The "truth" about spark plug wires?

Ry368

one mile = 5280 feet
Re: The "truth" about spark plug wires?

"CAPACITOR" EFFECT WIRES with grounded metal braiding over jacket
The most notable of exaggerated claims for ignition wires are made by Nology, a manufacturer of ignition wires promoted as "the only spark plug wires with built-in capacitor." Nology's "HotWires" (called "Plasma Leads" in the UK) consist of unsuppressed solid metal or spiral conductor ignition wires over which braided metal sleeves are partially fitted. The braided metal sleeves are grounded via straps formed from part of the braiding. Insulating covers are fitted over the braided metal sleeves. These wires are well constructed. For whatever reason, Nology specifies that non-resistor spark plugs need to be used with their "HotWires." In a demonstration, the use of resistor plugs with "HotWires" will nullify the visual effect of the brighter spark.

Ignition wires with grounded braided metal sleeves over the cable have come and gone all over the world for (at least) the last 30 years, and similar wires were used over 20 years ago by a few car makers to solve cross-firing problems on early fuel injected engines and RFI problems on fiberglass bodied cars — only to find other problems were created. The recent Circle Track Magazine (USA, May, 1996 issue) test showed Nology "HotWires" produced no additional horsepower (the test actually showed a 10 horsepower decrease when compared to stock carbon conductor wires).

The perceived effect a brighter spark, conducted by an ignition wire, encased or partially encased in a braided metal sleeve (shield) grounded to the engine, jumping across a huge free-air gap (which bears no relationship to the spark needed to fire the variable air/fuel mixture under pressure in a combustion chamber) is continually being re-discovered and cleverly demonstrated by marketers who convince themselves there's monetary value in such a bright spark, and all sorts of wild, completely un-provable claims are made for this phenomena.

Like many in the past, Nology cleverly demonstrates a brighter free-air spark containing useless flash-over created by the crude "capacitor" (effect) of this style of wire. In reality, the bright spark has no more useful energy to fire a variable compressed air/fuel mixture than the clean spark you would see in a similar demonstration using any good carbon conductor wire. What is happening in such a demonstration is the coil output is being unnecessarily boosted to additionally supply spark energy that is induced (and wasted) into the grounded braided metal sleeve around the ignition wire's jacket. To test the validity of this statement, ask the Nology demonstrator to disconnect the ground strap and observe just how much energy is sparking to ground.

Claims by Nology of their "HotWires" creating sparks that are "300 times more powerful," reaching temperatures of "100,000 to 150,000 degrees F" (more than enough to melt spark plug electrodes), spark durations of "4 billionths of a second" (spark duration is controlled by the ignition system itself) and currents of "1,000 amperes" magically evolving in "capacitors" allegedly "built-in" to the ignition wires are as ridiculous as the data and the depiction of sparks in photographs used in advertising material and the price asked for these wires! Most stock ignition primaries are regulated to 6 amperes and the most powerful race ignition to no more than 40 amperes at 12,000 RPM.

It is common knowledge amongst automotive electrical engineers that it is unwise to use ignition wires fitted with grounded braided metal sleeves fitted over ignition cable jackets on an automobile engine. This type of ignition wires forces its cable jackets to become an unsuitable dielectric for a crude capacitor (effect) between the conductor and the braided metal sleeves. While the wires function normally when first fitted, the cable jackets soon break down as a dielectric, and progressively more spark energy is induced from the conductors (though the cable jackets) into the grounded metal sleeves, causing the ignition coil to unnecessarily output more energy to fire both the spark plug gaps and the additional energy lost via the braided metal sleeves. Often this situation leads to ignition coil and control unit overload failures. It should be noted that it is dangerous to use this style of wires if not grounded to the engine with grounding straps, as the outside of the braided cables will be alive with thousands of volts wanting to ground-out to anything (or anybody) nearby.

Unless you are prepared to accept poorly suppressed ignition wires that fail sooner than any other type of ignition wires and stretch your ignition system to the limit, and have an engine with no electronic management system and/or exhaust emission controls, it's best not to be influenced by the exaggerated claims, and some vested-interest journalists', resellers' and installers' perception an engine has more power after Nology wires are fitted. Often, after replacing deteriorated wires, any new ignition
Yep! This is exactly why I've decided to ditch my nology wires......after getting bit by one of my nology wires I forgot to ground.:tup:
 

R&C_RallySyTy

Little Big Man
Re: The "truth" about spark plug wires?

I would think this would be a hot topic knowing how everyone here seems to like different wires. MSD, Taylors, Magnacores, ect.
 

nimbusgti

New member
Re: The "truth" about spark plug wires?

I don't own a sy/ty yet but have been using msd wires on my turbo vws for years and never had a problem with them.
 

SY2455

70's Veteran
Re: The "truth" about spark plug wires?

I have tried alot of diff plug wires on all types of engines. The only ones that I have not run on my own cars are the Taylors, Magnacores. I help someone with a tune up that use brand new Taylors that were junk, we had to close down on the sparkplug end as it was so loose that it would not even snap on the plugs. I have been using the MSD wires for the last 10 years on my own stuff and have yet to have any problems with them. I just finish the other day putting the MSD wires on our old Safari van because tne brand new GM plugwires were bad after 2 years. Over a 2 week period the mpg drop to 11mpg and now it back up around 19 mpg with 163,000 miles. The only problem with this install was, instead of getting 2 straight sparkplug ends, the set came with 4 of them.
 

NecroWolf

lost marbles member
Re: The "truth" about spark plug wires?

i prefer msd never had an issue with then, but the ones i got from detroit turbo were great till they pulled apart. i won't accell in a lawn mower. i toasted a set of their 70 dollars wires in less than a month on my ty. and my father has had to replace every accell piece on any motorcycle he's had at the dealership.
 

mrweelr

New member
Re: The "truth" about spark plug wires?

I use RPM Taylor wires on the Syclone, but have used MSDs in the past with good results. I'd be all over the Moroso Ultra 40 race wires if there was a precut set for our trucks. I don't like cutting and crimping my own wires.
 

InvisiBill

Active member
Re: The "truth" about spark plug wires?

I've used the Taylor SpiroPros for the entire time I've owned the Sy (almost 8 years) with no problems. They're more expensive than AutoZone crap, but they're still reasonable.

What is not generally understood (or is ignored) is that as a result of the laws of electricity, the potential 45,000 plus volts (with alternating current characteristics) from the ignition coil (a pulse type transformer) does not flow through the entire the length of fine wire used for a spiral conductor like the 1 volt DC voltage from a test ohmmeter, but flows in a magnetic field surrounding the outermost surface of the spiral windings (skin effect). The same skin effect applies equally to the same pulsating flow of current passing through carbon and solid metal conductors.

Shortly after getting the Sy, I was working at a two-way radio shop (i.e. lots of RF experience) and asked one of the engineers about this. He didn't think that a regular automotive ignition would be high enough frequency to hit the point of skin effect. We didn't get into it much more than that, but that's one guy's opinion - that skin effect wouldn't even come into play.
 

turbodig

Active member
Re: The "truth" about spark plug wires?

For about 15 years now, I've watched people buy every new plug wire that came down the pike. I've also tried most of the major ones myself.

None of them worked any better than the basic stuff.

I run Autolite or similar "cheap" plug wires. They last just as long and work just as well as the expensive ones.

One thing the magnecor page does tell like it is - the voodoo qualities of high voltage electronics mean that simple things like resistance have very little bearing on the quality and functionality of a plug wire. Unless you have some very elaborate equipment, you won't be able to evaluate plug wires in any meaningful way.

People still feel the need to pay big money for plug wires, for some reason.
 

R&C_RallySyTy

Little Big Man
Re: The "truth" about spark plug wires?

For about 15 years now, I've watched people buy every new plug wire that came down the pike. I've also tried most of the major ones myself.

None of them worked any better than the basic stuff.

I run Autolite or similar "cheap" plug wires. They last just as long and work just as well as the expensive ones.

One thing the magnecor page does tell like it is - the voodoo qualities of high voltage electronics mean that simple things like resistance have very little bearing on the quality and functionality of a plug wire. Unless you have some very elaborate equipment, you won't be able to evaluate plug wires in any meaningful way.

People still feel the need to pay big money for plug wires, for some reason.

I hope your right. What do you think about Nology wires though? Look those up and tell me what you think. I had some so called "experts" say they really do work the best and the conductors are awesome. I don't know what to think.
 

AUSyTyIN

Unbusted $#it box
Re: The "truth" about spark plug wires?

For about 15 years now, I've watched people buy every new plug wire that came down the pike. I've also tried most of the major ones myself.

None of them worked any better than the basic stuff.

I run Autolite or similar "cheap" plug wires. They last just as long and work just as well as the expensive ones.

One thing the magnecor page does tell like it is - the voodoo qualities of high voltage electronics mean that simple things like resistance have very little bearing on the quality and functionality of a plug wire. Unless you have some very elaborate equipment, you won't be able to evaluate plug wires in any meaningful way.

People still feel the need to pay big money for plug wires, for some reason.


+1 (but not quite for 15 years though)

I just buy the lifetime warranty wires at Autoblown :tup:
 

blk00z28

Forced to by choice
Re: The "truth" about spark plug wires?

The Buick 3.8 I helped build earlier this year that makes over 700rwhp on a very mild build started to have problems making more power over 5400 rpms. Watched the data logging and we thought the small valve springs that we put on the heads were floating the valves after that rpm. Replaced them, still did it. Thought a few sensors were giving it the problems. Replaced all of them. Still did it.. After about $400 on new parts chasing this problem, we finally said to try the plugs or wires. Changed from Taylor's back to stock plug wires(20 years old!) it cleared the problem right up. What kept us from hitting 9's at low boost will now let us hit mid 9's on mild boost.

Don't knock factory stuff sometimes. Had a similar problem with my ls1 with aftermatket wires, went back to stock and it cleared it up.

I think a lot of the problems come from the actual plug connector becoming lose from the wire. Its easy to pull them apart. I did it to 2 of mine on the truck last year and had to fix them. Its easy but a pain.
 

UR50SLO

V6+2=LSXCamaro
Re: The "truth" about spark plug wires?

It kind of comes down to getting the spark from A to B..... if that's not getting done no matter what it's made out of or who made it... it's not going to fire that plug right.

If the assembler of that wire isn't doing thier job at the factory or robot ..whatever.. your not going to have a good wire.

Finding the company that makes the most consistanty good connections at each end is the key.

I use the MSD 8.5's on my stuff. Buick and Ty's. Taylors are decent quality as are Magnacor.

I've not had luck with very cheap brands.

~Scott
 
Top