really spongy lifters happened to be in or near full lift on the cam lobe.

Near as I can tell, though the position of the lifter in the bore has no bearing on the hardness of the plunger.
If there's oil and not air in the bottom of the lifter body, the plunger shouldn't move.

I'm gonna pick up 4 lifters to replace the questionable ones, and will test them before they go in.

I think I figured out the rationale of the difference in the disc on the top... the concentric ring design looks like it would allow a slight bit of oil by into the pushrod even when it was tight against the pushrod cup. More top end lube.

Wasn't really planning on dissecting lifters to figure out how they work with this... these trucks do make you learn.
 

turbodig

Active member
Re: Rocker stud repair

Ok, after playing with them a while, I'm back at the original lifter question.

Mark, I understand what you're talking about, but I suspect the comp lifters are a bit different than the stockers or stock replacements. There's no way that I can figure out of how to open the check valve to allow oil in with the disc on the top of the plunger.

I can remove the disc, hold the check valve open and pump it up, but when I pull the snap ring to put the disc back in, I can't compress the plunger enough to get the snap ring back in.

What I need, is a mechanism to apply pressure to it, such that forces the check open and forces oil in.
Once pumped up, it should hold pressure for a number of days, if the majority of the lifters in the truck are any indicator.

The leakage issue has to be one of 2 things-

1) Leaky/dirty/non-concentric check ball.
2) Leakage between the body of the lifter and the internal plunger, when there's load on the pushrod cup.

The fact that the spongy ones appeared on valves that were at high points on the lobe points to #2.
 

WyoSyclone

Active member
Re: Rocker stud repair

only thing I've ever had to do with lifters Dig is put them in the bottom of a container full of oil and pump them up - used to use the end of a nylon parts cleaning brush. Of course that was back in the '80's but I couldn't see the technology changing that much. When they do pump up they definitely feel like trying to compress concrete. Never had to take one apart or release the check valve.
 

Quickstop [UK]

Combating adversyty.
Re: Rocker stud repair

One thing I just thought of when you reassemble them, there should be one or even two holes on the side to allow oil into the body. If you compress the lifter so the air comes out then let it suck the oil in, you've filled the chamber.

If you then compress the lifter again but hold your fingers over the hole, the check ball should allow oil into the lower chamber and pump up. Otherwise it just pumps in and out of the holes.

I'm not sure how much pressure you need so that may not work but it's worth a shot.

HTH.
 

turbodig

Active member
Re: Rocker stud repair

One thing I just thought of when you reassemble them, there should be one or even two holes on the side to allow oil into the body. If you compress the lifter so the air comes out then let it suck the oil in, you've filled the chamber.

If you then compress the lifter again but hold your fingers over the hole, the check ball should allow oil into the lower chamber and pump up. Otherwise it just pumps in and out of the holes.

I'm not sure how much pressure you need so that may not work but it's worth a shot.

HTH.

I'm not even sure that would work, given how these lifter are set up. The checkball will seat with every downward plunge, so no oil will get in that way.

What really needs to happen, is pressure applied to the hole. It'll fill the upper chamber, seat the disc, then push the ball open and allow oil to the lower chamber. Air would have to escape around the sides, or bubble out the check ball.

My plan now is to use my oil-pump primer for the drill to apply oil pressure to the lifters while they're in the block. Then check for the required firmness, and see if there's any overnight leakdown.

All the times I've adjusted, there were a few rockers that didn't seem quite "right" in terms of tightening down and getting pushrod tension, even after recent oil pressure. Adjusting the rockers would be a fools errand if you didn't have pressurized lifters... any adjustment you would be doing would be pure luck.
 

Norm

Donating Member
Re: Rocker stud repair

Try using a drill press, put a push rod in the press, put a lifter into a can covered in oil. You should be able to see what is going on inside the can while pumping up the lifter. Not sure what state of reassembly you are at right now.
 

Quickstop [UK]

Combating adversyty.
Re: Rocker stud repair

Dig, you're right. Not sure priming the engine with all the push rods and rockers loose will do much though. Good luck!
 
Last edited:

turbodig

Active member
Re: Rocker stud repair

I put the lifters+ spider in, plopped the prime shaft in, and spun 'er with the cordless drill.
They (the new lifters) pump up, but not perfectly hard. I suspect they need some full-load plunger action to be able to get all the air out. They're a whole lot better than the spongy ones I took out.

Speed Pro apparently changed their design... the exterior casting is different. I'll do a post-mortem on lifter guts after Nats.

Project update: I got all the parts cleaned up, threads chased, gasket surfaces cleaned, and the opposite head ready for rocker adjust. It's basically waiting for the head gasket and the head to get done, which I'm hoping for tomorrow. I have family stuff going on for the weekend, but with Monday and Tuesday off, I'm optimistic that it'll be done. Engine compartment won't look quite as pristine as it did, but if the machine shop comes through it seems reasonable. May need to bribe Jim (95xtreme) with beer and steak. :)
 

turbodig

Active member
Re: Rocker stud repair

I can't seem to find my arp head bolt torque specs... anybody know the specs on the 134-3601?

Trying to have all my specs together so I don't have to waste time searching when I'm trying to get 'er back together...
 

nallj92

Active member
Re: Rocker stud repair

ARP doesnt list the specs on those online but with some searching i found sequence of 25, 45, 65 with arp lube, some have done 70ft-lb also. 70 seems to be the consensus without finding acutal insturctions.
 

turbodig

Active member
Re: Rocker stud repair

My fuzzy memory seems to remember 65 as well.
I'm not sure how the arp lube would be relevant given that there will be RTV on the threads to seal the hole. I'll find some arp lube or moly for the washers, though.
 

Quickstop [UK]

Combating adversyty.
Re: Rocker stud repair

You have bolts, I have studs.

25, 45 and 65 are the numbers from the manual. 70 is a made up number :)
 

qbnkiller

Conflaguration Specialist
Re: Rocker stud repair

while I am not home until very late tonight, I have a replacement L35 already prepped for ARP studs if you want it Dig...
 

Ty 1885

Member
Re: Rocker stud repair

ARP head bolts should be 75-80 psi. ARP bolts are harder than oem, they need to stretch some in order to hold proper clamping forse.
 
Top