So....wideband.

crashing_sux

Blow Me?
Before anyone jumps down my throat I've done searches, in fact I've blown about 6 hours this weekend reading everything I can about widebands, chips, and ecm's here.

There is simply too much information, and it seems to vary quite a bit by date (guess the capability of the stock ecm is going up quickly with tweaks?). Here's what I want, maybe someone can help me out. I currently have an Accel Gen 6 DFI. Seems allright, but I really want wideband support. From what I"ve read my options are Accel Gen 7, FAST, Big Stuff 3, and the stock ECM with a wideband sensor, some software tweaking, and a romulator.

Can anyone give me a basic pro-con of these? Seems like the stock ecm with mods and datamaster would be the cheapest route (what am I into it after the romulator and wideband addons?), I don't want to have to wait on anyone else for chips so whatever route I go I'd like to make sure I can tune it myself real time. How much am I giving up with the stocker over the aftermarkets?

It looks like by the time you get the Accel or FAST units with the add ons you need you're in $2500 minimum where the Big Stuff might be under 1800 (although someone mentioned there are still bugs to be worked out).

If you have an opinion, let me hear it, or if you have a particularly good link, post it.

Thanks,

Shane
 

SeattleSy#1255

Category 5 Conservative
you might want to talk to Roland up here as he has a similar setup/build as you...i don't know wha the is using, so maybe he could give you some imput.

i'll try to dig up his contact info for ya.
 

SeattleSy#1255

Category 5 Conservative
go to

www.NWSTP.com and sign up there....make a new post something like "Calling ROLAND"....he is on there and not here much. I really think he may help you with a similar setup, but not sure if he has FAST or what?

i'll look for his email as well for ya
 

kwick6

Donating Member
BS3 is going to be the best system out of all of them. Retail on the system is $1999, and thats not including a harness that will probably be in the $500 range.

If your looking for cheapest route, then stock ecm and romulator , wb02 setup would be your answer. Many have done great with it, but its not going to be as easy to tune if your not already familiar with that type of chipping.
 

crashing_sux

Blow Me?
After talking with a couple of guys about it I think I can get most of what I want out of the modded stock setup and save a hefty amount of cash. Time to go figure out what wb02 to buy. I'm thinking of one with built in logging as the datamaster doesn't seem like it logs frequently enough. Do any of you guys have a problem with that?
 

turbodig

Active member
Re: So....wideband.

crashing_sux said:
Before anyone jumps down my throat I've done searches, in fact I've blown about 6 hours this weekend reading everything I can about widebands, chips, and ecm's here.

There is simply too much information, and it seems to vary quite a bit by date (guess the capability of the stock ecm is going up quickly with tweaks?). Here's what I want, maybe someone can help me out. I currently have an Accel Gen 6 DFI. Seems allright, but I really want wideband support. From what I"ve read my options are Accel Gen 7, FAST, Big Stuff 3, and the stock ECM with a wideband sensor, some software tweaking, and a romulator.

Can anyone give me a basic pro-con of these? Seems like the stock ecm with mods and datamaster would be the cheapest route (what am I into it after the romulator and wideband addons?), I don't want to have to wait on anyone else for chips so whatever route I go I'd like to make sure I can tune it myself real time. How much am I giving up with the stocker over the aftermarkets?

It looks like by the time you get the Accel or FAST units with the add ons you need you're in $2500 minimum where the Big Stuff might be under 1800 (although someone mentioned there are still bugs to be worked out).

If you have an opinion, let me hear it, or if you have a particularly good link, post it.

Thanks,

Shane


Another possible option... keep the Gen6, and get a WB 02 that logs
RPM and MAP itself. (Like the PLX wireless unit)

The Gen6 is a pretty simple beast, but it works ok. With the RPM and
MAP data from the WB software, you should be able to dial it in pretty
well. It's fairly easy to tune due to the simplicity of it.

Will it ever have all the bells/whistles the FAST or Bigstuff3 does? No.
Depending on what your goals for the truck are, you might not need them.

If you're looking to build an all-out, no compromises truck, I'd recommend
that you upgrade, but if you're just looking for a driver that runs well
enough and is tuned to not hurt parts, then you'll be fine where you're at.

Just my .02

Dig
 

crashing_sux

Blow Me?
I've been seriously considering this option for a while, my main concern is with data logging, but maybe the wideband unit has enough logging to get me where I need to be? The problem is I don't think a datamaster will work with the Accel DFI in there, I plugged in a scan tool and noticed that it altered my readings. First, I couldn't get live readings, just one time readings, and second many of them were inaccurate, like the mph reads 39mph always.

The Accel doesn't read everything accurately either, I don't know what's up with that. I don't know if it's for all readings but I noticed that my tps only goes to 82% when floored and worry if the computer will make the wrong adjustments never knowing when I'm actually WOT.

As for wideband units, there are so many I have no idea which one to get. The LM1 looks nice but I have read that it's more for taking in and out of your car and that the interface is big and bulky and that you need to have it in your truck constantly to keep the 02 sensor hot so you don't ruin it with carbon deposits. The PLX seems pretty cool as it's wireless (and I think logs one more sensor) and I have really been wanting to get my laptop hooked up to my truck wirelesly. The Zeitronix unit has a nice small led with it so I don't have to have a bulky unit in truck and it's cheap. I'm a bit confused by it all at this point, as I can't tell how much of the advertising is bs or if I'm reading it wrong. An example is the Innovative LM-1, it says it logs data on 5 channels, but then they sell a $250 add on, the AuxBox kit to allow logging of data on 5 channels. I thought it allready did that? And if it doesnt' really log data without a separate $250 add on, what about the PLX and Zeitronix units?

Is this just me or are other people a little confused by what the manufacturers advertise as well?
 

smeagol

Active member
Datamaster works off the stock ECM, you have the DFI in there, so toss the idea of using any regular scan tool out the window. The only software you can use to monitor your truck right now is Accel stuff.

As far as the throttle reading 82%, that may be correct. Most ECU's need to perform a calibration of sorts to know that the throttle is WOT. FAST doesn't read 100% either. As long as you are getting a full range of TPS readings, you should be ok. Each ECU out there has their own issues for setting TPS though.

Dig gave some good advice. How much are you willing to spend for more data, and better features? Also consider support, how many people have the ECU/configuration that you decide upon? This will matter if you have problems and come looking for answers.

Stock ECU + tweaking - many people on this board
FAST - again, many people on this board, as well as on turbobuick board etc.
DFI gen 7 - don't know of many running it on syty's, but there are more people using this in V8 land

what kind of work/modifications are you planning in the future?
will you settle for OK drivability, or do you want the best possible performance all around?
are you techy? does wiring or computers or electrical troubleshooting scare you in the least?
 

kwick6

Donating Member
Innovate Motorsports offers an LM-1 which is basically just the WB sensor and handheld display. Since you have the gen 6, and need to datalog, the "auxbox" would be needed in addition to the LM-1 setup so you could have 5 external inputs... RPM, MAP, TPS, etc.
http://www.innovatemotorsports.com/xcart/customer/product.php?productid=16153&cat=250&page=1


PLX Devices , wireless setup M-500 would give you the same type of inputs.
You can check out this page to see some demos....
http://www.plxdevices.com/M-Series_logging_productinfo.htm


You could get either one, and have datalogging capability, instead of using datamaster. It would be interesting to know which would be more accurate, datamaster or these setups. Innovate's is 12 samples/sec and PLX is 10 samples/sec.


Usually, most people that have the stand alone systems will have WB02's included....but it would still be good info if we could get the most accurate recording for those using a stock ecm, using either datamaster or one of these datalogging systems.
 
Top