Knock issue

WyoSyclone

Active member
Re: Knock issue

After talking with my dad, he remembers him and Ivan from back in the day were hooking up some gauges and the ATR aux intercooler. This was in 1998. My dad has a log of all the updates since 1994. It seems that Ivan hooked up a 3 bar map sensor which I verified the part number today T'ing into the vacuum line going from the AFPR to the stock 2 bar map sensor. Reading on the Sytyarchives it seems this is not recommended and I am wondering why they used a 3-bar map sensor for the aux. boost gauge. My dad doesn't remember. After taking off some electrical tape I noticed one of the the 3-connectors was broken. I don't know if I broke it or it was like that. They used some push type electrical pins crimped onto the lines. Could this possible be some of my knock problems?

Still waiting to hear from Hood on a tune.

Thank You,

Unless the 3-bar was patched into the ECM it wouldn't make a difference on the logs; your boost gauge would read correctly but that wouldn't affect the DM/TPRT logs.
 

sytyguy

Moderated User
Re: Knock issue

Sean, sorry for the late reply. I'd be glad to burn you a 3bar chip. I can also add some more fuel up top, but with the ineffectiveness of the raised FP, it might be that a 3bar chip alone is enough to do the trick.

Do you have a spare chip you could send for reburn? If not, I could pull one from a spare truck and send to you, and if the tune is to your liking, just return your old one.
 

Sean Krupa

Moderator
Re: Knock issue

Sean, sorry for the late reply. I'd be glad to burn you a 3bar chip. I can also add some more fuel up top, but with the ineffectiveness of the raised FP, it might be that a 3bar chip alone is enough to do the trick.

Do you have a spare chip you could send for reburn? If not, I could pull one from a spare truck and send to you, and if the tune is to your liking, just return your old one.

Michael,

I sent you a PM.

Thank You,
 

Sean Krupa

Moderator
Re: Knock issue

Well the search continues. I got a custom burned 3bar chip from Hood. He added more fuel up top. The new chip didn't seem to help much if at all. The boost is still high even with the new chip. I unplugged the wastegate solenoid and it still hit 14-15.

3rd gear is still making knock worse. When it shifts to 3rd, the boost spikes to 16-17 and knock is really high. I can't amagine how much knock would be if I didn't have the 2 gallons of Xylene. I even tried going on the Highway to eliminate any drivetrain vibrations which didn't help much.

I'm really considering getting an Alky Kit from Hood, because I've tried everything. The Xylene really helped which shows that it's mostly an octane issue.

I will send the files from today to whoever wants to assist me.
 

Sean Krupa

Moderator
Re: Knock issue

Here is the run of the 3bar Hood Chip and WG Solenoid unplugged with Xylene. The boost is high, but I'm going to turn out the WG rod.

Rob (Wyosyclone), has been giving me some things to try. I retarded the timing some. I adjusted it so, the mark is on the 1st tooth on the left, the one next to 0*. I will let you guys know how it runs tomorrow with the retarded timing.

3barChip.jpg
 

Don W.

Stab it and steer it
Re: Knock issue

Here is the run of the 3bar Hood Chip and WG Solenoid unplugged with Xylene. The boost is high, but I'm going to turn out the WG rod.

Rob (Wyosyclone), has been giving me some things to try. I retarded the timing some. I adjusted it so, the mark is on the 1st tooth on the left, the one next to 0*. I will let you guys know how it runs tomorrow with the retarded timing.

3barChip.jpg

To the left? If you're talking about to the left looking down on the timing tab (Forget the damper in the pic) then that is advanced, You need to be where I have the paint line on the timing tab. If you want to retard timing from -0- then you need to go toward the large part of the tab, toward that goofy piece of tubing sticking out.

attachment.php
 

Davemc1963

93 Ty Owner
Re: Knock issue

Only a thought, but have you verified you have TRUE TDC on the balancer and the outer ring hasn't slipped. This will obviously make your investigations pretty difficult if you dont know true TDC. I know mine has! I'm still looking at which one to to buy to replace it with that wont bust the bank. being that I only turn 4500 rpm I dont think I need an SFI approved one though.
 

Sean Krupa

Moderator
Re: Knock issue

Thanks guys,

We did verify top dead center awhile ago. Looks like we went the wrong way with the dist. We turned it slightly counter clock wise looking from the top front of the dist. Will readjust today. I also need to find someplace that sells a longer fuel hose for my fuel pressure test gauge so I can verify that fuel pressure is rising with boost and then need to remove the hood so I can tape the gauge on the windshield. My Walbro was replaced in 2000 with 40,000 miles since the install.

Thank You,
 

Sean Krupa

Moderator
Re: Knock issue

The retarded timing helped a ton. My dad and I wanted to double check and verify TDC today with my piston stop even though we did a year or 2 ago and was OK. I don't really know how much we retarded it, being that we don't have a digital timing gun. Guna have to invest in one. Well, it was enough to make a huge difference. Here is where I retarded my timing to on the RED mark. (Don's pic)
TimingMark.jpg


Here is the DM Files from today. I turned out the WG Rod about 3 turns and the boost is still high even with the Solenoid unplugged. It might be cause of where Hood set the boost control to be, I believe 17psi boost control.

1st file is Light Throttle with 1/4 tank of 93 with Xylene still in their.
2nd file is Heavy Throttle with 1/2 tank of 93. Didn't got WOT.
3barLowWGRT.jpg


3barLowWGRT1.jpg


Where should I go from here? Should I retard the timing some more? Will Alky take care of the rest?
PS: This thread is one of the most viewed in this section, and only a hand full of people have came up with suggestions. Is it because alot of people have bad running trucks with Knock or people don't wana speak up?

Thanks to those who gave me suggestions and tips, it is greatly appreciated! Special thanks to Rob(Wyosyclone) for constantly looking at my files and giving me things to try.
 
Last edited:

Don W.

Stab it and steer it
Re: Knock issue

I drag race my truck -and- use meth. My timing is set between Sean's red mark and my white mark in the pic. I figure -2 maybe 3 on a known good damper. (Not the one in the pic.) Motor is very sensitive to how much meth I use, when I use it, meaning early or late in the run, and mostly how much boost, Seems every run is a test run but at this point I running 2-3* retard peaks then out of nowhere I'll see a 5* peak but the graph looks like a mountain peak very sharp rise and fall.

Sorry no DM's available, computer is in the truck at the shop. I'll try to get one up later. Can speak to only my truck but I'll tell you it's very sensitive to minor changes. IOW I'm still learning. Weather is going to be hot this Wed which will change everything, again. :roll:

Glad you're making some progress.
 

sytyguy

Moderated User
Re: Knock issue

Sean, really sorry that I'm late in getting to this thread. Very happy to hear that timing was the issue. Knowing that now, if you need a reburn to "undo" some of the changes we made in the chip to help cure some of the issues, just LMK. No charge. You may find it a bit fat up top, and I took some timing out up top as well, so getting that timing back and leaning out the mixture will really help WOT power. With the fueling in the chip, I'd run FP around 48 psi and adjust from there if it's too rich/lean.

But, like I said, a reburn is waiting for you if you feel the need.
 

Sean Krupa

Moderator
Re: Knock issue

What should I do now? I can keep retarding the timing, but I don't want to hurt performance. I noticed more peformance with the retarded timing because it reduced knock. Again, I don't really know how much I'm retarding the timing cause I don't have a digital timing light.

Hood, your saying that I already have more fuel up top from your chip. Rob is saying that I need more fuel up top starting around 3000rpm and 200kpa. What I really need is the boost to be lower to be more consistent. I'm thinking we should set it to 15psi boost control, and have the ability to turn it up if I ever to go the track without problems.

I'm wondering if ALKY would take care of the rest of the knock. I really don't want to keep sending chips back and forth. I know I can go Code59, which I'm really considering, but I'm really close to solving this. I want to get the right tune all at once. If I get ALKY I want to have the tune for that.

Thanks guys,
 

sytyguy

Moderated User
Re: Knock issue

What should I do now? I can keep retarding the timing, but I don't want to hurt performance. I noticed more peformance with the retarded timing because it reduced knock. Again, I don't really know how much I'm retarding the timing cause I don't have a digital timing light.

Hood, your saying that I already have more fuel up top from your chip. Rob is saying that I need more fuel up top starting around 3000rpm and 200kpa. What I really need is the boost to be lower to be more consistent. I'm thinking we should set it to 15psi boost control, and have the ability to turn it up if I ever to go the track without problems.

I'm wondering if ALKY would take care of the rest of the knock. I really don't want to keep sending chips back and forth. I know I can go Code59, which I'm really considering, but I'm really close to solving this. I want to get the right tune all at once. If I get ALKY I want to have the tune for that.

Thanks guys,
What should you do now?

Tune for yourself.

It's as simple as that. TunerPro/Code59 is so easy to slide into, that it's a no brainer. You'll have the ability to make changes for whatever you need, and can infinitely adjust for things like higher boost, race gas, alky, hot weather, cold weather, etc.... Sending chips back and forth is foolish when you have aspirations of higher boost or alky or whatever in the future or if you're trying to track down an issue you feel a proper tune would remedy (not band-aid).

Obviously, I'll be glad to help you out either way, but doing your own tuning will reap rewards FAR beyond what I could provide with reading DM logs and trying to guess what will work. A few keystrokes by you with an emulator and you'll KNOW what works. I added a considerable amount of fuel in boost with that tune, but if more fuel is needed, it's an easy change with an emulator.

But, you know I'll be glad to help however I can.
 

Sean Krupa

Moderator
Re: Knock issue

I retarded the timing some more (RED). The stock timing mark is about 1/2" to the right of the mark I have now. I assume that the dampner has slipped.
TimingMark1.jpg


Here are the Datamaster runs from today w/ WG Solenoid Unplugged. I'm very happy with the performance and how low the knock is. Do you guys think I can improve on this? Is their anything else I should do to get the knock lower? I'm thinking about running some Top End cleaner. I also have my Dutchty IC to install to keep the temps down. This thing keeps pulling and pulling. I usually tell my dad to let off the throttle when I see a large amount of knock, and today I didn't have to.

5-4-11Retarded.jpg

5-4-11Retarded1.jpg
 
Last edited:

It's just a six

Super Member
Re: Knock issue

Bump the timing down a bit more since your damper seems to have slipped & you are still getting knock.

Check your damper & see if you can turn it or you can make it move/wobble.

Maybe need to order new damper?

You still have Xylene in your tank?

What plugs are you running.? What heat range?
 

Sean Krupa

Moderator
Re: Knock issue

I will try retarding the timing some more. The Xylene is gone. I have NGK UR6 plugs gapped to .028.
 

Sean Krupa

Moderator
Re: Knock issue

Just a little update. I retarded the timing some more. I went just enough so that it doesn't die with the Tan wire disconnected. Didn't notice much of an improvement. So it looks like I've done all I can with the Timing.

Being that I turned out my WG rod about 4 turns, my boost is around 12-14psi 1st and 2nd gear with Solenoid plugged in. When it shifts to 3rd is when I get 16-17psi. What could be the reason why boost is going up in 3rd? I have boost control set to 17psi in the Chip and it only hits that in 3rd. Is it because I have the WG turned out? If I turn it in, won't it go higher in 1-2 and go alot higher in 3rd?

I think the next thing I'm going to try is some Top End Cleaner and verify that fuel pressure is rising with boost.

BTW: Since I retarded the timing a whole bunch, does that hurt WOT performance, cause a friend took a video of a DM run and it didn't seem to impressive. Maybe cause it only hits 12-14psi 1-2 gear.
5-9-11.jpg

5-9-111.jpg
 
Last edited:
Top